United beat Sheffield 3-1 behind closed doors today

Lash

Full Member
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
11,888
Location
Buckinghamshire
Supports
Millwall, Saint-Etienne
Hopefully Gomes showed Ole he needs to start getting Lingard's mins.
 

bdecuc

Full Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2011
Messages
901
Location
Ireland
I do agree that some posters really aren't critical enough of the youngsters. There's a difference between protecting the kids form unjust criticism, not being reactionary, and being too lenient from a talent perspective. People need to realize that it's really difficult to make the step up and that most will not make that step up. That is why when I discuss our young talents I always take that into account and have a higher standard for what it takes to truly make me believe they're good enough. I will get it wrong though as I wasn't a big fan of Michael Keane (compared to Tom Thorpe), and I also wasn't fond of McTominay just like I wasn't fond of Blackett. I've always thought you have to show that you're special at youth level to even have a chance. That's different to just being overly critical and bashing youngsters via social media or in person. You have to protect the kids from those over the top reactions.

However, I also believe that posters and myself have gotten better at assessing what it takes to make it at United over the years. We're more experienced after watching years and years of youth players, and getting to compare the levels of these players to past players.

I don't know who told you Chong is our most natural dribbler in ages. Ravel was a better dribbler. Chong shows glimpses of that type of dribbling to the point where he looks like George Best in elegance when he's speeding past players (probably due to body type, speed). Difference is that Ravel had way more consistency in technique, and Ravel obviously had more to his game. That's a big difference and that is why Chong's glimpses are only glimpses. I think the only reason why anyone would say Chong is our most natural dribbler in ages is due to playstyle. We've had a lot of technical players who could dribble, but they were more attacking midfielders and didn't play that traditional winger style. Gomes, Januzaj, Rashford, Gribbin, etc... all ran well with the ball, but they just don't play that traditional winger role.

We'll see where this lot ends up, but I'll give my rankings for different positions/roles of our players over the years based on their play at youth level

Striker: Greenwood > Wilson >? Rashford > Keane > Burkart > Henriquez > Fletcher
Utility attacker: Lingard > Mellor > Weir > Bohui > Willock
AM: Ravel > Gomes > Januzaj > Gribbin > Daehli >
DM/BoxtoBox: Garner > Pearson > Rothwell = TFM > McTominay > Tunnicliffe >? Charni (short stint) >? Grimshaw
CM: Pogba >? Gomes > Levitt >? Pereira > Puigmal (aggressive ranking) > Petrucci >? Larnell Cole > Goss
CB: Tuanzebe > Thorpe > O'Connor = TFM = Keane > Williams >Mcnair > Warren > Ercolani > Bernard > Veseli > Wootton
FB: Laird > O'Connor >? Williams > CBJ > Vermijl > Varela = Janko > Fryers > James > Love > Blackett > Olosunde > Sang > El Fitouri
Winger: Chong > Lawrence > Harrop > Mitchell (could be 2nd before the injury)

Excuse the groupings being muddled and some rankings are a little tougher because different players had different attributes over the other. Also some players started off in other groups like Rashford and Greenwood originally being attacking midfielders, but then went up top. Similarly, there are a couple whoUsually our attack has been the most talented so Daehli being ranked last still means he was really good and I'm still keeping up to date with him at St. Pauli.

Personally, I think our biggest talents in the last 10 years are Ravel, Gomes, Greenwood, Januzaj, Pogba, and I'm now including Garner as well. Laird is there with Rashford, Gribbin, Pereira, Tuanzebe, Chong, and Wilson. Could go up if he continues performing, but that 2nd group all had periods where they were stars of the youth team. Third group is probably Levitt, TFM, O'Connor, Williams, Daehli, Keanes, Thorpe, Lingard, and Pearson. Extremely gray lines between these groups.

My memory could be off on some fringe talent like Veseli and Wootton, so others might disagree with my list and I'm also missing some players as I want to watch them some more before I rank them.

So based on how I view players, I think this group fares really well to past squads. Probably the most talented since the 2011 fa youth cup winning group so it didn't surprise me that we did better in last season's uefa youth league, though we had some big omissions which led to our surprise defeat.
This is a good post. Thanks for taking the time. I agree there is too little understanding of the step up needed from the underage ranks to the first team. Only the exceptional generally make it.

I agree with a lot of your rankings. Only a couple of minor quibbles. Personally I'd have moved Wilson down the striker list a couple of places and moved Keane up one i.e. Greenwood > Rashford > Keane > Wilson etc. That's just personal view re Wilson relying so much on pace which gets more negated as you progress towards the first team while Keane had real ability I thought would transfer up.

I might have put TFM a bit higher also in the midfield list...

It's probably heresy to say it nowadays but I'm still not convinced by either Garner or Laird. Yes they're very good but are they special enough? Not sure yet personally.

Anyway for us fans, it's all just a little distraction and amusement. Mindful that they're all real young people trying to make the best of their talents and fair play to them.
 

Ramshock

CAF Pilib De Brún Translator
Joined
Nov 20, 2007
Messages
45,425
Location
Swimming against a tide of idiots and spoofers
These games are few and far between as the regular season schedule leaves no time for them. I think basically this time of the season is the only time you can do it before the cup comps start. They exist as there is really no reserve football anymore and this is the only way to do it without taking game time away from the kids in the U23's
 

Tony247

Full Member
Joined
May 2, 2018
Messages
9,486
Garner has a good potential I am saying ever since his debut. That kid needs to be given some playing time.
 

hubbuh

New Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2010
Messages
6,110
Location
UK, hun?
Ultimately Jones, Smalling, Welbeck, Morrison, Cleverley etc. will be remembered as failures. You can blame injuries, attitude or whatever but the reason for their shortcomings is simply that they weren't good enough.

The point is that the caf (and United fans in general) set themselves up for disappointment. Every 'talent' is supposed to be the next big thing. Even with the current bunch, Greenwood is apparently the next RVP, Garner is the next Carrick, Chong is the most natural dribbler we've had for ages, Gomes is the solution to our no. 10 problems. Yet these kids barely have any starts for the A team. In 2-3 years some of these will either be playing for worse teams or they'll stick around with the club and be given the Pereira treatment by the fans (massive hype 2-3 years ago, now pretty much considered irrelevant).
Er, I don't think that's limited to United fans, mate. Do you have many football following mates, mate? Every nob'ed likes to talk up their own team's talent, it's part of the bluster that comes with chatting shit about football.
 

Devil_forever

You're only young once, you can be immature f'ever
Joined
Apr 28, 2007
Messages
11,008
Location
Head of the naval division of lolibfascon
Why can’t united televise these games on MUTV? It would make me subscribe throughout the year if they organised enough of these games throughout the year. Host a few at old Trafford and make them free to season ticket holders? It’s far more appealing than your u23 games.
 

Bondi77

Full Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2019
Messages
7,203
I am a little surprised why Greenwood was not introduced into the game earlier the other night considering he was our best player on the pitch on his full debut and he had a good preseason.
I can see the reasoning behind keeping him on the bench if we are starting with Rashford and Martial as if one gets injured he can come on and not have to change gameplan but even then if we are in a tight game I would be bringing him on at the hour mark on the right as he offers a lot offensively.
 

limerickcitykid

There once was a kid from Toronto...
Joined
Oct 3, 2012
Messages
14,051
Location
East end / Oot and aboot
Why can’t united televise these games on MUTV? It would make me subscribe throughout the year if they organised enough of these games throughout the year. Host a few at old Trafford and make them free to season ticket holders? It’s far more appealing than your u23 games.
Defeats the whole purpose of behind closed doors then doesn't it?
 

::sonny::

Full Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2007
Messages
17,868
Location
Milan
They called it the golden era :lol:

Results from the best young player poll in 2011:

Jones 31.83
Smalling 14.33
De Gea 5.5
Welbeck 4.5
Morrison 3.83
Rafael 3.5
Cleverley 2.5
Fabio 1.5
Pogba 0.5
The class of 2011
 

lsd

The Oracle
Joined
Jun 5, 2016
Messages
10,784
6 out of that list had good careers.

They all had good careers . You get paid to travel round the world playing then that's a good career.
 
Last edited:

Walters_19_MuFc

Full Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2013
Messages
29,263
Location
Birmingham
As if we put out such a strong side. :lol:

Guessing we stuck to a 4231. Something like:

Greenwood
Gomes Sanchez Mata
Matic Pereira
Darmian Jones Smalling Dalot
Romero