Players leaving? Who would you replace them with?

jesperjaap

Full Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2014
Messages
5,990
DeGea, Bailly, Valencia, Herrera, Pogba, Mata, Sanchez, Lukaku - Some of the bigger names linked with exits this summer, if they were to leave, who would you replace them with? A top four finish could decide ins and outs quite a lot of course.

DeGea - Well most of the good keepers are already at big clubs. And for me beign the best keeper in the world he is pretty ireplacable. Oblak is the obvious choice, but with DeGeas contract we could end up paying millions more for him. Donnaruma is probably the best young keeper in the world and would be a good signing. I think we have a great number two who can play as our number one anyway in Romero, with that in mind Svilar isnt a bad cheaper option.

Bailly - With Rojo more than likely leaving too, I think bringing in £50m if we are signing one centre back, the fee isnt a concern. I think De Ligt will end up at Barcelona. Koulibaily is the obvious choice, a great centre back. Personally I would love two centre backs, which I really dont think can happen if we buy Koulibaily, I would love Upemecano, his build, strength and power reminds me to a degree of Sol Campbell, Romagnoli I also think is an excellent centre back.

Valencia - Well we have DAlot, would love Bissaka though, think he is a special player and ticks a lot of boxes

Herrera and Pogba - Well with Matic showing signs of being past his peak, this could be a worry, as that could be our whole first choice midfield needing replacing. We have Garner and Gomes coming through and McTominay and Perreira to me look like good squad players, I dont see them as first choice players though. Add how poor Fred has been and we could be seriously short quality wise. Rice, Ascacibar, NDombele, Guimaraes, Rodri, Saul, Tielemans, Tonali. A lot of them would be a risk, but there are some fantastic young midfielders around at the moment.

Mata and Sanchez - Age, wages and general performance wise, though I am a fan of both players....not really a fan of either as players for us. I think with Greenwood and Chong coming through and how poor and inconsistant Sanchez in particular has been we dont need to do much. I would love Sancho though, to replace Lingard as first choice as much as anything. Lozano I also think is very under rated on here and a good buy for the price....I would consider him as another option fo rthe left, maybe moving Martial inside in if Lukaku moves

Lukaku - If we can recoup the fee, be great business, guarantees lots of goals in patches, and work rate....for me he offers very little in build up play and when he isnt at his best, he is truly awful. Also criminal for £75m his first touch is abysmal Would probably move Martial inside as a send striker option if he leaves and we have th enumbers out wide. As Rashford is first choice I dont see how we would spend a fortune reaplcing Lukaku anyway, I dont really have much idea who I would sign. Probably another really hot youngster, Lincoln the very little I have seen of him looks a similar like fo rlike replacement with more technique at probably half the cost. Gouri of Lyon looked fantastic for France youth levels, not sure he has even come back from injury though or is anywhere near ready subsequently for a big move
 
Would Donnarumma be a good signing for us? I've never seen him play but someone I know seems to think he's gonna be amongst the very best.
 
Valencia, Darmian, Rojo; Tuanzebe and Laird.
Mata; Greenwood.

These players should leave regardless.

Players that might leave and would need replacing:

Herrera; Anyone among the likes of Brandt, Partey, Barella, Pellegrini, Rabiot etc. As long as we do not spend £50m on another Fred we should be satisfied. Herrera, despite his heart and effort, is not the hardest player to replace.

DDG; If we can 75% of Oblaks clause for DDG then we got it all sorted. Might turn out to be a great deal for the the club in the long run.

Lukaku; Do not think he will be that difficult to replace him as we already got Rashford and Martial that should primarily be used as strikers.

Pogba is the only player that is difficult to replace, since most of our attacking game is dependent on him. The rest of the players in the squad can be replaced with similar quality or better for around the same price as they would fetch us, but replacing Pogba would mean that the team will have to adapt and find new ways to attack(something that should happen with or without Pogba).
 
Would Donnarumma be a good signing for us? I've never seen him play but someone I know seems to think he's gonna be amongst the very best.

Seen him probably only 7-8 times myself. He has the presence of a Schmeichel or a Neur, big frame and commands his area well. Virtually every game I have seen him he has made an amazing save and done something pretty poor, usually with his feet. Think as a long term signing he would be brilliant, but a bit like DeGea frustrated with his handling in the area, I think people expecting him to come in and be one of the best straight away may be too hopeful. I really hope DeGea stays, think he is the best in the world at the moment (still think VDS and Schmeichel were both better though).
 
Valencia, Darmian, Rojo; Tuanzebe and Laird.
Mata; Greenwood.

These players should leave regardless.

Players that might leave and would need replacing:

Herrera; Anyone among the likes of Brandt, Partey, Barella, Pellegrini, Rabiot etc. As long as we do not spend £50m on another Fred we should be satisfied. Herrera, despite his heart and effort, is not the hardest player to replace.

DDG; If we can 75% of Oblaks clause for DDG then we got it all sorted. Might turn out to be a great deal for the the club in the long run.

Lukaku; Do not think he will be that difficult to replace him as we already got Rashford and Martial that should primarily be used as strikers.

Pogba is the only player that is difficult to replace, since most of our attacking game is dependent on him. The rest of the players in the squad can be replaced with similar quality or better for around the same price as they would fetch us, but replacing Pogba would mean that the team will have to adapt and find new ways to attack(something that should happen with or without Pogba).

I agree pretty much with your thoughts on the players in terms of replacing....if they all leave in midfield hard to replace though as very short. I dont understand your "should leave regardless" list though? Are you wanting Laird and Greenwood to go out on loan or leave leave? With Young signing another year and if we sign another full back I can understand loaning Laird, but Greenwood surely will be getting lots of opportunities next season, especially if Mata, Sanchez for example leave.
 
De Gea - Oblak

Sanchez - Sancho

Mata - Zaha

Pogba - Renato Sanches and Neves

Bailly - Koulibaly

Valencia - Ricardo Pereira

Rojo - Recall Tuanzebe

Lukaku - Nobody. Zaha could play down the middle aswell.

Oblak
Pereira Koulibaly Lindelöf Shaw
Matic
Neves Sanches
Sancho Rashford Martial

Subs: Zaha, Smalling, McTominay, Lingard, Tuanzebe
 
De Gea - Oblak

Sanchez - Sancho

Mata - Zaha

Pogba - Renato Sanches and Neves

Bailly - Koulibaly

Valencia - Ricardo Pereira

Rojo - Recall Tuanzebe

Lukaku - Nobody. Zaha could play down the middle aswell.

Oblak
Pereira Koulibaly Lindelöf Shaw
Matic
Neves Sanches
Sancho Rashford Martial

Subs: Zaha, Smalling, McTominay, Lingard, Tuanzebe
You'd replace Pogba with Renato Sanches and Ruben Neves?
 
De Gea... ideally Oblak, if we are unable to sign him then Romero for a year than Dean Henderson.

Rojo, Darmian, Valencia, Bailly... Wan-Bissaka, Alderweireld, Manolas, Filipe Luís (free)

Pogba, Herrera... any three of Bruno Fernandes, Ndombele, Neves, Rodri, Rice.

Mata, Lukaku, Sanchez.... Sancho, if not then Nicolas Pepe, CHO if not then Hirving Lozano & Luka Jović.
 
DeGea, Bailly, Valencia, Herrera, Pogba, Mata, Sanchez, Lukaku - Some of the bigger names linked with exits this summer, if they were to leave, who would you replace them with? A top four finish could decide ins and outs quite a lot of course.

DeGea - Well most of the good keepers are already at big clubs. And for me beign the best keeper in the world he is pretty ireplacable. Oblak is the obvious choice, but with DeGeas contract we could end up paying millions more for him. Donnaruma is probably the best young keeper in the world and would be a good signing. I think we have a great number two who can play as our number one anyway in Romero, with that in mind Svilar isnt a bad cheaper option.

Bailly - With Rojo more than likely leaving too, I think bringing in £50m if we are signing one centre back, the fee isnt a concern. I think De Ligt will end up at Barcelona. Koulibaily is the obvious choice, a great centre back. Personally I would love two centre backs, which I really dont think can happen if we buy Koulibaily, I would love Upemecano, his build, strength and power reminds me to a degree of Sol Campbell, Romagnoli I also think is an excellent centre back.

Valencia - Well we have DAlot, would love Bissaka though, think he is a special player and ticks a lot of boxes

Herrera and Pogba - Well with Matic showing signs of being past his peak, this could be a worry, as that could be our whole first choice midfield needing replacing. We have Garner and Gomes coming through and McTominay and Perreira to me look like good squad players, I dont see them as first choice players though. Add how poor Fred has been and we could be seriously short quality wise. Rice, Ascacibar, NDombele, Guimaraes, Rodri, Saul, Tielemans, Tonali. A lot of them would be a risk, but there are some fantastic young midfielders around at the moment.

Mata and Sanchez - Age, wages and general performance wise, though I am a fan of both players....not really a fan of either as players for us. I think with Greenwood and Chong coming through and how poor and inconsistant Sanchez in particular has been we dont need to do much. I would love Sancho though, to replace Lingard as first choice as much as anything. Lozano I also think is very under rated on here and a good buy for the price....I would consider him as another option fo rthe left, maybe moving Martial inside in if Lukaku moves

Lukaku - If we can recoup the fee, be great business, guarantees lots of goals in patches, and work rate....for me he offers very little in build up play and when he isnt at his best, he is truly awful. Also criminal for £75m his first touch is abysmal Would probably move Martial inside as a send striker option if he leaves and we have th enumbers out wide. As Rashford is first choice I dont see how we would spend a fortune reaplcing Lukaku anyway, I dont really have much idea who I would sign. Probably another really hot youngster, Lincoln the very little I have seen of him looks a similar like fo rlike replacement with more technique at probably half the cost. Gouri of Lyon looked fantastic for France youth levels, not sure he has even come back from injury though or is anywhere near ready subsequently for a big move

It's always risky bringing in alot of new players and selling alot in a short space of time but it looks like our only option at the moment. Theres a serious lack of top quality players across the board and our best players are also looking to move on. Personally i think we need to sort out our center back options once and for all its crazy how we've ignored this for years and settle for jones and smalling every time. A RW that will gurantee goals and perform would be my next hope, as much as i like jadon sancho i do feel a move for bale could be the gamechanger. I know its a risk but imagine a happy and fit bale could win us games singlehandedly which we havent had since the like of RVP, Rooney or Ronaldo. Was hoping Sanchez would be that player for us and am very dissapointed it hasnt worked out as i loved him at aresnal he was a winner, felt like a united player. Hoping we dont lose pogba or de gea but dont mind herrera, mata, jones, smalling, rojo leaving
 
Going by only the players we've being linked to - I don't care if it were by the Daily Mirror or Sun, and assuming that most of those players listed on the OP are leaving - I doubt they will all leave, then I think we'd be better off recalling Dean Henderson to go with Romero rather than blowing loads on a goalkeeper, seeing that we'd have many other positions to fill.
We would probably be signing a center back anyway, so I think Bailly or/and Rojo leaving would be the outcome rather than the other way. Koulibaly would be good, but de Ligt would also be good to pair with Smalling though Romagnoli has always being my dream CB signing. We need a top performing CB that would likely perform from day 1, no point selling Rojo or Bailly and bringing in another CB that might underwhelm like them. If both Rojo and Bailly are leaving, then bring back Tuanzebe.
Valencia and Darmian leaving - although they rarely play - would leave us very light at FB. We would have Shaw who is very good on the left, Dalot who is young, and Young who is underwhelming. Since we have a performing LB with both Dalot and Young also capable of deputizing there, I think I am with @Devil may care opinion that we'd be better off signing an able RB at the right age and good going forward to bridge the gap to Dalot. We've being linked to Meunier, and I think he'd be a good signing. He is suspect defensively but dominant, and with a very good CB and CM backbone with Shaw on the other side, I think he would be a very good signing for decent money.
Midfield is where shit gets real for sure. We could do with one player there even if there's no exit. Matic would be the easiest to replace there as we could do with a DM that is actually a DM. Though Rodri would be a top buy, I think a Herrera - Rodri - Pogba midfield would still be unbalanced and probably even more defensive. Our current midfield setup is rubbish and incredibly lopsided with two defensive midfielders and a supposed attacking midfielder who is phobic to tight spaces and is always pulling out to the left. I don't know if it's on tactics or on Herrera and Pogba, but I feel for our right sided players - RB and RW, and any new RW would be isolated more often than not. What I'm trying to say is that our midfield needs a restructure. I wouldn't bat an eyelid if both Herrera and Pogba leave provided we replace both. I would bring in Bruno Fernandes and Ndombele to go with Rodri, but they might be too expensive, so I think Rodri, Rabiot and Bruno would be smart and balanced in a 2-1 midfield.
I would keep Lukaku in attack. He is a top striker, and with a more structured midfield and better service from the flanks, he'd be very good leading the line. Sancho on the right for decent money to replace Mata and potentially Sanchez in the squad would be great, if we can't get him, then do some scouting ffs.
OUTs - probably unrealistic
De gea
Bailly
Rojo
Valencia
Darmian
Herrera
Pogba
Mata
Sanchez(*)

INs
Koulibaly
Meunier
Rodri
Rabiot
Bruno
Sancho
Around £300m expenditure, but with Pogba and De gea potentially leaving, money would be there to be spent. It would be a massive shame if we've got a top overhaul plan for the summer, but Solskjaer turns out to be the wrong manager.
 
Oblak - De Gea
Jovic - Lukaku
Meunier - Valencia
Tanguy - Matic
Sancho - Mata
Greenwood - Sanchez
Bruno Fernandes - Pogba

Would also like us to add CHO (given his Chelsea predicament) and break the bank for De Ligt.
 
De Gea------We already have 2 fine goalkeepers with Romero and Henderson
Bailly and Rojo-------Koulibaly and Tuanzebe
Valencia----Wan Bissaka
Herrera-----Pelegrini
Matic-------Ndombele
Pogba-----Fernandes

If Lukaku leaves I like Jovic, but Greenwood will eventually take up that position, and we have Rashford and Martial.
 
I'll go with realistic options.

De Gea - Oblak/Romero
Rojo - Tuanzebe
Valencia - Hakimi/Bissaka
Herrera - Barella
Matic - Ndombele /Rodrigo

Pogba - Bruno Fernandes
Mata - Malcolm/ Pepe
Sanchez - Greenwood
Lukaku - Jovic
Jones - Andersen
Ashley Young - Louis Gaya

I'm aware it's going to cost us in excess of £350mil but the Pogba money should make it possible. We're in dire need of a major overhaul.
 
Last edited:
De Gea - Oblak

Sanchez - Sancho

Mata - Zaha

Pogba - Renato Sanches and Neves

Bailly - Koulibaly

Valencia - Ricardo Pereira

Rojo - Recall Tuanzebe

Lukaku - Nobody. Zaha could play down the middle aswell.

Oblak
Pereira Koulibaly Lindelöf Shaw
Matic
Neves Sanches
Sancho Rashford Martial

Subs: Zaha, Smalling, McTominay, Lingard, Tuanzebe
Are you just after finishing watching Euro 2016?
 
De Gea - Oblak

Sanchez - Sancho

Mata - Zaha

Pogba - Renato Sanches and Neves

Bailly - Koulibaly

Valencia - Ricardo Pereira

Rojo - Recall Tuanzebe

Lukaku - Nobody. Zaha could play down the middle aswell.

Oblak
Pereira Koulibaly Lindelöf Shaw
Matic
Neves Sanches
Sancho Rashford Martial

Subs: Zaha, Smalling, McTominay, Lingard, Tuanzebe
I assume you want to play with 12 players on a regular basis if you’re replacing Pogba with two. I think if you look at some of the lesser known rules of football, you’ll find that’s not technically allowed.

Renato “Out of his depth at Swansea” Sanches as well, I’m glad you’re not in charge of our scouting.
 
I agree pretty much with your thoughts on the players in terms of replacing....if they all leave in midfield hard to replace though as very short. I dont understand your "should leave regardless" list though? Are you wanting Laird and Greenwood to go out on loan or leave leave? With Young signing another year and if we sign another full back I can understand loaning Laird, but Greenwood surely will be getting lots of opportunities next season, especially if Mata, Sanchez for example leave.

Valencia, Mata, Rojo and Darmian should leave regardless of which other players leave, and don't necessary need replacing. Laird and Greenwood would be sufficent replacement for the work these players do in the squad.
 
Oblak - De Gea
Jovic - Lukaku
Meunier - Valencia
Tanguy - Matic
Sancho - Mata
Greenwood - Sanchez
Bruno Fernandes - Pogba

Would also like us to add CHO (given his Chelsea predicament) and break the bank for De Ligt.

Good to see someone else keen on Meunier too who says we are his favourite british team. Think De Ligt to Barca is done looking at Bartolomeu comments
 
DDG - must stay unless we could get Oblak
Grant - recall Henderson

Goalkeepers: DDG/Oblak, Romero, Henderson

Young - replace with Meunier
Darmian - promote Laird
Valencia - replace with a LB, Sessegnon, who can also play LW
TFM - not needed, no need to replace
Bailley - break the bank for de Ligt
Jones - replace with Anderson or Skiniar
Rojo - promote Tuanzebe
Bothwick-Jackson & Mitchell - not good enough, can both leave

Defenders: Meunier, Dalot, Laird, Smalling, Linderlof, Tuanzebe, de Ligt, Andeson/Skiniar, Shaw, Sessegnon

Mata - replace with Ndombele
Matic - replace with Rodri
Pogba - replace with Aouar
Herrera - replace with Barella

Midfield: Ndombele, Rodri, Aouar, Barella, Periera, McTominay, Fred, Gomes

Lukaku - replace with Jovic
Sanchez - replace with Sancho

Forwards: Sancho, Lingard, Greenwood, Rashford, Martial, Jovic, Chong

Massive turnover needed !
 
De Gea------We already have 2 fine goalkeepers with Romero and Henderson
Bailly and Rojo-------Koulibaly and Tuanzebe
Valencia----Wan Bissaka
Herrera-----Pelegrini
Matic-------Ndombele
Pogba-----Fernandes

If Lukaku leaves I like Jovic, but Greenwood will eventually take up that position, and we have Rashford and Martial.

When is eventually?
 
I assume you want to play with 12 players on a regular basis if you’re replacing Pogba with two. I think if you look at some of the lesser known rules of football, you’ll find that’s not technically allowed.

Renato “Out of his depth at Swansea” Sanches as well, I’m glad you’re not in charge of our scouting.
If we lose Pogba we need to sign two CMs to replace him.

I take it you haven’t been watching Bayern this season... Sanches has been good this season. You know Serge Gnabry was “out of his depth” at West Brom aswell, right? You know Solskjær, our current manager was “out of his depth” at Cardiff, right?

Solskjær would get the best out of Sanches and Zaha and honestly I think Sanches has massive potential. He’s still only 21 so why you’re so quick to write him off when he’s not even in his prime yet is beyond me.

You'd replace Pogba with Renato Sanches and Ruben Neves?
If Pogba leaves, what can we do about it? Neves is one of the best CMs in the league. He would walk into any starting 11 in the Prem. He’s a priority signing for me this summer. Sanches just looks like a United player to me. He’s very similar in terms of style to Pogba.

Are you just after finishing watching Euro 2016?
nah, I’m just finished watching Bayern this season. You know he was their player of the month for September right?
 
De Gea - Oblak

Sanchez - Sancho

Mata - Zaha

Pogba - Renato Sanches and Neves

Bailly - Koulibaly

Valencia - Ricardo Pereira

Rojo - Recall Tuanzebe

Lukaku - Nobody. Zaha could play down the middle aswell.

Oblak
Pereira Koulibaly Lindelöf Shaw
Matic
Neves Sanches
Sancho Rashford Martial

Subs: Zaha, Smalling, McTominay, Lingard, Tuanzebe
Oblak and Koulibaly are good players (though think we'd get fleeced in transfer fees) but Sanches?

And we're buying Saha (who would be £50m/£60m +) as a sub? (who's the only decent sub there).

And after all the changes, we'd still end up with Matic!

No thanks.

(Edit. I've just seen comment that he was player of the month in September.... I take it all back. With those honours, he's a must buy)
 
Oblak and Koulibaly are good players (though think we'd get fleeced in transfer fees) but Sanches?

And we're buying Saha (who would be £50m/£60m +) as a sub? (who's the only decent sub there).

And after all the changes, we'd still end up with Matic!

No thanks.

(Edit. I've just seen comment that he was player of the month in September.... I take it all back. With those honours, he's a must buy)
City has 60m Bernardo Silva on the bench nearly every week. What’s the problem? It’s like some fans don’t want us to fecking compete... if you want to win the league, you need squad depth and quality squad depth at that. City has probably got 200m on the bench.
 
GK: If DDG leaves then the best course of action would be to swap him with Courtois. Real would get the man they want, DDG will move were he wanted and we'll get a top goalkeeper whose EPL proven

RB: If we believe that Dalot is the future then we need to bring someone who can switch in a different role if needed. Milenkovic would be perfect for the role. He's tall, he's comfortable in both attacking and defending and can easily slot as CB to replace Smalling in the near future. Young should be kept for another year.
CB: I think we need to do a rethink here. If we believe that the likes of Smalling can lead our defense then we should aimi for potential (ex De Ligt or Anderson). If we need a leader at the back then that means that our experienced heads had failed so there's no real point in keeping them here. In my opinion our defence should have a top physical CB and a ball playing one. Thus Id go for Smalling, J Andersen, Lindelof and Tuanzebe.
LB: Shaw needs cover/competition. I think Tierney would be perfect for that role. He can play as LB and RB + he provides a certain aggressiveness our defence sorely need.

DM: Matic is growing old and we need a cover/competitor for him. Rabiot would be a good fit for the role. He's young, he has a point to prove, he's a free agent and he'll learn a lot from having Matic around. Mctominay would still remain as cover/competition.
B2B: Herrera might be leaving and Fred had been shite. If they leave then I'd go for Ndombele. Id suggest we also sign Tonali from Brescia to compete with Periera for the role
AMC: If Pogba leaves then Julian Brandt would be a decent replacement for him. He's versatile, he's an excellent player and that 20m-30m minimum fee clause is quite attractive

AML: If Sanchez leave then I'd suggest we sign Bergwijn. He's young, he's extremely talented and versatile and shouldn't cost us a bomb
AMR: We desperately need a RW. Id suggest Lozano for the role

STK: If Lukaku goes then maybe we should consider bringing Joshua King back. He's got a good eye for goal, he knows United inside out and would come on low salary which means it won't be an issue getting rid off once Greenwood is ready to play at top level
 
City has 60m Bernardo Silva on the bench nearly every week. What’s the problem? It’s like some fans don’t want us to fecking compete... if you want to win the league, you need squad depth and quality squad depth at that. City has probably got 200m on the bench.
No, it was more that you'd spend a fortune on a sub but keep Matic in the first XI. of all the "we'll never win the league with xxxxx" threads going around, I'm amazed there isn't one for him.
 
GK: If DDG leaves then the best course of action would be to swap him with Courtois. Real would get the man they want, DDG will move were he wanted and we'll get a top goalkeeper whose EPL proven

RB: If we believe that Dalot is the future then we need to bring someone who can switch in a different role if needed. Milenkovic would be perfect for the role. He's tall, he's comfortable in both attacking and defending and can easily slot as CB to replace Smalling in the near future. Young should be kept for another year.
CB: I think we need to do a rethink here. If we believe that the likes of Smalling can lead our defense then we should aimi for potential (ex De Ligt or Anderson). If we need a leader at the back then that means that our experienced heads had failed so there's no real point in keeping them here. In my opinion our defence should have a top physical CB and a ball playing one. Thus Id go for Smalling, J Andersen, Lindelof and Tuanzebe.
LB: Shaw needs cover/competition. I think Tierney would be perfect for that role. He can play as LB and RB + he provides a certain aggressiveness our defence sorely need.

DM: Matic is growing old and we need a cover/competitor for him. Rabiot would be a good fit for the role. He's young, he has a point to prove, he's a free agent and he'll learn a lot from having Matic around. Mctominay would still remain as cover/competition.
B2B: Herrera might be leaving and Fred had been shite. If they leave then I'd go for Ndombele. Id suggest we also sign Tonali from Brescia to compete with Periera for the role
AMC: If Pogba leaves then Julian Brandt would be a decent replacement for him. He's versatile, he's an excellent player and that 20m-30m minimum fee clause is quite attractive

AML: If Sanchez leave then I'd suggest we sign Bergwijn. He's young, he's extremely talented and versatile and shouldn't cost us a bomb
AMR: We desperately need a RW. Id suggest Lozano for the role

STK: If Lukaku goes then maybe we should consider bringing Joshua King back. He's got a good eye for goal, he knows United inside out and would come on low salary which means it won't be an issue getting rid off once Greenwood is ready to play at top level
We're not going to get ten players in. (I want Milenkovoc though).
 
We're not going to get ten players in. (I want Milenkovoc though).

Its evident that I am suggesting an unrealistic worst case scenario were DDG, Valencia, Darmian, Young, Bailly, Jones, Rojo, Fred, Herrera, Pogba, Sanchez and Lukaku would all leave.
 
Valencia, Mata, Rojo and Darmian should leave regardless of which other players leave, and don't necessary need replacing. Laird and Greenwood would be sufficent replacement for the work these players do in the squad.

Ahhh ok, I thought you had Laird and Greenwood on the list to sell, was thinking whattttttt :)
 
Would Donnarumma be a good signing for us? I've never seen him play but someone I know seems to think he's gonna be amongst the very best.

Not sure how well he would do for us as I also havent seem him play but Dino Zoff once said “I see him even better than myself" .
 
Its evident that I am suggesting an unrealistic worst case scenario were DDG, Valencia, Darmian, Young, Bailly, Jones, Rojo, Fred, Herrera, Pogba, Sanchez and Lukaku would all leave.
I hope 7/8 leave and think another 1/2 more could do. But even if they did, we're not buying the same number of replacements... It's not Ed/Glazers modus operandi especially when those leaving aren't bringing in big bucks (assuming Dr Gea and Pogba Pogba stay).I

Do we need 10 players? .... possibly. Will we get more than 4/5 (regardless of numbers out)? I don't see it.

A CH (for me, Milenkovic), a decent RW and one (ideally) two midfielders would be the max I see us buying.
 
I assume you want to play with 12 players on a regular basis if you’re replacing Pogba with two. I think if you look at some of the lesser known rules of football, you’ll find that’s not technically allowed.

Renato “Out of his depth at Swansea” Sanches as well, I’m glad you’re not in charge of our scouting.

I have to say I really wanted us to sign Renato before he ended up at Swansea, I think I was alone there haha... where he was dreadful yes. Isnt he doing well again this season though at Bayern?
 
Bailly - Koulibaly/De Ligt
Rojo - Tuanzebe
Valencia - Wan Bissaka
Herrera - Rice
Perreira - Bruno Fernandes
Mata - Sancho
Sanchez - Hudson Odoi
Lukaku - Greenwood

See us linked a lot with Fernandes, sure I remember seeing him play in Italy a long time ago and he looked rally average. Is he actually any good? Also Greenwood, what is his position, I see he started as a cm but most of the clips I have seen him he has been out wide, do you see him as a striker?
 
I hope 7/8 leave and think another 1/2 more could do. But even if they did, we're not buying the same number of replacements... It's not Ed/Glazers modus operandi especially when those leaving aren't bringing in big bucks (assuming Dr Gea and Pogba Pogba stay).I

Do we need 10 players? .... possibly. Will we get more than 4/5 (regardless of numbers out)? I don't see it.

A CH (for me, Milenkovic), a decent RW and one (ideally) two midfielders would be the max I see us buying.

As said its an unrealistic worse case scenario. Even if that was the case then we would be buying 8 players as Courtois would be a swap deal while Rabiot is a free agent. Tonali is a hot prospect. So that's 7. Brandt is a minimum fee clause so that's pretty straight forward as well.

We'll also get rid of plenty of high earners (Sanchez, Pogba, DDG and Lukaku) with young hungry players who won't be asking for such salaries.
 
See us linked a lot with Fernandes, sure I remember seeing him play in Italy a long time ago and he looked rally average. Is he actually any good? Also Greenwood, what is his position, I see he started as a cm but most of the clips I have seen him he has been out wide, do you see him as a striker?
That’s a different Fernandes I believe. This one is playing for sporting Lisbon.
 
I love the with Matic showing signs of being past his peak comment. You mean with Matic's quality having fallen off a cliff in quality as his legs are gone. Just like the fans who didn't want to sign him said would happen?

Why do a large portion of our fans fail acknowledge that players decline and some earlier than expected? Rooney Young Valenica and now Matic suffer from the fact that so many people insisted they were still good enough to "do a job" months or even years after that was no longer the case. It really hinders us!
 
Not sure how well he would do for us as I also havent seem him play but Dino Zoff once said “I see him even better than myself" .

Wow Dino ZOff, one of my first memories of football, certainly outside the domestic game, 1982 world cup. It was the famous Italy v Brazil game stands out, still one of the best games I have seen and fell in love with Brazil then with the fans, football and players like Socrates and Zico, was only eight years old. Im sure he was about 40 then!!! :)
 
I lve the with Matic showing signs of being past his peak comment. You mean with Matic's quality having fallen off a cliff in quality as his legs are gone. Just like the fans who didn't want to sign him said would happen?

Why do a large portion of our fans fail acknowledge that players decline and some earlier than expected? Rooney Young Valenica and now Matic suffer from the fact that so many people insisted they were still good enough to "do a job" months or even years after that was no longer the case. It really hinders us!

I never wanted to sign him in the first place, have to say, in the first season he did far better than I expected, £40m though and the £50m on Fred plus £30m on Herrera, having grown up with Robson, Ince, Keane its painfully bad our midfield recruitment for probably the last 10-15years or so. I loved Andersons early days, but off the top of my head Carrick is the only decent signing there we have made....ironically I think he only fully excelled with us when he got to the 29-30year age these other players you mention seem to have really declined.
Agree with you completely though, Ferguson, Wenger too....they always knew when the right time was to sell a player....last few years these players.....we have been buying them!
 
Wow Dino ZOff, one of my first memories of football, certainly outside the domestic game, 1982 world cup. It was the famous Italy v Brazil game stands out, still one of the best games I have seen and fell in love with Brazil then with the fans, football and players like Socrates and Zico, was only eight years old. Im sure he was about 40 then!!! :)
Me too. He was.
 
That’s a different Fernandes I believe. This one is playing for sporting Lisbon.

Just googled him, I thought he played in the same Palermo side as Dybala. Apparently he played for both Udinese and Sampadoria.....might be getting him mixed up with someone else anyway