This is basically what the club would be working with here. Though they own the freight terminal there's probably a long lease on it and it's not something that could be easily relocated.
New Stadium or Revamp Old Trafford
- Thread starter Ian Reus
- Start date
-
Hello, Guest! We have two new competitions (with taglines and awards as prizes) starting for the new Premier League season.
A new Premier League Predictions competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for MD1.
A new Last Man Standing competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for MD1.
For Last Man Standing you have until the 16th August to submit your predictions. Submissions will be open for the next 20 days, 17 hours, 15 minutes, 5 seconds, and will close on Aug 16, 2024 at 20:00.
Bonus: for fans of Odds or Evens, the thread will be going up mid-August with a deadline for after the transfer window shuts.
This is basically what the club would be working with here. Though they own the freight terminal there's probably a long lease on it and it's not something that could be easily relocated.
This is basically what the club would be working with here. Though they own the freight terminal there's probably a long lease on it and it's not something that could be easily relocated.
I didn't think about the lease issue. I guess they'd have to buy that out to make this work. I am guessing that's part of the £2bn estimate that's been floated for the new stadium.
Old Trafford is historic. Everything the ground has been through, the teams and players it's been home to, and everything that goes with it, it's where United belong. Rebuild it, should absolutely not be a new stadium.
What would rebuilding it in the same location acheive? The whole reason we're talking about it is because that site has reached the maximum capacity for its footprint and it was designed with much less space per person than modern grounds. So we could spend billions on making a new stadium in the same place that would hold fewer people. How many businesses do you see doing that?
If that's even possible in the contract as I said there's not many places that freight terminal could move to.
Why would it need to be on the exact same space? Spurs didn't do that, moved over slightly where there was more room and built from there. Is there seriously no way the ground couldn't be moved and build a modern version of Old Trafford? I simply don't want us going down the route most other clubs are, with big new grounds that are just soulless places. I'd far rather keep the aesthetic of Old Trafford with everything attached to it.
Spoken like a true sheikh supporter. I bet you're one of them who wanted a Sugar Daddy right? Sure just throw all history and everything else out of the window and become a soulless piece of shit oil club.
I know it's not in Rattys plans, but if a new stadium were to be built, what features/fluff would yoy like to see?
A proper outdoor fan area around the stadium like in cricket.
How did you infer that from a post about the capacity of a stadium? I'm not even saying I'm in favour of a new stadium, just discussing the actual physical properties of a given space.
Very weird post. A real waste of your handful. I'm very much anti-oligarch involvement in football and pro fan ownership, by the way. Not that it matters, or is ever going to happen, sadly. We're way past the point of no return on that.
Rebuilding by the very nature of the word means it would have the be on the same space. Anything other than that is a new stadium.
If Spurs can do it, then we can. It's just a big loan. We don't need Qatar money.
It won't be dated in 20 years, more like 50.
It's shitty that Everton will have a better stadium than us. No disrespect to Everton but we're much bigger and our stadium should reflect that.
I'm happy with the alternative of just incremental improvements also but the South Stand and railway line will always be a problem.
Lick of paint is all that's needed
There aren't many iconic football stadiums left, so losing one of the most famous would be a damn shame. It'd be like the Cubs tearing down Wrigley or the Red Sox tearing down Fenway.
We have the Glazers and we're already £1 Billion in debt. And at a time when it's a really bad time to borrow. We won't be getting a new stadium plas the guy taking over has said he'd prefer to redevelop OT.
Rebuild the Sir Bobby stand, retain the Munich tunnel but add that second or third tier, space the seats out a bit, give it a class leading concourse and hold it up as a a fitting tribute to the great man. You could even have a statue of Sir Bobby looking down from the roof like the skinny chicken on spurs stadium.
Then redesign the roof and add some screens.
Then redesign the roof and add some screens.
I’m not opposed to a demo and rebuild, but the structure itself truly is of historic value. Of course in the UK even buildings that are a only a century old are considered pikers but so much lived history was lived in the physical building known as Old Trafford that it seems pedantic to consider it as having little historic value, even if it is true that the current structure bears no resemblance to the original structure.
The trouble with that is the Munich Tunnel is absolutely the worst part of the ground in terms of accessing and exiting on a match day. And adding another tier without simultaneously extending to the south of the stand can't be done to the same extent as the rest of the ground.
As much as we'd all like to see a 100K (or thereabouts) seater stadium, the main stumbling block will be getting planning permission for such an expansion - since the police will have a major say in the process. And they are not happy about parking arrangements at present! Another 10k cars requiring spaces are not likely to be tolerated by residents of the surrounding area, and we're currently talking about a couple of miles around the ground! So unless we can come up with additional parking or alternative travel arrangements, we're screwed.
Juventus did it. But mostly because they couldn't fill the Delli Alpi.
We would rebuild on the car park but overlap the footprint partially with the existing stadium. Final quadrant would be delivered once old Trafford had been demolished making most efficient use of space whilst minimising down time.
A transparent glass Aquarium as the players tunnel.
Can the train track issues, as well as the homes in close proximity be overcome?
I wouldn't have thought so without spending hundreds of millions more. People used to say the club was buying up any houses that became available on Railway Road, but that doesn't appear to be true.
The south stand is the issue, to extend it it's not just the railway lines to build over, you have residential housing to consider, I'm under the impression united bought up lots of the homes parallel to the south stand but I'd imagine some if not most are still privately owned including some new build properties, I'd be interested to see how the club could tackle this, I'd imagine throwing money at people but if one person doesn't want to budge, what happens? then there's all the side streets to factor in and the disruption caused by such a huge amount of building work.
It would seem like a logistical nightmare to build over a railway track and compulsory purchase peoples homes, if that is even possible.
It feels like South stand development is the only thing worth doing. And even then, what is the value in adding a second, or even third tier to the South stand, when the rest of the stadium is old and lacking in facilities and space?
You would think they would need to buy both sides of the street. Just doesn't seem worth it when the rest of the stadium is also dated.
This would actually be awesome.
Gary Neville armwrestling Carragher in a parking lot
With animated cracks over the heads of the opposing team so they piss their pants before coming onto the pitch.
I'll re-grout the pool for a fair fee
Revamp it, not a new one. Too much history in that stadium.
Triggers broom
But isn't that like insisting on driving your old rusting Ford Cortina for nostalgia's sake whilst everyone else is upgrading to the latest BMW or Mercedes?
Unsure I'd want to see that - considering Carragher would almost surely win every time
Just watching the ladies Derby and the lights and pyro at OT are very impressive. Have we done that kind of thing before?
Life in the old ground yet! Renovation and modernisation is the way forward!
Life in the old ground yet! Renovation and modernisation is the way forward!
250m only buys paint and plaster.
You are right. We shouldn’t try. Everything is futile, why bother?
Yes that's the spirit you will do well here.You are right. We shouldn’t try. Everything is futile, why bother?