Bobby Charlton talks youth

032Devil

Full Member
Joined
Oct 26, 2004
Messages
22,146
"United are the best producers of youngsters in England.

I remember going to see Alex at the training ground a few years ago and was told he was out on pitch 11 or something. On the way over I saw this young lad weave past about three players and smash the ball into the top corner and thought ‘wow’. Alex told me ‘That’s young Ryan Giggs and we have just signed him this morning.’

I got exactly the same sensation watching us in the FA Youth Cup quarter-finals last season, only this time it was about defenders and midfielders. There were four or five of them and I remember thinking ‘wow’ again — I’ve never been so impressed.

I don’t know how other teams work, but we get our fair share of good players because of the way we work and the coaching staff we have attracts the best.”

***

Sounds good. For those of you in the know, who do you think Sir Bobby was raving about?
 

oskarutd

Full Member
Joined
May 25, 2004
Messages
2,150
Location
Norway
032Devil said:
"United are the best producers of youngsters in England.

I remember going to see Alex at the training ground a few years ago and was told he was out on pitch 11 or something. On the way over I saw this young lad weave past about three players and smash the ball into the top corner and thought ‘wow’. Alex told me ‘That’s young Ryan Giggs and we have just signed him this morning.’

I got exactly the same sensation watching us in the FA Youth Cup quarter-finals last season, only this time it was about defenders and midfielders. There were four or five of them and I remember thinking ‘wow’ again — I’ve never been so impressed.

I don’t know how other teams work, but we get our fair share of good players because of the way we work and the coaching staff we have attracts the best.”

***

Sounds good. For those of you in the know, who do you think Sir Bobby was raving about?
The team :
Zieler
Gray Cathcart Shawcross Lee
Mullan Hewson Gibson Rose
Campbell Evans, S

Cathcart and Gibson for sure,
Take a pick from the others.

We lost 0-1 to City, we were miles better, but needed more urgency and speed in our play.
 

032Devil

Full Member
Joined
Oct 26, 2004
Messages
22,146
oskarutd said:
The team :
Zieler
Gray Cathcart Shawcross Lee
Mullan Hewson Gibson Rose
Campbell Evans, S

Cathcart and Gibson for sure,
Take a pick from the others.

We lost 0-1 to City, we were miles better, but needed more urgency and speed in our play.

Chalton's given some of them the "wow-factor", considering that who do you honestly believe will make it amongst that team?
 

oskarutd

Full Member
Joined
May 25, 2004
Messages
2,150
Location
Norway
032Devil said:
Chalton's given some of them the "wow-factor", considering that who do you honestly believe will make it amongst that team?
That´s at least very promising. Nothing is certain. Should we say biggest amount of first teamers since the class of ´92?
 

SpaceMatlock

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 29, 2005
Messages
766
Location
Manchester
Lots of good things were said of the youth team that won the cup in 2003 but of that team only Bardsley and Richardson have had any first team impact. Of course David Jones still stands a chance but many bright prospects like Blake just aren't getting the oppurtunity anymore.
 

Red17

Full Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
2,978
032Devil said:
Sounds good. For those of you in the know, who do you think Sir Bobby was raving about?
My bet is on Craig Cathcart, Darron Gibson, Kieran Lee, Danny Rose & Mullan.

Though I think the most promising of the batch is Johnny Evans although he wasn't playing that particular game - groin injury. And I think Campbell has all the attributes to be a top striker although it's notoriously difficult to predict how a striker will develop, especially in a top club like United. Giuseppe excepted :drool:

I'd go so far to say that individually, these named youngsters are a cut above the 2003 batch.
 

londonredmaniac

I suffer delusions of grandeur
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
18,655
Location
Mid life crisis
SpaceMatlock said:
Lots of good things were said of the youth team that won the cup in 2003 but of that team only Bardsley and Richardson have had any first team impact. Of course David Jones still stands a chance but many bright prospects like Blake just aren't getting the oppurtunity anymore.
expectation has played some part in that. these players are expected to bed in instantly in todays game
 

oskarutd

Full Member
Joined
May 25, 2004
Messages
2,150
Location
Norway
SpaceMatlock said:
Lots of good things were said of the youth team that won the cup in 2003 but of that team only Bardsley and Richardson have had any first team impact. Of course David Jones still stands a chance but many bright prospects like Blake just aren't getting the oppurtunity anymore.
Eagles and Steele have also possibilities, McShane was in that team to. But all in all, 2-3 is pretty good.