Ramos has had a better career than Neuer surely
Best footballer by year of birth
- Thread starter Skills
- Start date
Not over Bobby Charlton.
Fair enough I would have thought. Although Gordon Banks as well was born in 1937. Tough
Last edited:
Neuer basically redefined, or at the very least perfected an entire position and has cemented the term "Sweeper Keeper" into the modern football lexicon.
Sergio Ramos had nice hair.
Belgium absolutely took the piss in '91. Two of the very best players of this generation born within 6 months of each other in towns just over 100km apart.
Buffon, 1978.
73 Roberto Carlos
74 Del Piero
79 Pirlo
74 Del Piero
79 Pirlo
50 - Lato
51 - Keegan
52 - Simonsen
53 - Zico
54 - Kempes
55 - Platini
56 - Rossi
57 - Elkjaer
58 - Sanchez
59 - Schuster
51 - Keegan
52 - Simonsen
53 - Zico
54 - Kempes
55 - Platini
56 - Rossi
57 - Elkjaer
58 - Sanchez
59 - Schuster
Damn you all for ruining my sleep when I need it - but this was too fun not to try 
1901 Ricardo Zamora
1902 Josep Samitier
1905 Guilermo Stabile
1907 Dixie Dean
1908 Eddie Hapgood
1909 Oldrich Nejedly
1910 Giuseppe Meazza
1911 Antonio Sastre
1913 Leonidas/Silvio Piola
1914 Attilio Garcia
1915 Stanley Matthews
1916 Jose Manuel Moreno
1917 Larbi Benbarek
1919 Valentina Mazzola
1920 Fritz Walter
1921 Gunnar Nordahl
1922 Tom Finney
1925 Juan Schiaffino/Nat Lofthouse
1926 Alfredo di Stefano
1927 Ladislao Kubala
1928 Didi
1929 Sandor Kocsis
1931 John Charles
1935 Luis Suarez (Spain - not Uruguay) / Omar Sivori
1936 Duncan Edwards
1937 Bobby Charlton
1938 Jose Altafini
1939 Amancio Amaro
1940 Pele
1941 Bobby Moore
1942 Eusebio
1943 Gianni Rivera
1944 Jairzinho
1945 Franz Beckenbauer
1946 Roberto Rivellino/George Best
1947 Johan Cruyff
1948 Ray Clemence
1949 Ruud Krol
1950 Grzegors Lato
1951 Johan Neeskens
1952 Allan Simonsen
1953 Zico/Scirea/Gentile
1954 Socrates
1955 Michel Platini
1956 Paolo Rossi
1957 Glenn Hoddle
1958 Hugo Sanchez
1959 Carlo Ancelotti
1960 Diego Maradona
1961 Lothar Mattheus
1962 Ruud Gullitt
1963 Ronald Koeman
1964 Marco Van Basten
1965 Gheorghe Hagi
1901 Ricardo Zamora
1902 Josep Samitier
1905 Guilermo Stabile
1907 Dixie Dean
1908 Eddie Hapgood
1909 Oldrich Nejedly
1910 Giuseppe Meazza
1911 Antonio Sastre
1913 Leonidas/Silvio Piola
1914 Attilio Garcia
1915 Stanley Matthews
1916 Jose Manuel Moreno
1917 Larbi Benbarek
1919 Valentina Mazzola
1920 Fritz Walter
1921 Gunnar Nordahl
1922 Tom Finney
1925 Juan Schiaffino/Nat Lofthouse
1926 Alfredo di Stefano
1927 Ladislao Kubala
1928 Didi
1929 Sandor Kocsis
1931 John Charles
1935 Luis Suarez (Spain - not Uruguay) / Omar Sivori
1936 Duncan Edwards
1937 Bobby Charlton
1938 Jose Altafini
1939 Amancio Amaro
1940 Pele
1941 Bobby Moore
1942 Eusebio
1943 Gianni Rivera
1944 Jairzinho
1945 Franz Beckenbauer
1946 Roberto Rivellino/George Best
1947 Johan Cruyff
1948 Ray Clemence
1949 Ruud Krol
1950 Grzegors Lato
1951 Johan Neeskens
1952 Allan Simonsen
1953 Zico/Scirea/Gentile
1954 Socrates
1955 Michel Platini
1956 Paolo Rossi
1957 Glenn Hoddle
1958 Hugo Sanchez
1959 Carlo Ancelotti
1960 Diego Maradona
1961 Lothar Mattheus
1962 Ruud Gullitt
1963 Ronald Koeman
1964 Marco Van Basten
1965 Gheorghe Hagi
Not over Puskas and Yashin
The thread is about best footballers for each year, which would translate to having more accomplishments (individual or otherwise), not your random metric in your head.
Neuer has had fewer years at the top, he got into the picture later, and got out of it sooner than Ramos.
Neuer is one of the most overrated players ever. His amazing sweeper keeper style has got him in loads of trouble over the years. Well overrated. If he was a premiership keeper the media would destroy his stupidity.
1972 is ridiculously stacked. Zidane, Rivaldo, Figo and Nedved were all born that year.
1970 - Cafu
1971 - Keane
1972 - Zidane
1973 - Giggs
1974 - Del Piero
1975 - Beckham
1976 - Ronaldo
1977 - Henry
1978 - Buffon
1979 - Pirlo
1980 - Ronaldinho
1981 - Ibrahimovic
1982 - Kaka
1983 - Ribery
1984 - Iniesta
1985 - Ronaldo
1986 - Ramos
1987 - Messi
1988 - Aguero
1989 - Bale
1990 - Kroos
1991 - Hazard
1992 - Neymar
1993 - Kane
1994 - Sterling
1995 - Kimmich
1996 - Sane
1997 - Lautaro
1998 - Mbappe
1999 - Felix
2000 - Sancho
1971 - Keane
1972 - Zidane
1973 - Giggs
1974 - Del Piero
1975 - Beckham
1976 - Ronaldo
1977 - Henry
1978 - Buffon
1979 - Pirlo
1980 - Ronaldinho
1981 - Ibrahimovic
1982 - Kaka
1983 - Ribery
1984 - Iniesta
1985 - Ronaldo
1986 - Ramos
1987 - Messi
1988 - Aguero
1989 - Bale
1990 - Kroos
1991 - Hazard
1992 - Neymar
1993 - Kane
1994 - Sterling
1995 - Kimmich
1996 - Sane
1997 - Lautaro
1998 - Mbappe
1999 - Felix
2000 - Sancho
Did the OP really manage to squeeze Freddy Edu into this list and have him tied with Bale?? 
1974: Me ;-)
1974: Me ;-)
1988 isn't highly debatable. I'd probably go with Agüero but Lewandowski and Sanchéz are also in the picture and personally I'm partial to Marcelo. Simply the most enjoyable full back that I've watched and an excellent footballer. Yeah, I'm going with Marcelo for the '88 slot.
2004 - Youssoufa Moukoko c/o Borussia Dortmund
Surely Pelé for 1940?
Ok - I ll give you that one. I actually had a hard time finding good footballers from 1957...anyone ?
Oh. How could he go missing? Yes, surely
1988 - Mesut Ozil
Must be Rinat Dasaev for 1957
1977 - Henry?
Ronaldinho and I born in the same year. It was a close call, but I graciously accept defeat to that lovable goofy toothed bastard.
Xavi says “hi” then
It would be an extremely close call. Almost like 1945 (Beckenbauer and Gerd Muller)
I thought about Robson, but think Dasaev was clearly a higher calibre player (it shouldn’t matter that Robson played for Man Utd - it’s similar with Romario who is clearly ahead of Cantona for 1966)Although Dasayev is also a good shout, @Alemar. Arguably the best goalkeeper of the 1980s!
Preben Elkjaer. Best striker of the mid 80's
1966 - Hristo Stoichkov
My birth year : 1986
Player: David Silva
Player: David Silva
Freddie Adu when he was young was hailed as the next Pele. He flopped big time despite all this hype following him for years.Why the hell is Freddy Adu there?
My birth year, 1984, is Iniesta, without a doubt.
It’s actually unbelievable how much weaker representatives of current generation are on the list compared to historical figures.
Starting from 1988 year of birth onwards, there is only one player who might be compared with the likes of Cruyff, van Basten, Di Stefano etc - Mbappe (and even then he is only a prospect and will need to fulfil potential to become a true great). All the rest are a tier (if not two or three) below even
Starting from 1988 year of birth onwards, there is only one player who might be compared with the likes of Cruyff, van Basten, Di Stefano etc - Mbappe (and even then he is only a prospect and will need to fulfil potential to become a true great). All the rest are a tier (if not two or three) below even
Over Casillas? I would say it is unlikely
I am biased, prefer attacking players. Very difficult to compare goalkeepers with defenders or attackers.
That being said, Casillas was a beast in his peak and has had a great career.
Not just you - many people are biased in this way
It's not a coincidence that only Yashin has ever won Ballon D'Or as a goalkeeperExactly why I'm asking why he's there.
Seeing all those other names and then seeing his was jarring.
2018 - Jesse Lingard
Are goalkeepers really footballers?
Ridiculous. “The British media would destroy his stupidity.”
You’re talking about Manuel Neuer, not about what reactions to posts like yours should really consist of.
Xabi Alonso has also played with prime Casillas for ages but called Neuer “by far the best goalkeeper he had ever played with” after only a couple of months of being at Bayern.
Aside of completely inventing and defining the role of the “modern” goalkeeper, he’s also an insane shot stopper, as well as very dominant in the box. Here’s a video for you with just reflex saves and no sweeping, should you have forgotten that he can keep shots out too.
Last edited:
1872 Joe Cassidy
1874 Billy Meredith
1884 Sandy Turnbull
1885 George Wall
1886 Enoch James West
1898 Joseph Spence
1918 Jack Rowley
1919 Johnny Carey
1929 Roger Byrne
1932 Bill Foulkes
1933 Dennis Viollet
1934 David Herd
1936 Duncan Edwards
1937 Bobby Charlton
1940 Denis Law
1941 Tony Dunne
1942 Alex Stepney
1946 George Best
1949 Martin Buchan
1955 Steve Coppell
1956 Frank Stapleton
1957 Bryan Robson
1960 Steve Bruce
1963 Peter Schmeichel
1965 Denis Irwin
1966 Eric Cantona
1970 Edwin van der Sar
1971 Roy Keane
1972 Jaap Stam
1973 Ryan Giggs
1974 Paul Scholes
1975 Gary Neville
1976 Ruud van Nistelrooy
1977 Phil Neville
1978 Rio Ferdinand
1979 Wes Brown
1980 Alan Smith
1981 Nemanja Vidić
1983 Robin van Persie
1984 Darren Fletcher
1985 Wayne Rooney
1986 Luis Nani
1987 Marouane Fellaini
1988 Javier Hernandez
1989 Chris Smalling
1990 David De Gea
1992 Phil Jones
1995 Anthony Martial
1997 Marcus Rashford
1874 Billy Meredith
1884 Sandy Turnbull
1885 George Wall
1886 Enoch James West
1898 Joseph Spence
1918 Jack Rowley
1919 Johnny Carey
1929 Roger Byrne
1932 Bill Foulkes
1933 Dennis Viollet
1934 David Herd
1936 Duncan Edwards
1937 Bobby Charlton
1940 Denis Law
1941 Tony Dunne
1942 Alex Stepney
1946 George Best
1949 Martin Buchan
1955 Steve Coppell
1956 Frank Stapleton
1957 Bryan Robson
1960 Steve Bruce
1963 Peter Schmeichel
1965 Denis Irwin
1966 Eric Cantona
1970 Edwin van der Sar
1971 Roy Keane
1972 Jaap Stam
1973 Ryan Giggs
1974 Paul Scholes
1975 Gary Neville
1976 Ruud van Nistelrooy
1977 Phil Neville
1978 Rio Ferdinand
1979 Wes Brown
1980 Alan Smith
1981 Nemanja Vidić
1983 Robin van Persie
1984 Darren Fletcher
1985 Wayne Rooney
1986 Luis Nani
1987 Marouane Fellaini
1988 Javier Hernandez
1989 Chris Smalling
1990 David De Gea
1992 Phil Jones
1995 Anthony Martial
1997 Marcus Rashford