Your dream United XI hybrid new vs old

[Motorman]

The rules are simple, you have 110 points.

You build a team with 110 points and 110 points only.

Team formation is a standard 4 4 2 or 4 3 3 or 4 2 3 1

Price list is below:

De Gea 13 points
Romero 9 points
Grant 6 points

AWB 8 points
Dalot 6 points
Shaw 8
Williams 7

Maguire 10 points
Lindelof 8 points
Bailly 7 points
Tuanzebe 6 points

Pogba 14
Fernandes 14
McTominay 8
Fred 8
Mata 6

Rashford 12
Lingard 6
Gomes 4
James 8
Sanchez 5
Chong 4

Martial 11
Igahlo 8
Greenwood 6

Wildcards:
07-08 Ronaldo 18 points
06-07 Rooney 15 points
05-06 Scholes 15 points
04-05 Ferdinand 14 points


My team would be:

Romero
AWB Bailly Tuanzebe Williams
Scholes McTominay Pogba
Ronaldo Greenwood Rashford

9 + 8 + 7 + 6 + 7 + 15 + 8 + 14 + 18 + 6 + 12 = 110​

 

[harms]

De Gea 13
AWB 8 Rio 14 Tuanzebe 6 Williams 7
Matic 6*
Scholes 15 - Fred 8
Greenwood 6 - Rooney 15 - Rashford 12​

* let's say 6, since he didn't even make your list

 

[Andersonson]

Ronaldo - Rooney - Rashford
Fred - Scholes - McTom
Shaw - Tuanzebe - Lindelof - AWB
Grant

 

[Motorman]

De Gea 13
AWB 8 Rio 14 Tuanzebe 6 Williams 7
Matic 6*
Scholes 15 - Fred 8
Greenwood 6 - Rooney 15 - Rashford 12​

* let's say 6, since he didn't even make your list

Ooooh. He'd be a 7 I'm afraid

 

[MyOnlySolskjaer]

We play with 10 men.

Romero
Wan Bissaka Bailly Maguire Shaw
Scholes Fernandes
Ronaldo Greenwood Rashford​

 

[Motorman]

We play with 10 men.

Romero
Wan Bissaka Bailly Maguire Shaw
Scholes Fernandes
Ronaldo Greenwood Rashford​

Haha good shout. Great team

 

[harms]

Ooooh. He'd be a 7 I'm afraid

Swap Rashford with Martial then

 

[Tom Cato]

Romero

AWB Bailly Tuanzebe Williams

Ronaldo Fernandes Scholes James

Greenwood Rashford

= 110 flat.

 

[Web of Bissaka]

OP needs updates.

• Matic
• Pereira

N Since Sanchez is somehow there..

• Smalling
• Henderson

 

[Web of Bissaka]

Romero
Wall Rio Axel Shaw
McT Scholes Pog
Ronaldo Rooney Rashford
​

Screw the pts!
9 + 8 + 14 + 6 + 8 + 8 + 15 + 14 + 18 + 15 + 12 = 127

Ok fine, swap these to get flat 110.

Rio-Mag​

Roon-Green​

Rash-Jam​

​

Rom​

Wall Mag Axe Luk​

McT PS Pog​

CR7 Green Jam​

 

[Web of Bissaka]

We play with 10 men.

Romero
Wan Bissaka Bailly Maguire Shaw
Scholes Fernandes
Lingard
Ronaldo Greenwood Rashford​

Fixed it for you.
107 + 3 = 110

Since Jesse is a shadow of his best self now, we half it into 3 (seriously OP why the heck is he 6 pts?!).

 

[Grande]

Fun challenge. I’m assuming it’s for one game, as for a season you build a squad, not a line-up. I’m also assuming that the wildcards are time machine versions as I reckon Scholes would be the only one currently worth his evaluation... Apart ftom that, I’m going off recent form.

First a bargain team of 96:

Grant
WanBissaka Bailly Lindelöf Shaw
McTominay Fred
Lingard Bruno Rashford
Martial

Reckon that would be solid enough against most teams.

Then I’d swap workhorse Lingard for prime Ronaldo. For the last two points, I could replace Grant with Romero or Lindelöf with Maguire for a bit more security.

 

[P-Nut]

De Gea 13

AWB 8
Bailly 7
Maguire 10
Williams 7

McTominay 8
Fred 8

Greenwood 6
Fernandes 14
Ronaldo 18

Martial 11

 

[kafta]

Romero 9
AWB 8
Maguire 10
Tuanzebe 6
Williams 7
Matic 7
Fred 8
Fernandes 14
Ronaldo 18
Rashford 12
Martial 11

 

[diarm]

Grant 6
AWB 8 Tuanzebe 6 Maguire 10 Williams 7
Scholes 15 Fred 8
Greenwood 6 Bruno 14 Ronaldo 18
Rashford 12​

 

[devilish]

---------------------------Romero-------------------------
AWB---------Ferdinand--------Lindelof---------Williams
-----------------Fred----------------Mctominay----------------
Greenwood---------Scholes------------------Rashford
----------------------------Rooney---------------------------

 

[Bwuk]

The rules are simple, you have 110 points.

You build a team with 110 points and 110 points only.

Team formation is a standard 4 4 2 or 4 3 3 or 4 2 3 1

Price list is below:

De Gea 13 points
Romero 9 points
Grant 6 points

AWB 8 points
Dalot 6 points
Shaw 8
Williams 7

Maguire 10 points
Lindelof 8 points
Bailly 7 points
Tuanzebe 6 points

Pogba 14
Fernandes 14
McTominay 8
Fred 8
Mata 6

Rashford 12
Lingard 6
Gomes 4
James 8
Sanchez 5
Chong 4

Martial 11
Igahlo 8
Greenwood 6

Wildcards:
07-08 Ronaldo 18 points
06-07 Rooney 15 points
05-06 Scholes 15 points
04-05 Ferdinand 14 points


My team would be:

Romero
AWB Bailly Tuanzebe Williams
Scholes McTominay Pogba
Ronaldo Greenwood Rashford

9 + 8 + 7 + 6 + 7 + 15 + 8 + 14 + 18 + 6 + 12 = 110​

Romero
AWB - Ferdinand - Axel - Williams
McTominay - Fred
Greenwood - Bruno - Ronaldo
Rashford​

 

[Baneofthegame]

Romero (9pts)
AWB (8pts) Rio (14pts) Tuanzebe (6pts) Williams (7pts)
McTominay (8pts) Scholes (15pts)
Fred (8pts)
Sanchez (5pts) Rashford (12pts) Ronaldo (18pts)

9+8+14+6+7+8+8+15+5+12+18 = 110​

 

[Class of 63]

Surprised nobody has suggested Lingard is -5 and Pereira -3 to make it easier, maybe Prunier -17 as well.

 

[nyanza]

Romero, Wan Bissaka, Ferdinand, Maguire, Williams, Scholes, Fred, Mctom, Sanchez, Martial, Rooney.

 

[Walters_19_MuFc]

De Gea
AWB Bailly Maguire Shaw
Mata Scholes McTominay Rashford
Rooney
Ighalo

13 + 8 + 7 + 10 + 8 + 6 + 15 + 8 + 12 + 15 + 8 = 110​