Who is our most important player?

[DWelbz19]

Maguire.

 

[Andycoleno9]

Pogba, Bruno and Maguire. In random order.
Shaw and Cavani close to them. Undecided on Rashford.

If i must choose one then........i want to say Pogba and based on ability it should be Pogba but it is Bruno.

 

[Maticmaker]

The most important player?
Usually I would say its your 'match winner' i.e the one who on their own you can rely on to win you the game, when things were going 'tits up'.
We've had a few over the years, but just recently I would say;

David De Gea, has won us games from the position of keeper (e.g.Spurs away a couple of seasons back!)
Rashford's 'lone-striker' goals, important pen's (PSG away) (perhaps why Southgate took a 'punt' with him against Italy?)
Greenwood's (come on as sub) and score winner, goals.
Bruno's penalties, delicate chips and passes to set others in
Pogba's defence splitting( 60yrds+) pin point passes (as well as the odd well timed goal)
Cavani's ( 'dart- across-the-box)'goals;

but for me its Maguire, when hes not playing, nine times out of ten, then neither are we!

 

[Adam_TFS]

Has to be Maguire. He is the leader and captain for a reason. He organises and motivates players when their heads drop in a way no one else in the team does. Football, IMO, is 70% mental, 30% skill and no one handles the mental side as well as our skipper.

 

[Nytram Shakes]

Fernandes by a million miles. I think people are forgetting just how much we struggled creatively before he joined.

 

[norm87cro]

I'm happy England did well and that both Maguire and Shaw stepped up this summer but judging on his UNITED form last season and his instant contribution it is without a shadow of a doubt Fernandes. This could change next season offcourse.

 

[Juanuzayne]

Maguire
Pogba
Bruno
Shaw
Cavani

Before 2021, I would have had Bruno at the top as he had a sensational 2020 and was holding the whole team together himself. But his form took a dive this year. Let’s see how he starts this season. Pogba was far more influential in our attack when he came back from his hamstring injury.

 

[Gandalf]

Maguire or Dan James

 

[Dirty Schwein]

Bruno, Maguire and Shaw.

Everyone else is interchangeable.

 

[Amadaeus]

Tier 1:
Maguire, Bruno, Shaw, and Pogba depending on form, fitness, mental health, etc.

Tier 2:
Rashford, Sancho, Cavani, AWB, and Greenwood. Expecting Sancho, Rashford and maybe Greenwood to go to tier 1 this season. ,

Tier 3
Mctominay, Fred, linderlof, De Gea, Diallo, Martial, and Henderson. I expect we will see multiple players from this tier, enter tier 2.

Tier 4

rest

 

[tentan]

1. Varane
2. Sancho
3.