Where did I say amazing, he is clearly not a "shit" player, its just the usual hyperbolic bullshit you see on here.Do you watch him play or are you just another one of those who looks at stats and sees an amazing player? There's a fair few of them stats men around here
That's a more sensible post, I think he wanted out of United for what ever reason and had downed tools, I said before the season started he would get at least 20 league goals. If you build the team around him he will score.I believe the general consensus is that he's obviously a good player, but not a great player. He's not going to propel a team to win trophies but he can score plenty of goals in the easier games if you give him good service.
It was right of us to sell him (especially considering the circumstances), but wrong of us to not replace him.