Keep, ditch, last chance

[JediSith]

1 Altay Bayindir (G) keep, but why not upgrade
22Tom Heaton (G)
24Andre Onana (G) keep, but assess.
2Victor Lindelof (D) keep
5Harry Maguire (D) ditch
6Lisandro Martinez (D) keep
12Tyrell Malacia (D) keep
15Sergio Reguilon (D) keep
19Raphael Varane (D) keep
20Diogo Dalot (D) keep
23Luke Shaw (D) keep
29Aaron Wan-Bissaka (D) keep
35Jonny Evans (D) ditch
NADaniel Gore (M) keep
NAIsak Hansen-Aaroen (M) feck knows
NAHannibal Mejbri (M) keep
4Sofyan Amrabat (M) keep
7Mason Mount (M) keep
8Bruno Fernandes (M) keep
14Christian Eriksen (M) ditch
17Alejandro Garnacho (M) keep
18Casemiro (M) keep
21Antony (M) keep
28Facundo Pellistri (M) keep
34Donny van de Beek (M) ditch
37Kobbie Mainoo (M) keep
39Scott McTominay (M) ditch
NAShola Shoretire (F) keep
9Anthony Martial (F) ditch
10Marcus Rashford (F) ditch
11Rasmus Hojlund (F) keep
16Amad Diallo (F) Keep
25Jadon Sancho (F) ditch

 

[AndySmith1990]

Rashford - ditch
Martial - ditch
Sancho - ditch
McTominay - ditch
Antony - ditch
Donny van de beek - ditch
Lindelof - ditch
Dalot - ditch

Keep the rest

 

[Varun1]

Can mods create a poll? Would make for an interesting debate.

Ditch: 18
Keep: 14
Last chance: 2

Eric ten Hag – Ditch
Altay Bayindir (G) - Keep
Tom Heaton (G) - Keep
Andre Onana (G) - Ditch
Victor Lindelof (D) - Ditch
Harry Maguire (D) - Ditch
Lisandro Martinez (D) - Keep
Tyrell Malacia (D) - Keep
Sergio Reguilon (D) - Ditch
Raphael Varane (D) - Ditch
Diogo Dalot (D) - Ditch
Luke Shaw (D) - Keep
Aaron Wan-Bissaka (D) - Keep
Jonny Evans (D) - Ditch
Daniel Gore (M) - Keep
Isak Hansen-Aaroen (M) - Keep
Hannibal Mejbri (M) - Keep
Sofyan Amrabat (M) - Ditch
Mason Mount (M) - Keep
Bruno Fernandes (M) - Last chance
Christian Eriksen (M) - Ditch
Alejandro Garnacho (M) - Keep
Casemiro (M) - Ditch
Antony (M) - Ditch
Facundo Pellistri (M) - Ditch
Donny van de Beek (M) - Ditch
Kobbie Mainoo (M) - Keep
Scott McTominay (M) - Keep
Shola Shoretire (F) - Ditch
Anthony Martial (F) – Ditch
Marcus Rashford (F) - Ditch
Rasmus Hojlund (F) - Keep
Amad Diallo (F) - Last chance
Jadon Sancho (F) - Ditch

 

[caid]

Eric Ten Hag - Keep

24Andre Onana (G) Keep / last chance - i'd give him a year heading to ditch pretty fast atm.
2Victor Lindelof (D) Ditch - just seems a good time to call it
5Harry Maguire (D) Ditch - wouldn't fit the system i'd be looking to play
6Lisandro Martinez (D) Keep
12Tyrell Malacia (D) Keep / last chance
19Raphael Varane (D) Last chance - I'd be tempted to try keep him around but cant really argue hes worth the wages involved, doubt we'll improve on him at least when available.
20Diogo Dalot (D) Keep - squad role
23Luke Shaw (D) Ditch - i'd take the money. giving a last chance to a player who's been here 8 years or something sounds silly.
29Aaron Wan-Bissaka (D) Ditch - doesn't fit system
35Jonny Evans (D) Keep / Ditch - i might keep him around but if hes making the bench something has gone badly wrong.
4Sofyan Amrabat (M) Last chance - maybe worth keeping as a squad player you dont really want to use but who's better than nothing.
7Mason Mount (M) Keep
8Bruno Fernandes (M) Keep
14Christian Eriksen (M) Ditch
17Alejandro Garnacho (M) Keep - i'd just default keep all the youth players, some might make sense to send on their way but not in a position to judge.
18Casemiro (M) Keep - still need experience in squad. Wages are stupid
21Antony (M) Last Chance - I'd have him as a squad player just to set a base line for the level of workrate needed by our forwards. 80m is an utterly stupid price for that but whats done is done.
28Facundo Pellistri (M) Keep
34Donny van de Beek (M) Ditch
37Kobbie Mainoo (M) Keep
39Scott McTominay (M) Ditch - doesn't fit
9Anthony Martial (F) Ditch
10Marcus Rashford (F) Last chance - were keeping him obviously, his wages guarantee that. In a functional, succesful united side hes an impact sub at best.
11Rasmus Hojlund (F) Keep
16Amad Diallo (F) Keep
25Jadon Sancho (F) Ditch

 

[P-Nut]

Eric Ten Hag - Ditch when possible. He hasn't delivered any sort of style of play, and I don't care about the injuries, the style shouldn't disappear due to injuries, it should simply get worse.

1 Altay Bayindir (G) - Keep, back up keeper likely to never play
22Tom Heaton (G) - Keep, United history, never going to actually play, means we can loan out the kid GKs
24Andre Onana (G) - Last chance, I'd like to see how he fared playing his natural game. This rooted to his line version is pointless

2Victor Lindelof (D) - Ditch, never going to be of the standard required
5Harry Maguire (D) - Ditch, we can't play positive football with him in the side
6Lisandro Martinez (D) - Keep, and pray his early season form was just a blip
12Tyrell Malacia (D) - Ditch, a young player with potential should have his role
15Sergio Reguilon (D) - Ditch
19Raphael Varane (D) - Last chance, I think he's been shaky when he's played, but he's of a higher standard than most of our defence
20Diogo Dalot (D) - Ditch, supposedly good going forward, but provides zero threat
23Luke Shaw (D) - Keep, best defender at the club
29Aaron Wan-Bissaka (D) - Last chance, should be a constant back up or tactical option
35Jonny Evans (D) - Ditch, nothing against him, but a sign of the malaise the club is in

NADaniel Gore (M) - Keep
NAIsak Hansen-Aaroen (M) - Keep
NAHannibal Mejbri (M) - Last chance/ditch, needs to show more when he gets an opportunity. Would be 100% profit if sold so he'd be a likely option to be moved on
4Sofyan Amrabat (M) - Ditch, added nothing
7Mason Mount (M) - Keep, too early to completely write him off, and in a side that plays positive football I wouldn't mind seeing what he can do
8Bruno Fernandes (M) - Last chance, this season he's been as big a problem as anyone. Not creating and constantly losing possession.
14Christian Eriksen (M) - Ditch
17Alejandro Garnacho (M) - Keep
18Casemiro (M) - Last chance, give him until seasons end to see if his legs are truly gone
21Antony (M) - Last chance, I'm one of a very few that think there is a player in there. But you can't have no end product for 2 full seasons and keep starting.
28Facundo Pellistri (M) - Ditch, never going to make it here
34Donny van de Beek (M) - Ditch
37Kobbie Mainoo (M) - Keep
39Scott McTominay (M) - Ditch, see Maguire

NAShola Shoretire (F) - Ditch
9Anthony Martial (F) - Ditch, he's broken
10Marcus Rashford (F) - Last chance, not like we have much choice, on far too much money we just need to hope he can be arsed for a bit
11Rasmus Hojlund (F) - Keep, although he's had a very worrying start
16Amad Diallo (F) - Last chance, more like one and only chance, never had a run in the side. Would like to see if his Sunderland form could translate across but how long do you wait.
25Jadon Sancho (F) - Ditch, attitude

 

[Sir Matt]

Debating making a Google Form survey to collect this data so we can see how each player is rated without reading through all of the posts. I am worried the results might be detrimental to the confidence of 90% of the squad.

Here's a survey (let me know of any corrections):
https://forms.gle/6Dz6tXpFqGE3Rqj36

 

[statpadder]

Keep:
Martial
Antony
Casemiro
Mainoo
Amrabat
Martinez
Amad
AWB
Malacia
Garnacho
Hoijland
Erikssen
Reguilon
Evans

Ditch:
Shaw
Maguire
Van de Beek
Bruno Fernandes
Rashford
Dalot
Pellistri
Mount
Sancho

Last Chance:
McTominay
Onana

Have to sell Bruno to start the rebuild. And yeah, keep all technically sound players. Obviously 90% here would disagree with this and that’s why we’re in this mess!

 

[Remember the geese]

Keep:
Martial

A genuinely insane opinion. Did you want us to keep Phil Jones too?