He's the best player in the world, who is still only 24 (!), and would instantly transform us into a force again. Why would Rashford and Garnacho "suffer"? He's not toxic, just high maintenance. And if he wants to leave for Real in a couple seasons or so, we'll get a record fee for him.
I'd rather get two-three seasons out of him than nothing, and I'm tired of watching our rivals win titles while we're miserable to watch. If you have an opportunity to get him, given where we've been for a decade now, you do it without any hesitation.
So Mbappe comes into the team, as you say he's the best player in the world, and he's 24, so presumably he will play every game and he plays predominantly on the left. His qualities don't lend itself to the the type of number 9 ETH typically likes to play in his system so he'll stay left, Rashford then has to come into the number 9 but he's only been played there this season out of necessity cause again he's not the typical 9 that ETH likes to play in his system, so he's out of position and he's not going to displace Mbappe, neither is Garnacho so Garnacho doesn't get a lookin either.
Our rivals win titles whilst we are miserable to watch because they have a great squad from top to bottom, where as our squad is mostly full of shit still, I swear none of you know how football even works, you seem to think signing Mbappe will just magically transform our entire team and all of a sudden we'll start playing this amazing magical football that ETH wants us to play. How about instead we get the players and the squad the recruitment team and manager want, get us playing the great football ETH is known for, get us competing with a fully realised squad, elevate our current good players and new players to elite heights and THEN we can think about adding players like Mbappe as a cherry on top.
Again, chasing galactico signings when we've not even fixed the basics yet, signing Mbappe won't stop our keeper from making mistakes and kicking like shit, It won't nullify our complete lack of midfield presence, it won't fix our lack of traditional number 9's, it won't change the fact our RB options are decent at best, it won't change the fact we have 1 decent backup CB, it won't change the fact our subs bench was primarily an 18 year old kid and Wout Weghorst in the FA Cup final to win us the game. I could go on and on
It's like none of you have learned anything over the last 10+ years, we're
in this mess because Woodward and the Glazers prioritised stupid signings like Mbappe instead of prioritising building an elite squad that enables us to compete against everyone on all fronts and can carry out the type of football the manager wants us to play. If you can't see this then you have deserved to watch our rivals claim titles and you deserve to see more of it, cause it will happen if we don't get a
squad. Our first decent season in a long while with potential to build on it and instead we should spent our whole summer budget on Mbappe.
Man City works because they have a terrific squad they keep building on topped off with players like Haaland that are the cherry on top. You want us to keep playing with Fred, McTominay, De Gea, Maguire etc and then throw in Mbappe and bar Mbappe making speedy runs and goals you'll be left scratching your head wondering why we still play like shit and howcome Mbappe hasn't magically transformed us!?
