Greenwood
Rashford
McTominay
Williams
Garner
The rest can go, for obscene money obviously.
Rashford
McTominay
Williams
Garner
The rest can go, for obscene money obviously.
What players in the team will you absolutely not sell no matter the price?
- Thread starter jamesjimmybyrondean
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran hold a long overdue conversation about United's awful league form with 1 win in 7. They discuss a disappointing draw at Bournemouth, a not so disappointing draw against Liverpool and a crushing defeat at Chelsea - Is time nearly over for Erik Ten Hag?
Then in a special second half of the pod, Nik welcomes Natalie ( https://twitter.com/natalie_17) to discuss the fortunes of Manchester United Women as they booked a place in the FA Cup Final after a historic first ever win vs. Chelsea.
The only obvious choice is Rashford. But then again I never imagined Becks would leave the club. And Pogba is leaving sooner or later.
Even with our goalkeeping options I absolutely do not want us to sell Dean Henderson
Rashford. He looks like a complete forward already, has made the left wing position his own, and looks on his way to becoming a club legend and an all-timer. Don't see any reason to consider selling him unless for a ridiculous price, but I would still think twice.
None. They can all be replaced (with the exception of PP). We are 5th on the table not 1st
To be honest, I think it would be a bad mistake to sell any of our top line players at the moment (I realise the OP is Of course just taking us on a sort of fun exercise).
But It’s been so great lately to see the team playing as a team, developing a chemistry that is genuinely exciting and has me, at least, beginning to contemplate the possibility of a return to the winning of trophies. This may just have the makings of a great Utd team. To regard these players as merely replaceable units in a machine- well, I just don’t see it that way.
Lingard apart, though I feel a bit mean even singling him out, I don’t want to sell any of them.
I'm just playing along because i'm as bored as everybody else, and i've gone to keep those that didn't only cost the club a penny, the rest would be off at the drop of a hat if somebody offered to give them a serious increase in wages whilst the Academy Grads would almost certainly show more loyalty.
If Real Madrid offered £250m for Pogba and Martial today would you not accept it knowing with that money plus any in the warchest we could recruit from the very top-table the LB, DLP, RW, and CF we need to compete at the very top-level again?
Wrong question I think. I would re-phrase it as Sandcastle would like to pay 100m for any of our 1st team players, who would you like to cash in first. And who would you say make it 150m and we will talk.
I would say Pogba is on top of my cash in list at any price. Greenwood, Henderson, Rashford, McTom are out entirely because we need our Academy list.
I would say Pogba is on top of my cash in list at any price. Greenwood, Henderson, Rashford, McTom are out entirely because we need our Academy list.
Rashford
Greenwood
McT
Bruno
But in general I am a reluctant to sell, reluctant to buy kind of fan. I prefer to see continuity in the squad wherever possible, especially with home-grown players and players who have really settled in and become fixtures. I still haven't totally got over the fact we let Herrera go, for example. The only players I would be happy to see go at any price are the ones I want us to shift out, namely:
Sanchez
Jones
Rojo
Lingard
Pereira
Greenwood
McT
Bruno
But in general I am a reluctant to sell, reluctant to buy kind of fan. I prefer to see continuity in the squad wherever possible, especially with home-grown players and players who have really settled in and become fixtures. I still haven't totally got over the fact we let Herrera go, for example. The only players I would be happy to see go at any price are the ones I want us to shift out, namely:
Sanchez
Jones
Rojo
Lingard
Pereira
Rashford
Bruno
Greenwood
Bruno
Greenwood
From the looks of things being a young local lad can go a long way at Utd, maybe even net you a whole career (see Lingard).
It doesn't make sense to say someone like Scott can't be sold at any price. No matter how much I like him, he's easily replaceable and upgradable. The only of our players who don't qualify for that criteria, in my opinion, are Rashford and Pogba. Maybe AWB and Martial at a stretch. The rest still have a lot to prove.
As we've seen before, breaking through the academy shouldn't be seen as a surefire guarantee of anything.
It doesn't make sense to say someone like Scott can't be sold at any price. No matter how much I like him, he's easily replaceable and upgradable. The only of our players who don't qualify for that criteria, in my opinion, are Rashford and Pogba. Maybe AWB and Martial at a stretch. The rest still have a lot to prove.
As we've seen before, breaking through the academy shouldn't be seen as a surefire guarantee of anything.
I'd sell everyone for a 'certain price' because we dont have a single world's best player in a single best position.
We could sell one potentially to get a better one player as a result
We could sell one potentially to get a better one player as a result
Well, I can see the attraction, but personally I’d hate to sell Pogba or Martial- though with Paul, as somebody else observed above, it depends on whether he wants to be here. If he doesn’t, then yeh id let him go for big bucks. Hope he doesn’t though- I really like this team now, although I know we’ve had a lot of false dawns.
This time I think it’s different- they seem to enjoy playing together. I’ll probably be proved hopelessly wrong! Such optimism isn’t really a characteristic of mine...
Messi
The boring answer but the correct one.
You can't sell a club icon.
The boring answer but the correct one.
You can't sell a club icon.
Wan-Bissaka
McTominay
Fernandes
Rashford
Martial
Greenwood
I'd never sell any of those above players for any price.
Pogba
Fred
I would sell these two if a great offer came in. eg. 120M pounds for Pogba, 80M pounds for Fred.
Sanchez
Rojo
Jones
Lingard
Pereira
These guys are the ones that I would actively try to sell/offload.
McTominay
Fernandes
Rashford
Martial
Greenwood
I'd never sell any of those above players for any price.
Pogba
Fred
I would sell these two if a great offer came in. eg. 120M pounds for Pogba, 80M pounds for Fred.
Sanchez
Rojo
Jones
Lingard
Pereira
These guys are the ones that I would actively try to sell/offload.
What, not even for £375m each?
Name one other player capable of this?
Would not sell.
Well, to be brutally honest... we are 5th, the season has been a huge letdown and we are fighting with Sheffield United and Wolves, not City or Pool. So yeah, most of these players have a price. I’m a firm beliver in class breeding class, so we need to keep DDG, especially Pogba and Rashford. And of course Fernandes, but he could be replaced if we got a ton of money. Everyone else is very replaceable in the market if we get a ton of cash. Now I do believe our squad is better than what we are doing this year, but with the manager in charge it’s not a big surprise that we are struggling as much as we do.
This. But wouldn’t you include Bruno just after the start he’s had?
Rashford, Greenwood, Fernandes, McTominay, Maguire, Wan-Bissaka and Fred for me are the only ones that are unsellable and if Pogba was to sign a new contract then settle down so putting in consistent performances to the level we know he can then I’d put him in the bracket too.
De Gea
Rashford
Martial
Bruno
AWB
Rashford
Martial
Bruno
AWB
Dean Henderson
Maguire
Wan Bissaka
Bruno
Rashford
Greenwood
I`d ideally keep Pogba, McTominay and De Gea but if good offers came for them I`d sell. Everyone else is easily dispensable.
Maguire
Wan Bissaka
Bruno
Rashford
Greenwood
I`d ideally keep Pogba, McTominay and De Gea but if good offers came for them I`d sell. Everyone else is easily dispensable.
As for the time being:
Should keep at all Costa:
Rashford
Greenwood
Bruno
Maguire
Sell only if a bid thats too good to refuse:
Shaw
AWB
Scott
Fred
Pogba
De Gea
Should consider selling if a decent bid came in:
Martial
Lindeløf
Mata
Smalling
Should sell at any price:
Andreas
Rojo
Bailly
Lingard
Should keep at all Costa:
Rashford
Greenwood
Bruno
Maguire
Sell only if a bid thats too good to refuse:
Shaw
AWB
Scott
Fred
Pogba
De Gea
Should consider selling if a decent bid came in:
Martial
Lindeløf
Mata
Smalling
Should sell at any price:
Andreas
Rojo
Bailly
Lingard
Have I missed something? The amount of Bruno admissions in here are absurd.
Mine would be;
Bruno
Rashford
Greenwood.
Mine would be;
Bruno
Rashford
Greenwood.
literally every single player has their price. Especially of they want to go. Rashford and Greenwood are the two Id least like to sell but 150 plus and Id think about it
Rashford
Bruno
Greenwood
Maguire
AWB
McTomminay
Fred
Pogba
Bruno
Greenwood
Maguire
AWB
McTomminay
Fred
Pogba
Rashford and Greenwood.
McTominay is the kind of player we've missed in the squad for ages. I wouldn't sell him. That kind of player is key to success in my opinion.
Haland is at 50m buyout clause.
But we sure as hell wont sell greenwood for 200m.
Caflogic
But we sure as hell wont sell greenwood for 200m.
Caflogic
Rashford
Greenwood
Bruno
Greenwood
Bruno
Absolutely not sell no matter the price ? I would use that concept only for Pelé and Ronaldinho in their primes.
As others have said, none.
But based from this season, for the next season, wouldn't sell these at all even at reasonable high prices (unless astronomical high):
But based from this season, for the next season, wouldn't sell these at all even at reasonable high prices (unless astronomical high):
- Bruno
- Martial
- Rashford
- McTominay
- Fred
- Maguire
- AWB
- Greenwood
- James
- Williams
- Romero
- Shaw
- Tuanzebe
- Lindelof
There's more to football than just price tags. It's a daft straw man anyway; in what world is anyone offering us £200m for Greenwood?
It's the op criteria. No matter what the price.
Forget 200m. A straight swap with halaand will seal the deal.
Bruno.
Greenwood.
That's all I'd definitely not want to part with under any circumstances. Martial I think we could improve on and Rashford too.
Greenwood.
That's all I'd definitely not want to part with under any circumstances. Martial I think we could improve on and Rashford too.
Rashford and Greenwood. If Pogba wanted to stay he'd be on that list too.
3 potentially top tier players all from the same academy is incredibly rare, even more rare is them all being quality attackers. The fact that we've got 2 players as good as Rashford and Greenwood for essentially nothing is something we should be very proud of. They were both developed entirely by United from when they were youngsters to the day they made their debuts and no-one can take that away from us.
3 potentially top tier players all from the same academy is incredibly rare, even more rare is them all being quality attackers. The fact that we've got 2 players as good as Rashford and Greenwood for essentially nothing is something we should be very proud of. They were both developed entirely by United from when they were youngsters to the day they made their debuts and no-one can take that away from us.
Some people watch football all their lives, know what this football club is all about and still don’t get it. Mental, indeed.
That depends is they’re replaceable even for a ridiculous fee. We could sell Fred or McTominay for £80m for example but who could we get in to replace? Bear in mind Fred took a while to settle in and is now finally looking class, and McT has the potential to be a complete midfielder.
All of them, unless their replacement is better 
But I definitely wouldnt be happy to see Rashford, Pogba(unless he really doesn’t want to be here), Bruno, Fred, or Greenwood leave any time soon.
But I definitely wouldnt be happy to see Rashford, Pogba(unless he really doesn’t want to be here), Bruno, Fred, or Greenwood leave any time soon.