Wot, no LB? (2026)

Status
Not open for further replies.
You forgot Dalot.. everyone can play LB.. We will put Heaven in there if there are no other options.
Fantastic! Maybe Rashford and Cunha can also play there, anyone checked if Darlow also played there?

Who cares who can possibly play there. We need a player who can actually play WELL there. Dalot cant. Amass is not good enough. Maz has injury issues and is not good enough. Heaven is a CB.
 
Fantastic! Maybe Rashford and Cunha can also play there, anyone checked if Darlow also played there?

Who cares who can possibly play there. We need a player who can actually play WELL there. Dalot cant. Amass is not good enough. Maz has injury issues and is not good enough. Heaven is a CB.
Martinez as well.
So many options.
 
Fantastic! Maybe Rashford and Cunha can also play there, anyone checked if Darlow also played there?

Who cares who can possibly play there. We need a player who can actually play WELL there. Dalot cant. Amass is not good enough. Maz has injury issues and is not good enough. Heaven is a CB.

Baleba has filled in at LB too.
 
It's unequivocally a massive feck up., we've left a huge risk on the table with no path to resolving or mitigating it.

We just have to hope the stars align and that Shaw finds form, never gets injured, and if he does then proven failures or unknown quantities can step in and also find form.
 
Is Dorgu classed as a winger nowadays? Keep hearing shaws the only LB. Develop Dorgu.
This should have been done during the summer, ready for the season as we never looked particularly serious about signing a LB. Just our arrogance that we thought we could get Hall for peanuts. Now if Shaw gets injured are they going to experiment during the season with Dorgu.
 
Glad the window is over and we can forget about this for now. Not ideal but I think we should have enough until Jan to cope and we can reassess then if needed.

It could be interesting to see if Amass or Leon can take the step up this season too.
 
This should have been done during the summer, ready for the season as we never looked particularly serious about signing a LB. Just our arrogance that we thought we could get Hall for peanuts. Now if Shaw gets injured are they going to experiment during the season with Dorgu.
Plus the fact Dorgu had some brilliant games and scored a wonder goal against Arsenal playing at LW made them thing it could have been a long term plan.
 
So it' Shaw and Amass as LBs + Mazraoui. Dalot and Mazraoui as RBs + Yoro. Martinez and Heaven at LCB (plus Shaw) and Maguire and de Ligt + Yoro as RCB options.

Think Dorgu will be option at wings behind Rashford, Cunha and others. Maybe at LB if needed but we haven't seen him there so far.
 
We've also apparently addressed midfield but if mainoo gets an injury I'm not confident we will do well at all.
 
I hope now that we've blocked Amass going out on loan, we actually give him some minutes rather than playing Dalot/Mazraoui out of position when Shaw gets knackered.
Clutching at straws here, but if he was able to step up over the next few months and challenge for the first choice LB spot...that frees up £50-60 million to spend on a decent RB. :)
 
What happened to Diego Leon? Is he totally unable to contribute still?
He’s not making the U21 squad which is a worry, he’s still only 19 but it looks like his development hasn’t been as good as United thought it would be
 
I think generally having one natural option for a certain position and multiple back-up's who can do a job is fine/survivable if that one player is a Bruno-esque ironman who can start most games and rarely gets injured.

However if you're no.1 option is Luke Shaw - a famously injury prone player, who is above 30 and is expected to play 50+ games this season - than that's just poor squad planning. It even worse if you consider that his back ups are either injury prone/ considered a winger/unproven on EPL level and meant to be sold this summer.

It's all just very naive.
 
Oh no, what shall we do? We only have one left-back! No cover at all!

Only Maz, who played LB at a World Cup and did it rather well.
Oh and Martinez perhaps, who is an experienced WC winning defender and could perhaps cope with a shift of position in an emergency.
Ah yes, and now Baleba, who may be able to follow in the footsteps of Keane and Ince to cover FB on his favoured side for a period, as we have plenty of CMs.
And don't forget Dorgu, who at least has experience of LWB.
And Heaven, who is a capable footballer as well as a decent defender, and might be able to provide cover for one of the above.

You know. I think we'll survive.
 
If money was so tight, we should have sold Dorgu and got a proper LB in. This was the summer to cash in.

Now what will happen is we use him at LB, he performs badly there, and we struggle to find buyers for him and he becomes another unsellable player.
 
We didnt want to make any "mistakes like in the past", but not signing anyone at LB will also prove to be a mistake, just a different kind.
 
Oh no, what shall we do? We only have one left-back! No cover at all!

Only Maz, who played LB at a World Cup and did it rather well.
Oh and Martinez perhaps, who is an experienced WC winning defender and could perhaps cope with a shift of position in an emergency.
Ah yes, and now Baleba, who may be able to follow in the footsteps of Keane and Ince to cover FB on his favoured side for a period, as we have plenty of CMs.
And don't forget Dorgu, who at least has experience of LWB.
And Heaven, who is a capable footballer as well as a decent defender, and might be able to provide cover for one of the above.

You know. I think we'll survive.
Stupid post. Nobody is saying we don’t have bodies that we can stick there. People are rightfully questioning why a club like Manchester United does not have a competent left back. Our first choice isn’t good enough, let alone shoehorning others into that position.

Why should we have to ‘survive’. It’s not too much to ask to have an actual decent left back, surely?
 
Stupid post. Nobody is saying we don’t have bodies that we can stick there. People are rightfully questioning why a club like Manchester United does not have a competent left back. Our first choice isn’t good enough, let alone shoehorning others into that position.

Why should we have to ‘survive’. It’s not too much to ask to have an actual decent left back, surely?
We have. You're all crying about cover. Which we also have in spades.

In the Ideal World, we would have bought a first choice, young, attacking LB to bed in over the season. But we'll have to try n upgrade in the summer, because in the Real World we're far too skint to do it all in one go.
 
He can, to the geographies where transfer window closes later than in England
The Scottish, Portuguese and Dutch seem to be the ones still open. I saw sporting were listed as interested, so that would make sense. I don't see him in Turkey or Saudi.
 
Where the hell is that Diego Leon fella we signed start of last season?? what was the point of that.. surely he's an option?
 
Where the hell is that Diego Leon fella we signed start of last season?? what was the point of that.. surely he's an option?
He’s apparently acclimatizing to U21 football so I’d say Amass is closer to the first team picture than him.
 
At 19, he should already be a squad player imo.
When we signed him there was posters putting him in their starting line ups, wouldn't listen that he was miles away from being ready
 
This should have been done during the summer, ready for the season as we never looked particularly serious about signing a LB. Just our arrogance that we thought we could get Hall for peanuts. Now if Shaw gets injured are they going to experiment during the season with Dorgu.
This is probably the most curious thing to me regarding this window, more than not signing a LB.

When Dorgu arrived, I understand him to be an option for the more defensive LWB, while Amad or even Anthony looked a candidate for a more attacking RWB. Dorgu as I understood it had played mostly LB before, and a good deal RW as well, and a little bit of LW.

He didn’t really impress as a LWB, though tbf not that many players impress under Amorim. When Amorim left i was expecting to see him more often as a LB back up to Shaw than a LW back up to Cunha. But Shaw was everpresent, and when Cunha was out, Dorgu really impressed and surprised a lot of us, as opposed to the one time I saw him at LB for us.

Regardless of these few games, going into this season with Cunha, Rashford on LW and Shaw, Amass on LB, I expected Dorgu to feature a bit at LB in preseason. When Amass shared every game with Shaw while the Rashford rumours/debate proliferated, I assumed like probably a few others that the idea was that Rashford was probably leaving while Amass was probably considered ready or almost ready.

So when Amass all of a sudden was rumored to get sold while Rashford was integrated into the squad with tales of merry rejoinders, it certainly confused me as to why Dorgu was never played at LB. It was actually the only reason I felt sure that we would buy a LB this particular window.

Shaw + the Dorgu I expected to see would IMO be a slightly weak link but not at all a big issue if the idea was to get a better LB in next year than we could afford this year. It’s just the fact that he never appeared as LB in preseason that gives me the impression that a cock-up has happened in that position..
 
This is probably the most curious thing to me regarding this window, more than not signing a LB.
Shaw + the Dorgu I expected to see would IMO be a slightly weak link but not at all a big issue if the idea was to get a better LB in next year than we could afford this year. It’s just the fact that he never appeared as LB in preseason that gives me the impression that a cock-up has happened in that position..
Obvious answer is Carrick was promised a LB, and he built his squad and pre-season planning for that.
 
This is probably the most curious thing to me regarding this window, more than not signing a LB.

When Dorgu arrived, I understand him to be an option for the more defensive LWB, while Amad or even Anthony looked a candidate for a more attacking RWB. Dorgu as I understood it had played mostly LB before, and a good deal RW as well, and a little bit of LW.

He didn’t really impress as a LWB, though tbf not that many players impress under Amorim. When Amorim left i was expecting to see him more often as a LB back up to Shaw than a LW back up to Cunha. But Shaw was everpresent, and when Cunha was out, Dorgu really impressed and surprised a lot of us, as opposed to the one time I saw him at LB for us.

Regardless of these few games, going into this season with Cunha, Rashford on LW and Shaw, Amass on LB, I expected Dorgu to feature a bit at LB in preseason. When Amass shared every game with Shaw while the Rashford rumours/debate proliferated, I assumed like probably a few others that the idea was that Rashford was probably leaving while Amass was probably considered ready or almost ready.

So when Amass all of a sudden was rumored to get sold while Rashford was integrated into the squad with tales of merry rejoinders, it certainly confused me as to why Dorgu was never played at LB. It was actually the only reason I felt sure that we would buy a LB this particular window.

Shaw + the Dorgu I expected to see would IMO be a slightly weak link but not at all a big issue if the idea was to get a better LB in next year than we could afford this year. It’s just the fact that he never appeared as LB in preseason that gives me the impression that a cock-up has happened in that position..
Be interesting what the targets will be next season. If Dorgu did well, would they try to get away without signing at least a backup? Depending on how our CB's progress, plus if the older ones pick up more injuries, will it be a CB. Would they still be happy with our RB options? I would say we definitely need another striker option. Hopefully we have a bit more cash to splash next summer. I just hope Carrick does well, not sure I can take another manager with different ideas and the squad being all over the place again.
 
Amusing fact I just read. Carrick retired 10 years ago and his current starting left back is his former team mate back then.
 
Amusing fact I just read. Carrick retired 10 years ago and his current starting left back is his former team mate back then.

Rashford as well. Unsurprisingly, Carrick rates both - probably because he played with both.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.