If McTominay were Brighton or West Ham player, people would rate him £100m +. It is no wonder teams like Bayern Munchen are interested.
Scott McTominay | Transfer discussion not performance discussion
- Thread starter Reapersoul20
- Start date
- Status
Sure thingShould be looking to sign both (propose loan deal for Amrabat). Not surprised to see United Stand fan channel bought the Bild stuff about McTominay hook,line and sinker
Bayern are now linked with Dier, someone is making this shit up.
Well, Rice and Caicedo who are worse players are now somehow rated £100m players. McTominay, if we use their measurement, would be worth lot of millions more.
This is top tier comedy, well done!Not sure where you are in the world, but isn’t it a bit early to be this drunk?
Are you one of those who also thought Pogba was great player?
I don't drink so there is no problem with that. What have Rice or Caicedo done to be valued more than McTominay? I'm curious. What is £100m + quality? Because they haven't show that yet. Not even close.
There's no way he goes to Bayern.
So then being a Manchester United player who has the biggest platform of them, the Mcterminator should go for a fee higher than those two. Correct?
He might have to be utilised at the back the way things are going.
I don't think McT would like to take a step down at this stage of his career. Within a year he'd have the world at his feet as our top CM. Why would he want to go to Bayern of all clubs?
Both Rice and Caicedo are nowhere near that valuation. Nowhere near. McTominay is a player that is not worse than those two. So if they are valued that much, so should McTominay. The truth is that those players are worth like 1/3 of that sum. If even that. I'm still waiting for someone to explain how Rice and Caicedo quality is £100m +.
Outside of shooting ability, what exactly does McTominay excel in at a level above Rice and Caicedo?
Scotchness ?
You mentioned Rice and Caicedo being worse players than McTominay. That's a pretty...interesting opinion.
They were sold for 100m because they'd performed relatively well and were on long term contracts. Both Brighton and West Ham would've rather kept them. Us, on the other hand, I suspect would like to get a better level of player than McTominay.
Rice is a funny one to judge. For a DM his sides sure don’t have great defensive records
McTominay can't pass wind and when he does, it comes out sideways towards the nearest man.
He also doesn't show for a pass. He is nowhere near Rice. Could he be at Rice's level had McTominay started 200+ games at West Ham to develop his game? Maybe, but he hasn't and when he was starting at United he looked bang average.
Ha ha, thanks.... it is a depressing time for United fans, I need the humour!!
I’ve said this for a while now. The only reason other top English sides aren’t in for him is because he’s at Utd imo. If he played lower down he’d be snapped up and this Bayern interest sort of proves it. Brighton have Gilmour and fecking Milner in midfield now
I would ask instead. What does Rice and Caicedo do to be valued £100m+? None of those are better players looking from attacking piont of view. With a good engine and strong in physical game McTominay is a all around player.
I still think valuation of those players are insane. Relatively well for a bottom- and midtable team don't say much to me. We have lot of those kind of players in Premier League.
Pochettino, Guardiola, Klopp and Arteta were all willing to pay huge fees for either Rice or Caicedo. I'm sure ETH would have taken either, had the budget been available.
Yet you are saying a McTominay is up there with them, despite not being good enough to get into a struggling United midfield?
Strange how only David Moyes has come in for McSauce, despite only being valued at about a third of Rice or Caicedo!
Tuchel has been given control of recruitment and he's targeting EPL players.
I'll say the part that is maybe true is that if we were in a different market where Rice and Caicedo moved for half the price, McTominay transfer value wouldn't be divided by 2.
If this is a genuine post I'll be upset if I don't get promoted to this forum. Im joking! Seriously though. McTominay was overlooked by England and Rice was coveted and successfully urged to switch nationalities after already representing the rep of Ireland. Caciedo is a whole different kettle of fish as well talent wise.
Mctominay would be the subject of a bidding war right now if he was as valuable as you deem him. The truth is its likely no club would meet the 45M pounds valuation placed on his head by the club
Yeah....I've stopped looking at player valuations as reflections of their abilities. Lukaku's career transfer fee dwarfs someone like Berbatov, for example. Transfer fees are complicated.
I'd disagree that McTominay is on the same level as Rice though.
If you’re correct in your assessment (you’re not, miserably off) then Mctominay will go for 100m plus. Let’s see if that happens. You must be expecting it to happen.
McTominay would make a lot of posters on here eat humble pie if he moves to Bayern.
He’ll do well there and I’m sure most of us won’t have an issue with that.
I share this opinion. He's a good player and would compliment most teams in the league
He's had more than enough time to make them eat humble pie at United and hasn't managed to.
Come on, I like McT a lot as a player, but Rice and especially Caicedo are far better.
The only thing McT has over them is late runs into the box and shooting.
Hope Bayern snaps him, those funds together with Henderson’s will get us a better midfielder.
Get £40m for him, sign Amrabat and get Gravenberch on loan. The best we can hope for this window.
As long as we get rid of him for a decent I’m happy to have any type of pie.
at this point anything over 30 million they just need to take. Getting zero for him would be absolutely shambolic. Best case we move him and maguire on, and bring in a LB on loan, get the CB to help cover varane, and one more midfielder in while mount and mainoo are out. That is best we can hope for. Things like another CF will have to wait.
So they actually want to buy McT permanently? Or is this a year loan with option to buy rubbish?
I’ve always said if McT went to West Ham he’d be Rice reincarnated. They are the same player.
I would trade McT for a sturdy chair, let alone any player we can actually use, like Gravenberch, because McT is virtually useless to us and chair can be useful, a functional DMF player - even more so.
But I don't for a second believe Bayern is actually interested in McT. This is all a propaganda to make gullible fans go "see! McT is good! Even Bayern wants him!" And as we can see - there are plenty of fans that bought it.
Unless you are star player in big team people usually underrate you.
Guardiola wanted to pay huge money for Maguire. Pochettinho is average manager so I have no idea what you want to say bringing him up. Klopp have paid lot of money for players that also failed. I'm not sure where you are going with this.
We have to agree that we disagree on this.
I'm not saying McTominay is going to go for 100m plus. I'm saying he is no worse than Caicedo or Rice and that those two are overrated. Insane money have been thrown.
In what way are they better. I'm still trying to get that answer. It is no coincidence that both Brighton and West Ham are better this year without those two players.
- Status