This is next to the Russian border, 40km south of Belgorod. Confirms that the Russian troops north of Kharkiv have retreated back into Russia.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Russian invasion of Ukraine | Fewer tweets, more discussion
- Thread starter Wednesday at Stoke
- Start date
Would be nice to see where Russian troops are now against where they were in Donbass the day before the war began.
The issue with Chechnya is that their families are basically held hostage — not literally but if they decide to run away, at the very least they are going to be disowned, at worst their family members can be kidnapped/arrested (sometimes it's hard to spot a difference between the two). Defectors are also going to be in danger for life whenever they flee — if it's in Russia, Chechen policemen can semi-legally steal people even from other regions; if it's somewhere abroad it's obviously much safer but there were still cases of different Chechen defectors (LGBT activists, political activists, women that escaped arranged marriages etc.) getting kidnapped back to Chechnya or even killed (Mamikhan Umarov in Austria, Imran Aliev in France).
I'm not just speculating btw — there are tons of examples on every "punishment". The latest infamous case was with the Yangulbayev family — the father was a federal judge (already in retirement), his sons were political activists (one was a lawyer working for a non-government organization named the "committee against torture"). In January 2021 the eldest son came public saying that around 40 of his relatives are missing, after a few days police raided his house (outside of Chechnya) under the suspicion of terrorist activity, later that month police raided the father's flat (again, not in Chechnya), letting him go (he still had immunity as a retired judge) but taking his wife back to Chechnya — originally as a "witness" but later as a perpetrator of some insane crimes which included kicking the shit out of multiple policemen while resisting arrest. She's still under arrest. Kadyrov has said, openly, that the entire family are terrorists and they'll make sure that their place is either in jail or below the ground.
Last edited:
Thank you for the reply.
Wow , that really is a shitty situation.
Maybe a complete reset is the best option.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
I'm aware of the current situation, but I wonder (and I guess Kadyrow does, too) what will happen to him if Putin is gone? Would a successor keep the current arrangement ongoing, or would he (whoever he would be) see Kadyrov as a risk he should get rid off. If it's the latter I guess it would make sense for Kadyrov to be president of his own insignificant state outside Russian reach (assuming the Russian army gets heavily beaten and generally in trouble) rather than being killed for being a political risk. Bit of a "all-or-nothing" experiment for him.
Any targeting of nuclear power stations? I hope not.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Blackouts across the Kharkiv region. Russia hitting the power grids putting eastern Ukraine into darkness.
Somehow knew they'd not leave without a sting in the tail.
Somehow knew they'd not leave without a sting in the tail.
Terrorising and killing civilians is what they do best so yeah, no surprises. When they have to fight against the army they run like chickens.
I think it's a given that they will try to destroy as much of the vital infrastructure before the winter as possible, especially the heating plants.
just heard they've targetted every power plant across ukraine. i thought this would happen in the event that ukraine made any advance. it's where it gets dangerously high alert for eveyone. it's a sign that russia will do things it has not yet done should it find itself on a major defensive.
Think we now know what they were doing at Zaporizhzhia.
Back to doing war crimes again.
Prove it.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
last two lines!
Come on!
Very smart usage of missiles that cost over $10m each just to cause a few hours of blackouts.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Yeah he’s goneElectricity is back up again too in affected regions. Hundreds of millions of US dollars that could have gone into making lives of ordinary Russians better end up causing electricity disturbances for a few hours in Ukraine.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Can someone explain how Ukraine “wins” this war? Like what would be the sequence of events?
Do they push all the invading forces back to the Ukrainian borders and the Russians just say “Well played, lads. Got us good. We’ll be off now. Sorry about all the drama” and life goes back to normal in the region?
I’m obviously being glib but what does the most optimistic end game for Ukraine realistically look like?
Do they push all the invading forces back to the Ukrainian borders and the Russians just say “Well played, lads. Got us good. We’ll be off now. Sorry about all the drama” and life goes back to normal in the region?
I’m obviously being glib but what does the most optimistic end game for Ukraine realistically look like?
Yep, I agree. IF this is Russia's response to a significant collapse (obviously a massive if) then it's more indicative of their own impotence than anything else. However i suspect that there are more serious responses being planned. I might sound pessimistic but what I'm hoping for now is a Hitler 1944 style badly rushed, badly planned, poorly staffed, attack relying on non-existent armies and unrealistic supply lines. I can see that happening if Putin really has removed himself from the reality of the war, or is being deceived by his own generals, both of which seem quite possible. But i doubt knocking out a few power stations really is all Russia can muster.
If the eventual successor is going to be more or less from the Putin's circle (I mean not someone like Navalny who would try to destroy most of the current institutions of power & rebuild them from the ground), I'd imagine that they would try & make the same deal with him. Replacing him would be a monumental task that may lead to the Third Chechen War, I'd imagine — and Kadyrov, the mindless illiterate oaf that he is, will probably see the situation similarly — he'll lose way too much if he'll try and proclaim republic's sovereignty (unless we entertain the scenario where Russia falls apart like U.S.S.R. did but I don't think that it's likely) — not just the finances but Russia will probably try to forcefully replace him in that case. Although trying to rationalize Kadyrov is a moot task, unlike Putin he isn't a smart person and neither does he have any smart people in his immediate surroundings. Plus he's horrendously impulsive.
It's really a hopeless situation where there isn't a realistic way to solve the issue without escalating it to a potential civil war, you can only prolong the status quo and hope for some Black Swan event. Who knows, maybe Ukraine will somehow play a part in his eventual demise.
If I had to take a guess I'd say Ukraine pushes back the Russians to pre-invasion borders and they call a ceasefire and that's it. But Ukrainian rhetoric lately seems to indicate they won't tolerate that solution so...
Wow. Slava Ukraini.
I think the Ukrainians would be counting on some kind of internal Russian upheaval for that scenario to play out. But it wouldn’t be unprecedented, it’s pretty much what happened to the Chinese in Vietnam in 1979.
It might also have happened in the Iran-Iraq war in 1982 if the Iranians had stopped their counter-offensive at the Iraqi frontier and agreed to a ceasefire (Iraq had initiated the war by invading Iran in 1980). Instead, they invaded Iraq and the war dragged on for another six years, ultimately producing no territorial change.
In both cases, the pre-war territorial status quo was ultimately preserved, although in the case of Iran and Iraq at least, the impact of the war on their societies and governments was immense.
It is the big question of this conflict. I'm guessing that the best bet is on demoralizing effect that this hypothetical win will project on Putin & Russian's internal politics. It's hard to try and to objectively predict the possibility of such scenario since I want it too happen quite desperately but if you imagine that, say, a year of this "special military operation" has gone by, Ukraine retook not only the newly-invaded territories but also took back the so-called DPR & LPR (and maybe Crimea, who knows?), while the economy is crumbling, the coffins keep on coming etc.
Otherwise, if Putin's grasp on Russia is still strong, I find it hard to imagine a scenario where he backs down, he's already gone way past a point where you count your losses and retreat.
I think that the conversations that happen privately between the West and Ukraine are very different from the current rhetoric about returning to the 1991 borders. I'd bet if today Ukraine were offered an immediate end to the war by not challenging the Crimean referendum and by giving up the areas of the Donbas that have been independent since 2014 they'd jump at the chance. Because that is currently not on offer I can see that it makes more sense for them to keep up the mantra of not one inch of land, etc..
If they maintain access to the Black Sea, and keep Mariupol, Kherson, Odessa, that would be a major win for them, given what they were facing earlier this year.
Yeah, uncross them. It's a sensationalized version of something that had happened a couple of days ago and it is nothing like the name of the article suggests. Municipal deputies are just about the highest in modern Russia that you can get while not being supportive of Putin (and that's going to change after this round of election that ended today, I'd imagine). But they solve issues like park benches and pedestrian crossings, calling them "Kremlin officials" is not even a stretch, it's factually wrong.
0% chance.
It really looks like they're going to push back to the 2014 borders, they're not settling for half-measures (like they probably would in the first month of the war when the peace talks were still on-going). The only compromise I can see them going for is not pushing for Crimea but that's simply because logistically retaking Crimea seems like a very improbable task. But with the things going like they're going lately...
UAf have demonstrated the capability to conduct large scale combined arms offensives, and that ability will only grow since the weapon deliveries will continue. So its not unrealistic to assume that they can push Russia all the way to the border. After that Russians will probably be more concerned of keeping Crimea than trying to get back into Ukraine : their capability is actually getting weaker every day. The best equipment is gone, they have to field mothballed stuff from the cold war. They can't manufacture modern units at scale because they lack the western supplied components Their ammunition is getting low - rumours of a deal with North Korea for artillery rounds stock. They are losing trained men but replacing them with conscripts or almost senior citizens.
The only thing they can realistically do is order full mobilisation. But unless they are planning to use them as a cannon fodder, they need equipment . And as we said, the stuff they are fielding rn is ancient. Also a full mobilisation basically grinds the economy to a halt , and creates very large discontent within the people. It is hard to justify if Russia itself has not been attacked. Which might be why the Ukrainians think twice before invading Crimea.
I really doubt they would think it is a major win given the country being destroyed, many lives lost, the armed forces being stronger now.
Can Putin still sell a success to the Russian public if they're pushed back all the way to pre-invasion borders? Technically speaking...he would still control the Donbas.
Well, fart.