The importance of a Director of Football: Marcel Brands

SilentWitness

ShoelessWitness
Staff
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
30,500
Supports
Everton
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/49423487

Everton's signing of Italy's brilliant teenage striker Moise Kean from Juventus was one of the surprise deals of the transfer window.

Kean, 19, emerged as one of Europe's top young attacking talents in Serie A last season, showing enough promise to be given his full international debut by manager Roberto Mancini in November 2018.

Juventus' decision to sell Kean prompted surprise and anger among many of the club's supporters - while Everton's ability to close out the move was regarded as a major coup for the Merseysiders and director of football Marcel Brands.

This is how the Toffees secured the signature of one of Europe's brightest young talents, and why former PSV director of football Brands is central to an effective recruitment process.

How the deal was done
Kean had been on the radar of the well-connected Brands, along with many others, for 18 months and Everton formulated plans for a loan deal in January, a window the Dutchman rarely likes to get involved in unless the circumstances and the players are special. Kean was one of those exceptions.

Juventus, with Serie A and Champions League commitments, were not receptive to any such deal, while in the remaining months of the season Kean's profile rose dramatically on the strength of his performances and, sadly, when he was subjected to racist abuse during Juventus' game in Cagliari in April.

This led to concerns behind the scenes at Goodison that a move for Kean, which was at the forefront of Brands' plans, would now be more difficult. In March, he made his first start for the national side, scoring in a Euro 2020 qualifier against Finland, which Italy won 2-0. The goal meant he became his country's youngest goalscorer, at just 19 years and 23 days, since Bruno Nicole in 1958.

Everton, however, remained convinced a deal could be done and all the pieces fell perfectly into place.

Brands and Everton chairman Bill Kenwright have a good working relationship with super-agent Mino Raiola, who represents Kean, while a changing of the guard at Juventus opened the door for a move.

Maurizio Sarri replaced Massimiliano Allegri, who was a mentor to the youngster, with Sarri's personal favourite Gonzalo Higuain returning to Juve after loan spells at AC Milan and Chelsea. Kean was being pushed down the pecking order.

Higuain joined an attacking force led by Cristiano Ronaldo and complemented by Paulo Dybala, Mario Mandzukic, Douglas Costa and others.

Italian journalist Stefano Boldrini, London correspondent for Italian daily Gazetta dello Sport, told BBC Sport: "The story of Kean surprised a lot of people in Italy because at the end of last season he was very good. He scored for Juventus and he scored for Italy.

"But with Sarri and the Allegri departure, a lot of things changed in Juventus. The younger Kean had to move.


Moise Kean played 16 Serie A games for Juventus (five starts) and scored seven goals
"We spoke to Roberto Mancini and he said it is a pity younger Italian players do not find places and have to move. He said he is sure Everton will be a good experience because Everton is a well-organised, ambitious club who wants to get back into the big European competitions so it may be a good experience."

Everton also took advantage of what could be called Juve's 'in the moment' mentality which means they demand instant results rather than count on too many works in progress, such as Kean.

Juve also needed to recoup money after heavy outlay on fees and salaries on the likes of Ronaldo and, this summer, Matthijs de Ligt from Ajax and Aaron Ramsey from Arsenal.

Raiola, who also negotiated the De Ligt deal, knows he can work with Brands and Kenwright and regarded Everton as the ideal club for Kean to get regular football, not guaranteed at Juventus and perhaps not by other clubs who may have taken an interest such as Inter Milan, Arsenal and Manchester United.

This all enabled Everton to strike a deal which resembles a real bargain at £27m with add-ons that will leave any potential final fee just short of £30m.

The final flourish was added when Everton were able to seal the deal without the buy-back clause Juve would have preferred.

Everton's personal touch
Everton director of football Brands brings the personal touch to his transfer dealings, believing it can make the difference when closing out the sort of deals that are his trademark - namely young, emerging talent that can serve a club well and retain serious sell-on value.

In other words, Moise Kean.

It was a key factor in convincing Kean that Goodison Park was the place for him.

The approach was perfectly illustrated on the day Kean signed for Everton in the presence of his mother, who was handed a personalised Everton shirt by Brands as he told her: "We will take care of your son."

Joep Schreuder, leading presenter with Dutch state broadcaster NOS, told BBC Sport: "This deal for Moise Kean is typical of Marcel Brands.

"He talks to the wives of the players, to the family. He knows everything - and I mean everything. If Kean has a nephew he will know about him.

"Marcel knows the hard world of money but gives it a personal touch. It is his way of persuading and convincing players to come. He plays the family card. He will know everything about the mother, the father, the family, their circumstances."

Kean has revealed how impressed he was on first meeting with Brands - and it is his attention to detail that proved key in persuading the young Italian and others that Everton is a club on a new footing and the perfect platform for the next stage of a career.

Of course finance plays a big part, but the Kean deal and others were based on a personal presentation given to each prospective signing on how Everton see them working within the squad, analysis of the player, performance statistics, strengths and capabilities, different systems and styles they may be expected to play.

When Everton agreed a deal with Manchester City for Fabian Delph, Brands went to the England midfield man's house to deliver his pitch and presentation.

Kean felt this additional detail demonstrated how much Everton wanted him, how much homework had been done and how they mapped out his future. Brands made it clear to Kean he was a desired investment and not simply a commodity.

Brands used this approach while sporting director at PSV, persuading the in-demand Mexican attacker Hirving Lozano to leave Pachuca for the Dutch club in the summer of 2017. It was a deal six months in the making, including two visits to the player and his family.

Lozano, who helped win the league title in his first season when Brands was still at the club, is now moving to Napoli in a 42m euros deal.

The Brands touch worked on Lozano and it worked on Kean.

Everton also have a three-tier care system for players once they have signed to ensure they have no off-field distractions, so Kean will even have details such as a National Insurance number, mobile phone, car and housing options all dealt with by designated members of staff.

Brands, who has formed a shrewd negotiating partnership with chairman Kenwright, put the full force of his package in front of Kean and completed what may prove to be a transfer of real significance for Everton.

The Brands factor
The 57-year-old Dutchman arrived from PSV in May 2018, replacing Steve Walsh as director of football after his disastrous spell. Such has been his impact that he was appointed to Everton's board seven months after his arrival and placed in charge of overall football strategy at the club.


Marcel Brands told Moise Kean's mother: "We will look after your son"
Kean's acquisition has his imprint all over it - a young player ripe for development placed in the hands of the manager, in this case Marco Silva, to apply the polish.

It is a strategy that has served him well, such as when he acquired the young Georginio Wijnaldum from Feyenoord at PSV in 2011 and when he brought the tyro Mousa Dembele from Willem II to AZ Alkmaar in 2006, the former Spurs midfield man playing a key role in their unlikely Eredivisie title triumph three years later.

"He has an unbelievable knowledge of world football and this Kean deal shows everything about Marcel Brands to me," Schreuder added.

"He is adaptable and creative - remember he did so many smart deals with not so much money at AZ and PSV. He is never lazy and he is so well-connected.

"Marcel is a correct guy with good manners. He talks to families but he can also take coffee with agents such as Raiola and the owners of the big clubs in the world.

"He has signed Kean and it will not be his last like this. He can do other types of deals too.

"Let's say there is a player who is not in a good way at a big club, then Marcel Brands will try to persuade him that there can be new life in football, new fun, that his wife will be happy and then maybe in two years you might move on but first give us two years at Everton. "

Brands has given Everton's transfer strategy the new dimension of a man at the helm whose name means something when he calls the big clubs and agents, an area where Walsh struggled.

Everton have now done three deals with Barcelona for Lucas Digne, Yerry Mina and Andre Gomes and also negotiated smartly with Juventus to sign Kean.

How big is Everton's coup?
Kean has already generated real excitement at Everton, particularly with his explosive cameo as a substitute in the 1-0 win against Watford.

Former Everton winger and BBC Sport pundit Pat Nevin saw a lot of Kean last season - and believes his former club have engineered what could be the best piece of business this summer.

Moise Kean career stats
Team
Appearances Goals
Verona 20 4
Juventus 21 7
Everton 2 0
Italy 3 2
He told BBC Sport: "I can see this being the deal of the season. When I look at the players who have been bought, say like Joelinton at £40m to Newcastle, Kean is miles ahead and the price is cheaper.

"Kean is also much younger. I was staggered by the relatively low price Everton have paid and also thought an Arsenal or a Chelsea might try to get him as well."

He added: "I'm not shocked Everton got him. I just thought they would have to spend a lot more. Three, four or five years down the line he could become an Everton great. He has such potential.

"He has work-rate, match intelligence. I love him as a player and told quite a lot of people about him.

"I don't really go on about that many players. I remember telling people to go and get Virgil van Dijk when he was at Celtic, Kieran Tierney from Celtic. There are very few you think are a no-brainer but, if you have watched Kean often enough, he is. I think this could be a fantastic deal at an incredible price."

Few things I gauged from this...

1. The media really don't know a lot about transfers and people here need to calm down and have a word with themselves during the Summer window. Kean was on our radar for 18 months and we were interested in bringing him in during the January window and it was barely spoken about.

2. Transfers don't just happen overnight and people need to realise the profiling of players more. Brands while at PSV took 6 months to get Lozano there with a couple of visits and persuading/building a relationship with him before they managed to push the signing through.

3. Brands is the epitome of what a good Director of Football should be. A clear strategy and gets about his business in a sufficient and no nonsense manner without any drama. Gets the deal done and moves on but always with a personal touch. A bunch of people were mocking the Kean thing where Brands gave his mum a jersey and told her he'd look after her son but players/families love that. They love to feel wanted and cared about.

4. Yes, the tier system mentioned is highly privileged and it's a bit sad that football has come to the stage of players needing to be 'babysat' so to speak but it ensures that everything is done and is stress free. Making a player feel immediately settled can help ease early nerves.

When we signed Brands to replace Walsh I was a bit nervous as Walsh - despite snapping up Gueye who's our best signing in the last 5 or so years (Digne is rapidly trying to make a case for that though) he made a bunch of meh signings that Brands has now been trying to rectify. He's quality though and makes a very good case as to why every club should have a DoF.
 

Classical Mechanic

Full Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2014
Messages
35,216
Location
xG Zombie Nation
Who are the players that he's signed? Everton seem to spend a lot to tread water.

It depends how good Kean actually is, he could be a dud which is why Juve wanted to cash in.
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
12,557
Didn't Everton spend £50m on Sigurdson and £40m for Iwobi?
 

DWelbz19

Correctly predicted Portugal to win Euro 2016
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
34,026
Transfers don't just happen overnight and people need to realise the profiling of players more. Brands while at PSV took 6 months to get Lozano there with a couple of visits and persuading/building a relationship with him before they managed to push the signing through.
Which probably explains why sometimes teams have ‘free runs’ at a player despite it seeming obvious that another team could equally use that player. Let’s say, Rodri to City.

Equally why a team might only be pursuing one or two players and have no major interest in another. It was van Dijk or bust with Klopp last season.

It probably takes a while to put the same effort into scouting another player on the same level as your initial target.
 

Zlatattack

New Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2017
Messages
7,374
Who does this role for us? I suspect we might not have anyone doing it.
 

SilentWitness

ShoelessWitness
Staff
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
30,500
Supports
Everton
Who are the players that he's signed? Everton seem to spend a lot to tread water.

It depends how good Kean actually is, he could be a dud which is why Juve wanted to cash in.
It's not just signing players, it's moving players on which he's needed to do.

In terms of signings Digne is the leading candidate and he's on par with Robertson as the best LB in the league for me. Gomes at 22m was a fantastic deal as he along with Gylfi are instrumental in what we are trying to do and how we want to play. Delph at 8m is a shrewd signing, experienced individual that's won trophies and can cover a couple of positions. Bernard and Richarlison from last year have both shown to be very good deals too (Yeah, Richarlison would have also been targeted by Silva but he got it over the line and the fee doesn't look stupid anymore).

Kean, Iwobi and Gbamin are all ??? but they clearly all have quality potential. The Kean thing isn't because he's a dud but because of Sarri mainly - other clubs were interested.

He's made a profit on Lookman/Vlasic/Onyekuru too despite them all barely featuring for us (the latter didn't feature for us at all). Our total spend may look high but our net-spend this season is only 30m.

Didn't Everton spend £50m on Sigurdson and £40m for Iwobi?
45m for Gylfi which was before Brands was stated but I don't think it was a bad deal. 13 goals and 6 assists last season and he's vital to how we try to play.

Iwobi was 28m which can rise to 34m - the 40m stuff is nonsense. I think he has resale value too so if it doesn't work out we should be able to recoup something for him. I think he'll come good though, time will tell.
 

Tiber

Full Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2014
Messages
10,278
Didnt he try to buy Rojo? Twice? Or do we only mention when DOFs do good things?
 

SilentWitness

ShoelessWitness
Staff
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
30,500
Supports
Everton
Didnt he try to buy Rojo? Twice? Or do we only mention when DOFs do good things?
Mentioned a few times but I think that whole deal is bollocks. Two summer windows we are randomly in for Rojo around deadline day and two summer windows where it 'collapses' for random reasons.

EDIT: Also the point of the thread wasn't necessarily about who he is signing - but the importance of a DoF in terms of building relationships with signings/profiling of signings/achieving signings and good deals for players that may necessarily not have been interested if there wasn't a DoF who is putting this level of care and attention into a deal.
 

Kag

Full Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2013
Messages
18,875
Location
United Kingdom
Reads like PR spin and internal back-slapping to me. Which is fine, but don’t take it any more seriously than needed.

OMG WE NEED A DOF!!!
 

André Dominguez

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2017
Messages
6,374
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Benfica, Académica
Best example of that is in Portuguese league also. While Porto had Antero Henrique ahead of their structure, they were targeting amazing players overall and they actually recovered from their poor transfer market activity from previous seasons. Who the hell knew Hulk? He was playing at JLeague 2, fro crying out loud :lol:

And that was the main reason PSG hired him in the first place, and he took his team with him.

Nowadays Porto has a more disorganized structure and they even target players above 25 y.o., which is something that can be very harmful in long term at our league, because our clubs only survive with transfers money, since our TV revenue and federation prizes are very low.
 

giorno

boob novice
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
26,592
Supports
Real Madrid
It probably takes a while to put the same effort into scouting another player on the same level as your initial target.
Clubs employ multiple scouts though. They don't scout players one at a time
The Kean thing isn't because he's a dud but because of Sarri mainly - other clubs were interested.
No, it's because he had one year left on his deal and they're in win now mode

The whole higuain came back bit is bullcrap. They've been actively trying to get rid of him all summer, told him outright he was not part of their plans. Player refuses to leave

Kean was simply judged not ready to be a starter, he wanted guarantees of playing time they couldn't give him, and so they had to sell him now to avoid risk of losing him for nothing. Also, they needed the profit
 

Thunderhead

Full Member
Joined
Nov 2, 2016
Messages
3,155
Supports
City
i think they're important but employ the wrong one and it can be worse than employing a wrong manager as the DoF could be buying duds the manager can't work with but the manager gets the boot, the next one is the same yet the DoF just keeps on getting away with mistake after mistake.
 

Gopher Brown

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
4,547
While I understand the need for a DoF, that is not to say we don't have people at least doing a version of this at United. Do you think the Pogba deal or the Lukaku from Everton deal were just last minute - put in a bid and sign them - type deals?

There will be established, long-term targets, but also players sometimes just become attainable.
 

giorno

boob novice
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
26,592
Supports
Real Madrid
i think they're important but employ the wrong one and it can be worse than employing a wrong manager as the DoF could be buying duds the manager can't work with but the manager gets the boot, the next one is the same yet the DoF just keeps on getting away with mistake after mistake.
Then the mistake there is hiring the wrong manager
 

Davie Moyes

Full Member
Joined
May 10, 2013
Messages
786
Location
Up North
I got this guy mixed up with Utd's own Marcel Bout. I was thinking FFS we had this guy at our club and never considered him for DoF!
 

André Dominguez

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2017
Messages
6,374
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Benfica, Académica
i think they're important but employ the wrong one and it can be worse than employing a wrong manager as the DoF could be buying duds the manager can't work with but the manager gets the boot, the next one is the same yet the DoF just keeps on getting away with mistake after mistake.
Usually, the DoF also picks the manager. The whole idea of having a structure like that is that the Department of Football picks managers / players / staff, and ultimately the board approves or disapproves. It's pretty much similar to any major company with shareholders.
 

Bojan Djordjic

Full Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2018
Messages
1,650
I thought this story by Rory Smith about Monchi was excellent in illustrating how a proper football front-office should be run.

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/02/sports/transfer-window-sevilla-monchi.html

I feel the situation at United could not be further from this right now with opportunistic agent-led signings the order of the day and nobody with a helicopter view on what we need to do to build a title-challenging/winning squad. We have carried lots of deadwood for well past their sell-by date and despite us having had major holes in our team for over six years, we go into the new season with substandard/unproven players in about three/four very important positions.

Separately, we need to get much better at data and build a data analytics team before we fall way behind smart established clubs like Liverpool, Spurs and City, not to mention the up and coming clubs like Leicester and a number of the promoted sides who seem capable of identifying great value in the transfer market. Its noticeable how few transfer failures some of these teams have compared to their own recent pasts and more importantly compared to United for the last few years.
 

Bastian

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2015
Messages
18,575
Supports
Mejbri
I don't doubt having a competent DoF can help a club, especially if it is lacking in expertise and authority to utilise said expertise. The recruitment Everton have done recently is promising. I like quite a few of their players. Digne, Richarlison, Bernard, Sigurdsson. All very good players. I assume the first 3 were recruited by Brands. Anyhow, on to the Kean thing. I'm not sure it's as much about personal touch and due diligence as it is about stuffing the pockets of Raiola. We know what sort of a beast he is. I think probably every decent club will put in effort to navigate long-term targets. I'd assume Woodward is a one-off in that regard. It just reads novel because we're all invested in United, so seeing competence elsewhere may feel like "is this the future?". Granted, I know OP is an Everton supporter, but still, we're on a United forum and the obvious benefits of competence, whether in the form of DoF or just a competent hierarchy, seems at times, from a United perspective, utopian.
 

SambaBoy

Full Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2009
Messages
4,225
I feel United are changing their ways for the first time since SAF left. All this scattergun approach is going to be left behind hopefully. We seems to be concentrating on bringing in the best youth players in Europe, players who haven't yet featured for the first team. The lad from Monaco and PSV, as well as a few others.

The market has changed significantly in the last 10 years that the prices for 'punts' are too expensive. The likes of Vidic, Hernandez and Evra would be £30m+ if we were to sign them nowadays. Even in this market, that would be a bargain but for every Vidic, there is a Tosic, Kleberson, Diouf, Bebe etc. We are now delving into even young players with the hope they will in a 3-4 years be able to compete for a place in the first team.

Obviously we are still going to spend significant money but it is more focused on the players ready for the next step like SAF used to do. AWB and Maguire have shown their pedigree in the Prem and looked to be top players for their position without playing for a big club. They still have a lot to prove but the potential to be world beaters in their position is there. James is one of those punts that Fergie would love. Relatively cheap and could be a key player for us down the line if he develops.
 

Grande

Full Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2007
Messages
6,312
Location
The Land of Do-What-You-Will
Mentioned a few times but I think that whole deal is bollocks. Two summer windows we are randomly in for Rojo around deadline day and two summer windows where it 'collapses' for random reasons.

EDIT: Also the point of the thread wasn't necessarily about who he is signing - but the importance of a DoF in terms of building relationships with signings/profiling of signings/achieving signings and good deals for players that may necessarily not have been interested if there wasn't a DoF who is putting this level of care and attention into a deal.
So what’s the verdict on Marcel Brands at this point in time?