Interesting to see people using players that were never really top first eleven starters for the club to use as an argument to justify Fred being good?
Herrera was a great personality at the club but really only had one decent season, Butt was a reliable and solid midfielder who could always do a good job, but he was limited and very much a quality squad player.
So why are we using those players as examples to justify a huge outlay on Fred? Also, personally Herrera was a much more reliable player than Fred and I was never mad on him and Butt was certainly more reliable and consistent and had better perfdormances when starting that Fed has....consdering he hardly started that says a lot.
I wouldnt even compare Fred with Anderson who was very promisign in his first eighteeen months before the fitness issues really hit. Fred is more compatable wih Djemba Djemba or Klerberson as he has been a flop.
How are people saying he has been one of our better players the last two or three years. Even in a side generally performing terrible he is still low down the peking order.
Fred is good battling in midfield or following a player....but positionally and intelligence wise he is lacking. He has played best further forward....but there is no end produt. His shooting is all over the place consistency wise, his retaining possesion against a press is awful, his consistency of pretty simple passes is awful and his creativiy or awareness isnt there.
He seems to havea good attitude and always works hard, that should be the minimum and that simply isnt enough to play for Manchester United. COnsidering the fee he is the worst signings we have made in terms of a player that has made a lot of apperances. I mean DOnny for example is obviously a flop, but he isnt playing. Fred is and has for several seasons.
Id happily be rid of McFred and VDB, make a big summer signing and give squad places to Hannibal and Mainoo....this "he is a useful squad member" seems to be bandied about for far too many players here the last few years who simply arent good enough, are on good wages and cost a lot of money