A side with Rashford and Sancho in the lineup has to compete for the title. Not sure if that’s better than City or Liverpool but definitely competing worthy.
With Sancho & Camavinga in, do we soon surpass Liverpool & City's squad?
- Thread starter luke511
- Start date
Agree with this, not just Rashford and Sancho, we are looking at a very good spine.
DDG, Maguire, AWB, Pogba, Bruno, Rashford, Sancho. A team consisting with these many quality players has to compete with the very best.
I know alot of people have their doubts, but even this season we have hardly seen our best 11 on the pitch together very long.
With the additions of Bruno and potentially Sancho if we can get them to play 30/38 games together then there is a good chance we compete.
Just Sancho & Camavinga — no way. But with Mejbri coming through as well... 
Still no
Still noCompared to their squads, James isn't a very good backup to the level of Mahrez and Sane on the wings. So in comparison our squad will not surpass theirs.
Is this under the assumption that Liverpool will sign Werner, etc... or that Liverpool and Man City's squads will stay exactly the same for next season?
City wing options: Sterling, Mahrez, Sane, B. Silva
Potential Utd wing options: Rashford, Sancho, Martial, Greenwood, James
We'd be good on the back up front.
Yeah we've been outcoached every time we've played both...
City's squad looks better overall and Klopp has figured out alchemy in midfield and their front 3, fullbacks and Van Dijk + Allison are all fantastic.
I don't see why next year won't be City and Liverpool in a great title race and then United, Chelsea, Leicester and Spurs fighting for the 3rd and 4th spots and probably one team joins them by outperforming expectations like Arsenal, Wolves or Everton getting hot for a couple months.
I don't see why next year won't be City and Liverpool in a great title race and then United, Chelsea, Leicester and Spurs fighting for the 3rd and 4th spots and probably one team joins them by outperforming expectations like Arsenal, Wolves or Everton getting hot for a couple months.
Maybe you miss understand the concept of having a batter squad.
2 of our wing options are actually strikers (Martial starting and Greenwood)
Then James is a big drop in quality.
Vs Citys list of 4 quality wingers. We have depth but its not as good a squad as Citys
Thats fineHaha, I still have a bit of faith for Baillyfor his age he's played about half the amount of professional games he should have, he's still got a lot of potential as a CB, with time/experience he has a chance to be starting for us. But yeah I don't think we'll be after a CB this summer so the choice is Bailly or Lindelof, I prefer Bailly personally.
I dont see it at all myself, but still a nice thought. And I hope you are correct and im wrong.I just think there's to much flaws in his game.
Camavinga?
Who on Earth has seen that lad play more than five times?
Who on Earth has seen that lad play more than five times?
Wilshere, Fabregas, Gerrard (although he was trash), Oxtail Chambermaid I think, possibly Barkley if Everton count?
It is going to be Matic and Sanchez next season,
Get excited about that!
Get excited about that!
Now more than ever I disagree with the Champions League issue. He’s not going to determine the next fifteen years of a career at United on whether we have specifically CL next season.
Further, do we even know if there’s going to be a Champions League next season and what it’d look like.
Does it make that much difference playing behind closed doors in CL or EL?
Short answer to OP, no.
Long answer, maybe in time when we've had more experience long term we will absolutely be better, but immediately absolutely not. Sancho will definitely provide a spark right now though
Long answer, maybe in time when we've had more experience long term we will absolutely be better, but immediately absolutely not. Sancho will definitely provide a spark right now though
Sancho
Camavinga or Partey
Ighalo
Upamenco or Konate
Then id say were closing the gap alot, but thats 4 signings away. With the current situation we arnt signing all the above, 3 at a push but id be very suprised with 4.
Id honestly be happy with Sancho and Ighalo, and then Dm, Cb the next summer, but if we can get rid of some through sales that third signing may happen.
Camavinga or Partey
Ighalo
Upamenco or Konate
Then id say were closing the gap alot, but thats 4 signings away. With the current situation we arnt signing all the above, 3 at a push but id be very suprised with 4.
Id honestly be happy with Sancho and Ighalo, and then Dm, Cb the next summer, but if we can get rid of some through sales that third signing may happen.
Maybe its the cabin fever thats got me in such a negative head space, but i cant see us signing anyone, i think this i going to get a lot more messy before it gets better. Spoke to a doctor friend of mine today who is connected with one of the big clubs, (I know how ITK that sounds and I genuinely wasnt even going to post this, but feck it, it genuinely what she told me today) and she says they are preparing for the likelihood that next season will be played behind closed doors. If thats the case, surely there will be no signings made by anyone, other than maybe Newcastle, City and maybe a few swap deals? Sorry, I realize i sound like a doom and gloom merchant. Apologies.
Its hard to stay positive when all the media and experts paint a negative picture, for me the number of deaths is coming down rapidly, were almost 200 deaths down from this time last week, and i dont speak of those numbers lightly. A couple more weeks and we may be down to double figures.
Il throw this out there, alot of people at my workplace where ill with the exact symptoms just before christmas, ive recently seen a report that in France a blood sample taken showed somebody had it there im december, maybe alot of people have already had it, dealt with the illness and recovered not knowing it was coronavirus. Im pretty convinced this will come to light, and the country wont have to be scared into a lockdown in various forms lasting years
Squad? Overall.. No.
We have better midfield depth than Pool and better gk department than City. That's it.
First 11? No.
That said, we can beat both teams in one-on-one matches, but not winning league.
We have better midfield depth than Pool and better gk department than City. That's it.
First 11? No.
That said, we can beat both teams in one-on-one matches, but not winning league.
Based on?
...
He would start over Matic.
Camavinga being a better footballer currently. That doesn't take anything away from Matic playing well for us since Feburary. It is a position we're looking to strengthen.
No 17 year old is joining United and starting week in week out
I haven't said otherwise. I've only said Camavinga would strengthen our team.
You laughed at someone and said he would start over Matic. He wouldn't
Thats not me saying he'd be starting week in week out, which he's managed fine doing for Rennes, but I'd choose him over Matic in a starting line up.
A think you are right to be optimistic Luke despite the reaction here. Football can move very fast and it is clear that Ole is rebuilding the squad in both quality and mentality. With the continued evolution of Rashford and Martial plus the addition of Pogba and Fernades that is some serious ability. Now if we can add someone like Sancho into the mix then we are laughing and our potential becomes very high. People forget that just a couple of seasons ago Liverpool had a worse squad, poor prospects, and few ideas and yet with a clear direction they have made dramatic strides. We could very well do the same and I think we are on the brink of something special emerging.
Liverpool and City have players who have consistent output and you know what you're going to get a bare minimum throughout a campaign.
The same cannot be said of Rashford, Martial, James, Sancho, Bruno, Greenwood, Ighalo because they need to take another step or two higher in terms of consistency and having a higher floor.
We all saw this increase in potential and consistency when it came together for Ronaldo and Wazza, but then they were supplemented by such a good squad with some class sprinkled in. Even though United lost the CL tie against AC Milan in 06/07, you really felt and saw that they turned a corner and it was amazing to see them turn that final corner and they took no hostages after that.
This set of players plus a potential Sancho and whoever have to earn that right of passage before our eyes before we can say they are able to surpass the clubs ahead of us.
The same cannot be said of Rashford, Martial, James, Sancho, Bruno, Greenwood, Ighalo because they need to take another step or two higher in terms of consistency and having a higher floor.
We all saw this increase in potential and consistency when it came together for Ronaldo and Wazza, but then they were supplemented by such a good squad with some class sprinkled in. Even though United lost the CL tie against AC Milan in 06/07, you really felt and saw that they turned a corner and it was amazing to see them turn that final corner and they took no hostages after that.
This set of players plus a potential Sancho and whoever have to earn that right of passage before our eyes before we can say they are able to surpass the clubs ahead of us.
Eerrm no. We're miles off.
100% agree. Should have left it at that.
Are you suggesting that we're two youngsters away from potentially reaching 100+ points?
No.
No.
Call me cray but with the additons Ole has made in the summer and with Bruno, I would say we have arguably have the best squad in the league.
I'm talking about the general squad depth, the players' physical, technical abilities and overall upside potential.
The problem and this a big one is that no manager before been able to get the best out of them in a consistent manner.
In a blank state, with the right coach, you could play any style of football with this team and not really worry about not having the right players. Possession, out of defence, low block, high press, counter attacking etc or more devestatingly, a perfect mix of all, which is exactly Fergie's way of playing.
I'm talking about the general squad depth, the players' physical, technical abilities and overall upside potential.
The problem and this a big one is that no manager before been able to get the best out of them in a consistent manner.
In a blank state, with the right coach, you could play any style of football with this team and not really worry about not having the right players. Possession, out of defence, low block, high press, counter attacking etc or more devestatingly, a perfect mix of all, which is exactly Fergie's way of playing.
No, obviously not. Great squads are constructed not purchased.
Also, this.
Nah, we're miles off at the moment, a couple of decent signings just gets us a bit closer - assuming they even work out
Isn't that lad like 17 too? Doubt he's improving us that much for a good while
Isn't that lad like 17 too? Doubt he's improving us that much for a good while
What a ride I just went on with this. It's like the hyperbolic time chamber of muppetry.
Add Sancho into our side and if everyone can stay fit we've got as strong a starting 11 as anyone in the league.
On paper that is an excellent side. I'd be extremely disappointed if we didn't close the gap on City and Liverpool if that was our starting 11 next season.
De Gea
AWB - Lindelof - Maguire - Shaw
McTominay
Bruno - Pogba
Sancho - Martial - Rashford
AWB - Lindelof - Maguire - Shaw
McTominay
Bruno - Pogba
Sancho - Martial - Rashford
On paper that is an excellent side. I'd be extremely disappointed if we didn't close the gap on City and Liverpool if that was our starting 11 next season.
Camavinga would simply be rotation for a year or so (I mean, we ain't signing him in the first place). So no he wouldn't improve our first team to the level of league winners. Sancho would improve us a lot in my view, but again not to the level of league/CL winners.
It seems to that fans think we will sign Sancho. There are about 5 clubs in for him. Real, Barca, Liverpool, City and United.
He could go anywhere, the only thing we can offer is money.
He could go anywhere, the only thing we can offer is money.
no. but if it was partey instead of camavinga, and assuming we kept pogba. we'd be getting pretty darn close.
we are 3-4 top signings away imo. sancho and a top DM are the 2 most crucial of those 3-4 signings. the other 1-2 signings would be a striker (backup like Ighalo perhaps) and a centre back.
we are 3-4 top signings away imo. sancho and a top DM are the 2 most crucial of those 3-4 signings. the other 1-2 signings would be a striker (backup like Ighalo perhaps) and a centre back.
doesnt seem like city and liverpool are in for him at all. and barca cant afford him. real madrid would prefer to sign mbappe i'd imagine, but they might target sancho.
aside from money, united can offer a player the project, and an exciting one at that. there are now the foundations for our team to become great once again. united has a huge fanbase, so coming here would be massive for sancho's personal brand (getting the #7 shirt potentially) and popularity. playing at the famous old trafford, a club with a rich history. one thats also in england as well, so sancho would be closer to home here. anyway, there are plenty of reasons. most of all, united have shown the most desire to actually sign sancho. he is most wanted by us, not barca or city, etc. at united sancho has the opportunity to be the face of a massive football club. he wouldnt be that at any of those other clubs.