Discussion in 'Manchester United Forum' started by #07, Apr 24, 2018.
Tweet— Twitter API (@user) date
Tweet— Twitter API (@user) date
Bigging him up a lot at the moment. As my fave player I am cool with this
Herrera is always a big mystery to me. When he is good he is really good. But Mourinho would drop him for a few months during which he was not injured, so what went missing? Or put in in another perspective - why can't Herrera keep playing consistent football week in week out?
p.s. we all know Pogba can be a great player when and if he set his mind on the job, just hope he will switch on during big game.
I've heard Howson from Full Time Devils say Mourinho dropped Herrera cos Herrera refused to sign a new deal.
That's another reason I found this piece from Mitten interesting, since Andy's saying Ander has no intention of leaving United.
Who knows what the truth is? I guess both have their sources.
I honestly thought he was destined to leave in the summer, but can't for the life of me see him going anywhere now, and rightfully so. He's delivered.
He was brilliant V Spurs, and I really like him as a player. When he is on form he gives a lot of balance to the midfield, and our best team atm is surely with him in a midfield 3 with Pogba and Matic. He has been poor this season though, his worst season for us imo, and thats probably the simple reason that he got dropped.
In some games maybe. At home to West Brom it was a waste of time having three midfielders.
Really don’t know with Herrera but there’s a distinct possibility that his mind hasn’t been on the job with serious legal stuff hanging over his head. There’s definitely a player in there, so just hoping it’ll come out now.
It depends on how we play. City always play with a three man midfield and it doesn't harm them.
Honestly, I didn't think the first half against West Brom was that bad. In my opinion, Mourinho blinked first by switching to 4-2-3-1 at half time. That left us vulnerable to the counter attack and we were no more of an attacking threat, as our full backs either could not or would not try and take on their opposite numbers. Had we stuck with the 4-3-3, as we did a few days later against Bournemouth, I'm sure eventually we would've ground West Brom down and escaped with a 1-0.
4-3-3 should be our default shape.
Not with players like Herrera and Matic they don’t. It works for them because they play attackers there. We lost any attacking threat because within ten minutes we took off another midfielder and lost any shape at all.
We'd be stupid to sell him.
I like him, but he's too inconsistent to be starting in our midfield. Let's be honest here.
We can't be relying on players that put in a shift for a few big games, then revert back to nothing form. That's been Herrera throughout his United career.
Even though his form was poor earlier in the season, he's still the very definition of a big games player.
Might as well sell Pogba then
Herrera showed genuine leadership qualities with the way he stepped up in that second half, a proper captains performance that (minus the armband of course).
If Herrera could play like he did from 25 minutes onwards @ Wembley on Saturday he'd be one of the first names on the teamsheet, if he plays like he did in the first 25 minutes, or how he's played for most of his time at United he's not even worth a place in the squad.
Maybe we should put him in cold-storage, and just bring him out when we're playing sides from the Capital in must win games.
wouldve been absoutely fine if we had 2 proper wingers. Problem wasnt the 3 in the middle, it was the lack of balance, pace and creativity. But thats for another debate!
Come on. Fellaini refused to renew and Mourinho still started him ahead of Pogba. I don't think Mourinho would take this into consideration unless you refuse to train etc. I really like to know what was the missing factor on a Herrera down day, that somehow the coaching team fail to ignite it on a consistent basis.
See him as rotation option for Matic and a tactical option in certain games. Basically the new Fletcher.
He'll probably suffer when we bring in a new midfielder but hopefully he's willing to play the squad role
Playing 433 against WBA was a practise match for Spurs. In fact, I think Mourinho would have rested most of the key players during mid-week game if the Sat game wasn't such a disaster.
Valencia and Young have got that covered.. Hasn´t Smalling been captain couple of times? I think Jose thinks the captain must speak English if he isn´t Valencia..
Our best XI includes him. Simples.
You need a few bastards in your team too. Something we've lacked in recent years.
Separate names with a comma.