You laugh but isn't that the one criticism that hurts him the most?
It definitely is, but then again, i think if that's the caveat, any/all managers would have such a question mark over them.
I think a lot of posters also act as if he walked into an all-conquering Barca side, when in fact he had a lot to do with their dominance.
Would Messi have been Messi without Pep? Xavi, Iniesta? Most likely, but fact remains they were not the all world conquering - one of the GOAT teams when he stepped in. A more balanced view is required there. It's like discrediting SAF for the CO'92.
Either way, I'm not a die hard Pep fan (how could I be when I grew up worshipping SAF
) and I actually really, really rate Klopp up there, but Pep (and depending on what Klopp does next) will go down as one of the GOAT managers, IMO. He'll have question marks about him, no doubt. But I think that's part of the parcel and why no one player/manager ever goes down as the undisputed GOAT, barring some exceptional cases.