Van Dijk revisited

TenonTen

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jan 16, 2022
Messages
861
Supports
Neutral
And he is nowhere near being the GOAT Defender, he has a chance to be the best of his time/maybe era and to be considered among the second tier of all time defenders.
But when it comes to the the best defender of alltime, he is clearly lacking in ball playing ability in comparison to his competition.
Just two names:
Beckenbauer
Baresi

Case closed.

(Seriously: Some posters need definitely a lesson in football history)
Van Dijk is lacking in ball playing ability? Wtf mate? He's amazing with the ball at his feet. Pings pinpoint 60 yards diagonals for fun. :lol:
 

Tavern in the town

New Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2022
Messages
1,532
I won’t pretend I’m old enough to watch football in the 90s but this century he’s taller, faster, stronger, more dominant in the air and better on the ball than any defender I’ve witnessed. All while playing 40 metres from his own goal for the team with the most attacking full backs in football.
 

IrishMcD

Full Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2017
Messages
1,077
Location
Ireland
Everyone has already mentioned who i was gonna say are the best I have ever seen (Baresi and Maldini, alongside others like Stam, Cannavaro, Nesta, etc) but I genuinely think, and this could be looking at it through green tinted glasses, if Paul McGrath didn't have the demons he had and hadn't knees made from biscuit, he would be in the conversation. His performance against Italy in Giants Stadium during USA 94 still ranks as one of the best individual performances I have ever seen. He made a young Phil Babb look potentially world class on occasions, THATS how good McGrath was.
 

Gio

★★★★★★★★
Joined
Jan 25, 2001
Messages
20,297
Location
Bonnie Scotland
Supports
Rangers
I don't feel that they are desperate, they are genuinely ignorant and think that the world start and end with themselves.
I think Owen's comments sum this up too. His argument is he cannot imagine anyone being any better. Therefore his GOAT is limited to who he has experienced in his lifetime and what has been in front of his face in the Premier League. That's such a narrow take on the history of the game and the many incredible centre-halves who came before him.
 

Tucholsky

Full Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
181
Location
Somewhere in Germany
Supports
VfB Stuttgart
Van Dijk is lacking in ball playing ability? Wtf mate? He's amazing with the ball at his feet. Pings pinpoint 60 yards diagonals for fun. :lol:
Yeah and long passes are the only measurement of ball playing ability? Then Boateng should also be considered among the all time greats, he could also do that.
How about short passes and creative interplay with teammates, and I am not even talking about dribbling ability and shooting technique.
Beckenbauer and Baresi are considered among the Top 5 (Top 20) of all time (not only defenders) because of that abilities. That is van Dijk's competition and he falls short.
 

Verward

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 11, 2021
Messages
121
I don't think this season he is at his best. He looks slow but he has very good game reading capability and that keeps him out of trouble most of the time (sign of very good players).
Everyone gave stick to TAA for 2nd goal but for 1st goal VDV was too slow and let Dia steal the ball easily.

I felt Matip is much better than VDV this season.
 

TenonTen

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jan 16, 2022
Messages
861
Supports
Neutral
Yeah and long passes are the only measurement of ball playing ability? Then Boateng should also be considered among the all time greats, he could also do that.
How about short passes and creative interplay with teammates, and I am not even talking about dribbling ability and shooting technique.
Beckenbauer and Baresi are considered among the Top 5 (Top 20) of all time (not only defenders) because of that abilities. That is van Dijk's competition and he falls short.
VVD is literally good at all those things.

He had some amazing dribbles and goals for Celtic too.

You would not find him misplacing short passes or giving away possession.

He's very technically gifted for a CB.
 

KeanoMagicHat

Full Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2019
Messages
3,941
Van Dijk has it all as a defender, look at the high line they are able to play, look at the football they play, look at the attacking football they play. Look at the shite football they played when he was out injured. The whole system stems from him. Try playing that way with Maguire instead. So you look at the pace, the physicality, the height, the passing, the leadership. It's everything you'd want from a centre back. Top 5 best central defenders this century I would say. Best ever, it's hard to look beyond the likes of Beckenbauer and Baresi, but Van Djik has that extra physicality on them both, if not the marauding runs into midfield and the creativity.
 

Hammondo

Full Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2015
Messages
6,664
I might be wrong but i don't think Rio was part of that record much. The only two consistent in that run were VDS and Vidic and Vidic was easily the best player in the league that season. That stupid game against Torres cost him the player of the year award I think.

Maldini has to go down the greatest of all time surely?
Evans was with vidic for that record if I remember correctly.
 

Trezeguet17

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Mar 12, 2019
Messages
307
Yeah and long passes are the only measurement of ball playing ability? Then Boateng should also be considered among the all time greats, he could also do that.
How about short passes and creative interplay with teammates, and I am not even talking about dribbling ability and shooting technique.
Beckenbauer and Baresi are considered among the Top 5 (Top 20) of all time (not only defenders) because of that abilities. That is van Dijk's competition and he falls short.
I'd argue he is a better 1 vs 1 defender than Baresi and Beckenbauer. He is also bigger, stronger and faster than them.
I am not saying he should be regarded higher than them, but when you say he can only get to the all time 2nd tier of defenders because of dribbling ability, shooting technique and ball playing ability, can we then really consider Messi, Pele or Maradona as GOATS because they then have to be also measured by tackles, clearances, interceptions and so on.
 

B20

HEY EVERYONE I IGNORE SOMEONE LOOK AT ME
Joined
Aug 23, 2003
Messages
27,548
Location
Disney Land
Supports
Liverpool
Nesta aside, I think he's the best centerback since Baresi.

Never seen a defender like him who actually has everything. Height, physique, technique, pace, positioning, anticipation, leadership.

We've had some great defenders in the past and he's easily our best ever.
 

B20

HEY EVERYONE I IGNORE SOMEONE LOOK AT ME
Joined
Aug 23, 2003
Messages
27,548
Location
Disney Land
Supports
Liverpool
Or Liverpool likely as Alan Hansen says "hi."
Hansen was top quality but if you think Liverpool fans rate him higher I reckon you're caught in anti-recency bias.

Virgil is just better. An incredibly special player.
 

Loon

:lol:
Joined
Aug 17, 2011
Messages
9,128
Location
No-Mark
Hansen was top quality but if you think Liverpool fans rate him higher I reckon you're caught in anti-recency bias.

Virgil is just better. An incredibly special player.
I've seen them both in the flesh. I'm not fussed what some of the Liverpool fans think.
 

KirkDuyt

Full Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2015
Messages
24,444
Location
Dutchland
Supports
Feyenoord
He's probably not even the best Dutch centre back of all time yet.
Who is our best center back in your opinion? I actually do think it's him. The pairing of Stam and Frank de Boer was better than Van Dijk and De Vrij or Van Dijk and De Ligt though in my opinion.

I don't especially like Van Dijk though, he comes across as artificially laid back to the point of arrogance.
 

The Corinthian

I will not take Mad Winger's name in vain
Joined
Dec 10, 2020
Messages
11,465
VvD has been bailed out by Alisson all season. GOAT defender? Give me a break.
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
65,354
Location
France
Who is our best center back in your opinion? I actually do think it's him. The pairing of Stam and Frank de Boer was better than Van Dijk and De Vrij or Van Dijk and De Ligt though in my opinion.

I don't especially like Van Dijk though, he comes across as artificially laid back to the point of arrogance.
Isn't he dutch?
 

Mike Smalling

Full Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
10,464
This is his third full season for Liverpool, when accounting for injuries right? Let's all calm down a bit with the GOAT talk.

He's really good, but I'm not seeing anything Rio, Vidic, Terry or Kompany didn't do over 7, 8 or 9 seasons with their clubs. He is also well short of each of their trophy hauls.
 

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,411
Location
Inside right
Nesta aside, I think he's the best centerback since Baresi.

Never seen a defender like him who actually has everything. Height, physique, technique, pace, positioning, anticipation, leadership.

We've had some great defenders in the past and he's easily our best ever.
Stop it. He has faced nobody to be mentioned with them.
 

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,411
Location
Inside right
I'd argue he is a better 1 vs 1 defender than Baresi and Beckenbauer. He is also bigger, stronger and faster than them.
I am not saying he should be regarded higher than them, but when you say he can only get to the all time 2nd tier of defenders because of dribbling ability, shooting technique and ball playing ability, can we then really consider Messi, Pele or Maradona as GOATS because they then have to be also measured by tackles, clearances, interceptions and so on.
You'd argue that based on his epic encounters with a host of elite forwards? It's not a good argument to make unless you know what others faced and how they were rated. Not names to throw out there casually.
 

sullydnl

Ross Kemp's caf ID
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
34,063
Obviously the best CB in the world right now and if you're talking about peak years then has an argument for being the best CB in PL history.

However, as someone said above, that peak is effectively just three full seasons at Liverpool thus far. As compared to someone like Ferdinand say, who was at United for something like 12 seasons in total? Think we have to see VVD last for several more seasons at Liverpool before we weigh up his overall impact and standing.

As for the greatest of all time, I'm not sure how you'd even weigh that up given how much the game has changed over the years. But however you do it, having VVD as the GOAT based on three seasons is madness.
 

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,411
Location
Inside right
Youre point is a fair one but he has faced Mbappe Haaland Messi Ronaldo Lewandowski Benzema Aguero Kane.
He's faced Kane this season, the same one he is being hailed as something outrageous and he might encounter Benzema in the final. Did he ever face Ronaldo whilst being considered this or that?

It's not the time to be hailing him as some god amongst men when not facing any monsters of the game.
 

Righteous Steps

Full Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2016
Messages
2,346
He's faced Kane this season, the same one he is being hailed as something outrageous and he might encounter Benzema in the final. Did he ever face Ronaldo whilst being considered this or that?

It's not the time to be hailing him as some god amongst men when not facing any monsters of the game.
He faced Ronaldo in the CL final, no? A Ronaldo much closer to his prime than now, Mbappe Neymar Lewandowski Haaland all close to their prime as well. VVD was already considered arguably the best CB in the league at Southampton in reality. I think people will always look back more fondly on past eras naturally when judging players anyways.

VVD isn’t the GOAT, but after Nesta he is in the conversation alongside Ferdinand as the best CB of the last couple decades just based on characteristics alone, many great defenders of the past have weaknesses he simply doesn’t have in his game. He is like McGrath without the mental health and drinking issues.
 

Gio

★★★★★★★★
Joined
Jan 25, 2001
Messages
20,297
Location
Bonnie Scotland
Supports
Rangers
I'd say he's drawn alongside Rio as the best defender the Premier League has seen. Modern defenders are so divisive but personally post Nesta/Rio it's only really Thiago Silva who matches him, although I think there's a case for Godin for his massive influence as a completely different type of defender with Atletico.
 

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,411
Location
Inside right
He faced Ronaldo in the CL final, no? A Ronaldo much closer to his prime than now, Mbappe Neymar Lewandowski Haaland all close to their prime as well. VVD was already considered arguably the best CB in the league at Southampton in reality. I think people will always look back more fondly on past eras naturally when judging players anyways.
The assessment goes by how he did against them, which is what has defenders hailed - who you go up against, what their level is and how you handle that/them is what sets the tone with everything else falling into place, as it should. In a season where he has faced 'no one' it makes little sense for him to be even discussed in any conversation about the greatest of all time. I think the best example of such a CB's repute going through the roof (well being put in an extension in said roof) was when an aged Nesta came up against a monstrous Messi and was immaculate. That's the kind of elevation I am referring to.

I think any top player doing truly special things is held up to the same esteem as anyone who has gone before them; it's not nostalgia, and if anything, these legends of the past are being summarily downplayed as time goes by.
VVD isn’t the GOAT, but after Nesta he is in the conversation alongside Ferdinand as the best CB of the last couple decades just based on characteristics alone, many great defenders of the past have weaknesses he simply doesn’t have in his game. He is like McGrath without the mental health and drinking issues.
He has the attributes, does he have the body of work? Playing a high line and doing well is great and all, but it's essentially against a bunch of nobodies, which adds perspective as he's not containing prime versions of truly elite forwards whilst doing so, which would be heralded in a completely different light.
 

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,411
Location
Inside right
I'd say he's drawn alongside Rio as the best defender the Premier League has seen. Modern defenders are so divisive but personally post Nesta/Rio it's only really Thiago Silva who matches him, although I think there's a case for Godin for his massive influence as a completely different type of defender with Atletico.
I'm not against this view, as his attributes certainly put him on par with Rio, in fact, above him for the aerial prowess, but Rio's body of work, and against who he did it, easily surpasses VVD's, which is where the great divide is between them at the moment.

Still, I'd have no issue with him being in the PL all time xi next to your man.
 

padzilla

Hipster
Joined
Oct 31, 2005
Messages
3,329
There's definitely a lack of great strikers about these days compared to previous years but you can't really hold that against Van Dijk and there's still plenty more football for him to play over the years.
 

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,411
Location
Inside right
There's definitely a lack of great strikers about these days compared to previous years but you can't really hold that against Van Dijk and there's still plenty more football for him to play over the years.
You have to in such a discussion where those he's up against those who walked the walk against some of the greatest players to have played the game. As I said in my first post, it's never an athletes' fault when they are in a weak era, but it doesn't matter in the grand scheme when up against those who weren't. If he doesn't have names on his resume, his body of work will have to be stratospheric.
 

Tavern in the town

New Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2022
Messages
1,532
I'm not against this view, as his attributes certainly put him on par with Rio, in fact, above him for the aerial prowess, but Rio's body of work, and against who he did it, easily surpasses VVD's, which is where the great divide is between them at the moment.

Still, I'd have no issue with him being in the PL all time xi next to your man.
It’s true that he hasn’t faced the quality of strikers previous generations faced, but it’s swings and roundabouts. Defenders from older eras didn’t have to deal with wide forwards who made diagonal runs all game. The best strikers today play wide.
 

Righteous Steps

Full Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2016
Messages
2,346
The assessment goes by how he did against them, which is what has defenders hailed - who you go up against, what their level is and how you handle that/them is what sets the tone with everything else falling into place, as it should. In a season where he has faced 'no one' it makes little sense for him to be even discussed in any conversation about the greatest of all time. I think the best example of such a CB's repute going through the roof (well being put in an extension in said roof) was when an aged Nesta came up against a monstrous Messi and was immaculate. That's the kind of elevation I am referring to.

I think any top player doing truly special things is held up to the same esteem as anyone who has gone before them; it's not nostalgia, and if anything, these legends of the past are being summarily downplayed as time goes by.

He has the attributes, does he have the body of work? Playing a high line and doing well is great and all, but it's essentially against a bunch of nobodies, which adds perspective as he's not containing prime versions of truly elite forwards whilst doing so, which would be heralded in a completely different light.
He’s had good performances against all those players I named though that’s the point, Ronaldo Mbappe Haaland Aguero Kane etc.
 

Gio

★★★★★★★★
Joined
Jan 25, 2001
Messages
20,297
Location
Bonnie Scotland
Supports
Rangers
I'm not against this view, as his attributes certainly put him on par with Rio, in fact, above him for the aerial prowess, but Rio's body of work, and against who he did it, easily surpasses VVD's, which is where the great divide is between them at the moment.

Still, I'd have no issue with him being in the PL all time xi next to your man.
Certainly the acid test for any defender who wants to be considered amongst the best of all time is how they have fared against the absolute best. I take your point about the calibre of what Rio and Van Dijk have faced, although I don't think the margin between @Righteous Steps list and what Rio has bossed in his time is that wide. The best attackers in the world around 2004-2008 would be Henry, Shevchenko, Kaka, Drogba, Eto'o, Torres and Villa. Arguably they're a bit better than what Van Dijk has faced, but equally Rio didn't always come out of those encounters covered in glory either.

Of course earlier in his career he faced Real's Galacticos which included post-injury Ronaldo and didn't really handle them, so I don't think that works in his favour. He helped shut down Rijkaard's Barcelona in 07/08 with a very impressive display, but a central Messi scored winners against him in 2009 and 2011. While over the course of his career he's played against many of the greats, I don't think he's dominated the best forwards of his generation any more than Van Dijk has in his. While rating Rio very highly, I think - like Van Dijk - his CV is not quite as strong as Baresi, Nesta, Scirea, Figueroa, etc in shutting out the greatest of all time.
 

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,411
Location
Inside right
He’s had good performances against all those players I named though that’s the point, Ronaldo Mbappe Haaland Aguero Kane etc.
Is good the same as epic, because that's what I'm referring to. Contests for the ages he will be remembered by? Not just games he was part of, but games where he shone against the best.

The issue with him isn't doubt that could happen, it's that it has happened for others and it is more the reason why they are regarded as they are before other feats of theirs are even brought to the table. Their names were effectively made off the back of who they matched up against and how they performed in those contests. Baresi is seen as the best organiser of a backline there's ever been, but that doesn't trump what he did in one on one contests, and it's a running theme for this level of CB seen as the best of all time.

Kohler is another one whose name is made off of what he did against the very best. Even if VVD has superior attributes, he's done nothing to be ranked above him because the former was a monster when up against the elite.
 

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,411
Location
Inside right
Certainly the acid test for any defender who wants to be considered amongst the best of all time is how they have fared against the absolute best. I take your point about the calibre of what Rio and Van Dijk have faced, although I don't think the margin between @Righteous Steps list and what Rio has bossed in his time is that wide. The best attackers in the world around 2004-2008 would be Henry, Shevchenko, Kaka, Drogba, Eto'o, Torres and Villa. Arguably they're a bit better than what Van Dijk has faced, but equally Rio didn't always come out of those encounters covered in glory either.

Of course earlier in his career he faced Real's Galacticos which included post-injury Ronaldo and didn't really handle them, so I don't think that works in his favour. He helped shut down Rijkaard's Barcelona in 07/08 with a very impressive display, but a central Messi scored winners against him in 2009 and 2011. While over the course of his career he's played against many of the greats, I don't think he's dominated the best forwards of his generation any more than Van Dijk has in his. While rating Rio very highly, I think - like Van Dijk - his CV is not quite as strong as Baresi, Nesta, Scirea, Figueroa, etc in shutting out the greatest of all time.
But it's still superior to VVD's, and he has clean sheet records and CL records on top of that, which is the point here, really. As I said previously, in terms of raw attributes, VVD even has Rio beat and may well be the archetype what is optimal, but his body of work is still lacking.

VVD coming through in a time of less [brilliance], has to do more to offset that, if he's going to be thrown into the loftiest of discussions. He also has nothing at the international level, which is another mark against him.