United over the decade - Nominations thread

[Wumminator]

Hello all.

I've previously done threads on Redcafe's favourite United players. (Here.) I want to do a similar series of polls on United's memorable moments of the decade.

In this thread I'd like you to nominate the following categories (Please copy and paste the list and only write second names to make it easier for me!)

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

You can nominate in as many categories as you want. I will then compile a list of the top ten and ask the mods to start a poll on the outcomes. We will have a week of posts with the winners being crowned on the 31st.

Than y

 

[Paul_Scholes18]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. Carrick
2. De Gea
3. Valencia
4. Van Persie
5. Rooney

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. 3-0 Win over Aston Villa to win the title 2012/2013
2. 3-2 Win over Man City during the 2012/2013 season.
3. Fa cup final win over Crystal Palace 2015/2016
4. Europa league final win over Ajax 2016/2017
5. League cup final win over Southampton 2016/2017

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. Pogba
3. Mctominay
4. Lingard
5. Evans?

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. Van Persie
2. David De Gea
3. Young
4. Herrera
5. James

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Falcao
2. Schweinsteiger
3. Di Maria
4. Schneiderlein
5. Depay

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Mctominay
3. Rashford
4. Henderson (if he counts)
5. Williams

7. Manchester United's best match of the decade:
1. 8-2 over Arsenal 2011/2012
2. 4-2 win over Man City in 2014/2015
3. 3-0 over Villa in 2012/2013
4. 3-0 over Spurs in 2014/2015
5. 2-1 over Man City in 2019/2020
Will add more later

 

[Wumminator]

@paulscholes18 glad you put Valencia. He will be on my list.

btw changed the last category.

 

[Paul_Scholes18]

@paulscholes18 glad you put Valencia. He will be on my list.

btw changed the last category.

Interesting with best goal of the decade. Need to think about that. Van Persie vs Villa is hard to beat though. Rashfords freekick this season should probably compete well too. Rooney and Berbatov had some nice overhead kicks too in 2010/2011.

 

[paulscholes18]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. DDG
2. RVP
3. Carrick
4. Valencia
5. Herrera

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. Winning the premier league
2. Winning the europa league
3. PSG away
4. Winning the F.A cup
5. Winning the league cup

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. Pogba
3. McTominay
4. Cleverly
5. Lingard

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. DDG
2. RVP
3. Herrera
4. Martial
5. Pogba

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Falcao
2. Lukaku
3. ADM
4. Memphis
5. Schneiderlin

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Rashford
3. Henderson
4. Tuanzebe
5. McTominay

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney V City
2. Mkhitaryan V Sunderland
3. RVP v Villa
4. Berbatov V Liverpool
5. Rashford V Chelsea

 

[Random Task]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. DDG
2. RVP
3. Rooney
4. Carrick
5. Scholes

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. When we last won the title (2013)
2. Winning the EL for the first time
3. Winning the FA Cup
4. The second-half comeback against City (2-3)
5. The sacking of Jose Mourinho

3. Manchester United's best homegrown player of the decade:
1. Pogba
2. Rashford
3. Mctominay
4. Greenwood
5. Lingard

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. DDG
2. RVP
3. AWB
4. James
5. Pogba (?)

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. BFS
4. Depay
5. About 15 other players occupy this position equally

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Rashford
3. Mctominay
4. Williams
5. Gomes

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. RVP' volley against Villa (which was also the title decider)
2. Rooney' scissor kick against City
3. Valencia's volley against Everton
4. Martial' solo effort against the dippers
5. Lingard' solo effort against Watford

 

[Suedesi]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:

1. De Gea (player of the year, every year)
2. Rooney (before fading badly, he was our best outfield player and driving force going forward)
3. Carrick (underrated player, key to our midfield)
4. Giggs (one of our best players ever, was able to slot seamlessly in midfield and prolong his career)
5. Valencia (I know he faded badly, but he gave great service for a decade)

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:

1. Winning the title 2013
2. Winning the title 2011
3. Making it to the CL Final 2011
4. Winning the FA CUP 2016
5. Winning UEFA 2017


4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:

1. De Gea
2. van Persie
3. Chicharito
4. Zlatan
5. Blind

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:

1. Sanchez ($40m transfer fee + ridiculous wages for zero impact on the field)
2. di Maria (snek)
3. Mkhitaryan (awful player)
4. Schneiderlin (awful player)
5. Darmian (awful, injured player) (could have been Rojo, Bailly, Phil Jones for that matter)


7. Manchester United's best match of the decade:

1. Schalke - United 0:2 - CL Semifinal, 04.05.2011 (our last great match in Europe, totally dominated a good side, should have won 10-0 if it wasn't for an inspired Manuel Neuer)
2.Man United - Arsenal 8:2 - PL, 28.08.2011 (No explanation needed)
3. Man City - Man Utd 2:3 - PL, 09.12.2012 (RVP derby)
4. Man Utd - Newcastle 4:3 - PL, 26.12.2012 (so many fun games that season, 'no defense, but we'll score one more than you')
5. Liverpool - Man Utd 1:2 - PL, 22.03.2015 (in the midst of a 6-game winning streak which also included demolishing Spurs 3-0 and City 4-2, Juanfield was Van Gaal's finest tactical game at United)
6. Man Utd - Liverpool 3:1 - PL, 12.09.2015 (the Anthony Martial introduction, always nice to outplay the scouse)
7. Man Utd - Ajax 2:0, UEFA Cup final (not a great match, but nice to win a final, comfortably)
8. Paris SG - Man Utd 1:3, CL, 06.03.2019 (amazing result)
9. Man City - Man Utd 1:2, PL, 07.12.2019 (Pep's team couldn't live with us for 45 minutes, then we defended comfortably)
10. West Ham - Man Utd 2:4, PL - 02.04.2011 (what a comeback from 2-0 at halftime, the Wayne Rooney hatrick and subsequent banning for swearing at the camera

8. Manchester United's worst match of the decade:

1. Man Utd - Man City 1:6 - PL, 23.10.2011 (just a bad day in the office)
2. Man Utd - Fulham 2:2 - PL, 09.02.2014 (Plenty to chose from this season, but symptomatic of Moyes' tactics, 82 crosses)
3. Leicester - Man Utd 5:3 - PL, 21.09.2014 (We played brilliantly up to a point, to see us fold in that manner was heartbreaking)
4. Chelsea - Man Utd 4:0 - PL, 23.10.2016 (Mourinho made to look clueless by Antonio Conte, the first of many to come)
5. Man Utd - Sevilla 1-2, - CL, 13.03.2018 (No heritage)

 

[Wumminator]

I won’t do one for worst match. That would be a depressing thread.

 

[DVG7]

@Wumminator excellent thread. Have always enjoyed reading the long ones that you do, admirable work.

 

[DVG7]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De gea
2. Carrick
3. Rooney
4. Van Persie
5. Valencia

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. RVP goal v villa and winning title
2. Mata scissor kick v Liverpool
3. Rashford Pen v PSG
4. Europa league final v ajax
5. Pogba double against city to stop them winning the league

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. Pogba
3. McTominay
4. Greenwood
5.

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Ibrahimovic
3.
4.
5.

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2.
3.
4.
5.

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Mejbri
3. Williams
4.
5.

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. RVP v Villa
2. Mkhitaryan v Sunderland
3. Mata v Liverpool
4. Berbatov v Liverpool
5. Matic v palace

 

[Denis79]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. DDG
2. Rooney
3. RVP
4. Valencia
5. Carrick

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. 8-2 Arsenal
2. League win 12-13
3. League win 10 -11
4. UEFA Cup Win
5. FA Cup win

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. McTominay
3. Greenwood
4. Williams
5. Lingard

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. RVP
2. DDG
3. Hernandez
4. Ibrahimovic
5. Herrera

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Falcao
2. Schweinsteiger
3. Sanchez
4. Di Maria
5. Mkhitaryan

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Williams
3. Gomes
4.
5.

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney Overhead kick vs City 2011 (Undisputed)
2. Valencia bomb vs Everton 2017
3. RVP volley vs Aston Villa 2013
4. RVP Freekick vs City 2013 (Not pretty but important)
5. Rashford Free kick

 

[roonster09]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Rooney
3. Carrick
4. RVP
5. Valencia

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. Winning PL in 2013
2. Winning PL in 2011
3. Winning Europa League
4. FA Cup win
5. Reaching CL finals in 2011

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Pogba
2. Rashford
3. McTominay
4. Lingard
5. Evans

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. RVP
3. Smalling
4. Herrera
5. Pogba

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Schweinsteiger
3. Falcao
4. Mkhitaryan
5. Schneiderlin

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Morrison
3. Pogba
4. Rashford
5. McTominay

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney bicycle kick vs City
2. RVP volley vs Villa
3. Berbatov goal vs Liverpool
4. Mata's goal vs Liverpool
5. Rashford's freekick vs Chelsea

 

[jem]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Rooney
3. Carrick
4. Van Persie
5. Evra

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. Van Persie wonder goal against Villa
2. Scholes' last-minute header against City
3. Rooney bicylce against City
4. Berbatov overhead against Liverpool
5. Mata goal against Liverpool

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. Pogba
3. Fletcher
4. McTominay
5. Lingard

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Van Persie
3. Hernandez
4. Smalling
5. Wan Bissaka

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. Schneiderlin
4. Depay
5. Darmian

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player: (does this mean at the moment?)
1. Greenwood
2. Williams
3. Garner
4. Gomes
5. Chong

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Van Persie against Villa
2. Rooney against City
3. Berbatov against Blackburn
4. Mata against Liverpool
5. Rashford freekick against Chelsea

 

[Zoo]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Carrick
3. Rooney
4. Van Persie
5. Valencia

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. 2013 PL title
2. 2011 PL title
3. Europa League win 2017
4. FA Cup win 2016
5. League Cup win 2017

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Giggs
2. Rashford
3. Pogba
4. McTominay
5. Lingard

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Van Persie
3. Chicharito
4. Smalling
5. Pogba

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Alexis
2. Schweinsteiger
3. Falcao
4. Di Maria
5. Phil Jones

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Pogba
2. Greenwood
3. Rashford
4. McTominay
5. Williams

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney vs City
2. Van Persie vs Aston Villa
3. Mata vs Liverpool
4. Rooney vs Barcelona (CL final)
5. Rooney vs Arsenal (a) - 2010

 

[Dr. Dwayne]

Decade of Crapulence

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Marcus Rashford
2. Mason Greenwood
3. Scott McTominay
4. Brandon Williams
5. Axel Tuanzebe

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. van Persie
2. De Gea
3. Pogba
4. Wan Bissaka
5. Martial

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. Schneiderlin
4. Schweinsteiger
5. Lukaku

 

[slored1]

Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Rooney
3. Van Persie
4. Carrick
5. Valencia

Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. Van Persie's hat-trick vs Villa
2. Title in 2011
3. Winning the Europa League
4. PSG away (because it gave us hope)
5. FA cup win

Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. Pogba
3. Giggs
4. Scholes
5. Lingard

Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Van Persie
3. Hernandez
4. Smalling
5. Herrera

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Falcao
3. Schweinsteiger
4. Schneiderlin
5. Jones

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Rashford
2. Januzaj
3. Greenwood
4. Martial
5. Shaw (if he counts)

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney vs City
2. Van Persie vs Villa
3. Martial vs Liverpool
4. Mata vs Liverpool
5 Lingard vs Palace

 

[Volumiza]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. DDG
2. Rooney
3. Giggs
4. Carrick
5. RVP

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. PL Title in SAF's last year
2. Europa League
3. FA Cup
4. Rooney OH kick v City
5. Martials debut goal v Liverpool

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Giggs
2. Rashford
3. Pogba
4. McT
5. Fletcher

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. DDG
2. RVP
3. AWB
4. James
5. Zlatan

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. Depay
4. Schweinsteiger
5. Bebe

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Williams
3. Laird
4. Garner
5. Lingard*

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. RVP v Villa
2. Rooney OH kick v City
3. Michael Owen v City
4. Martial debut v Liverpool
5. Mata v Liverpool

 

[Invictus]

Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. David de Gea
2. Michael Carrick
3. Wayne Rooney
4. Robin Van Persie
5. Antonio Valencia

Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. 20th (2013)
2. Manchester United 6—1 Schalke (2011)
3. Ajax 0—2 Manchester United (2017)
4. 19th (2011)
5. Crystal Palce 1—2 Manchester United (2016)

Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. David de Gea
2. Robin Van Persie
3. Javier Hernández
4. Sergio Romero
5. Zlatan Ibrahimović

Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Alexis Sánchez
2. Matteo Darmian
3. Morgan Schneiderlin
4. Tiago Manuel Dias Correia
5. Bastian Schweinsteiger

Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney's bicycle kick vs. Manchester City (2011)
2. Berbatov's bicycle kick vs. Liverpool (2010)
3. Van Persie's volley vs. Aston Villa (2013)
4. Rashford's free kick vs. Chelsea (2019)
5. Mkhitaryan's scorpion goal vs. Sunderland (2016)

 

[MyOnlySolskjaer]

Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Rooney
3. Carrick
4. Van Persie
5. Valencia

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. 2012 - League Win
2. Europa League
3. FA Cup
4. Van Persie hattrick, last hatrick in the league we've had
5. PSG Away - Ole's at the Wheel

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. Pogba
3. Giggs
4. McTominay
5. Lingard

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. Van Persie
2. De Gea
3. Wan-Bissaka
4. Pogba
5. Zlatan

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. Falcao
4. Bailly
5. Memphis

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Rashford
3. Henderson
4. Williams
5. Gomes

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney vs City
2. Van Persie vs Villa
3. Mata scissor kick vs Liverpool
4. Martial debut goal
5. Rashford vs Chelsea (freekick)

 

[Annihilate Now!]

Best goal of the decade was RVP vs. West Ham in the FA Cup for me... hasn't made any of your lists so far!!

 

[jderbyshire]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Evra
3. Rooney
4. Van Persie
5. Pogba

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. 20th Title
2. One Night in Paris
3. Rooney Overhead Kick v City
4. Europa League Win
5. Berbatov Hat-Trick v Liverpool

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Pogba
2. Rashford
3. Fletcher
4. Lingard
5. Tuanzebe

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. Van Persie
2. De Gea
3. Ibrahimovic
4. Wan Bissaka
5. James

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Schweinsteiger
3. Fellaini
4. Schneiderlin
5. Bailly

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Williams
3. Gomes
4. Laird
5. Garner

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney v City (2011)
2. Van Persie v Villa (2013)
3. Rashford v Chelsea (2019)
4. Martial v Liverpool (2015)
5. Rashford v City (2016)

 

[jderbyshire]

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Falcao
2. Schweinsteiger
3. Di Maria
4. Schneiderlein
5. Depay

Falcao was on loan. Doesn't count.

 

[AshRK]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Van Persie
3. Rashford
4. Carrick
5. Rooney

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. Winning the 20th.
2. Rooney's Bicycle kick
3. Winning the Europa League
4. Winning the FA cup
5. Rashford scoring twice in his PL debut against Arsenal

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Pogba
2. Rashford
3. McTominay
4. Lingard
5. Giggs

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. Van Persie
2. De Gea
3. Zlatan
4. Hernandez
5. Martial

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. Bebe
4. Schneiderlin
5. Valdes

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Rashford
2. Greenwood
3. McTominay
4. Williams
5. Tuanzebe

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. RvP volley against Villa
2. Rooney's Bicycle kick
3. Mata's Scissor kick
4. Martial's debut goal
5. Lingard's FA cup final goal

 

[Wumminator]

You have to Sunday to nominate peeps!

 

[Panther]

Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. David de Gea
2. Robin van Persie
3. Michael Carrick
4. Antonio Valencia
5. Ander Herrera


2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. 2013 League title.
2. Europa League win.
3. 2011 League title.
4. Beating Schalke 4-1 to reach the CL final in 2011.
5. Comeback against PSG

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Paul Pogba
2. Ryan Giggs
3. Marcus Rashford
4. Jonny Evans
5. Scott McTominay

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. David de Gea
2. Robin van Persie
3. Chris Smalling
4. Ander Herrera
5. Zlatan Ibrahimovic

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Alexis Sanchez
2. Morgan Schneiderlin
3. Angel di Maria
4. Matteo Darmian
5. Eric Bailly

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Mason Greenwood
2. Brandon Williams
3. Ethan Laird
4. Largie Ramazani
5. Angel Gomes

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney v City (2011)
2. van Persie v Villa (2013)
3. van Persie v City (2012)
4. Martial v Liverpool (2015)
5. Rashford v Chelsea (2019)

 

[Panther]

Most promising youth player is a bit difficult, I see people including established first team players like Rashford and McTominay, there should be an age limit or a max first team games played rule or something.

 

[Njord]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Carrick
3. Rooney
4. Smalling
5. Pogba

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. SAF's last title win w/ RvP volley
2. PL win 2011
3. EL win
4. FA cup win
5. Rashford debut

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Pogba
2. Rashford
3. Giggs
4. McTominay
5. Scholes

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Pogba
3. Van Persie
4. Smalling
5. Ibrahimovic

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. Fellaini
4. Schweinsteiger
5. Darmian

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Garner
3. Mejbri
4. Laird
5. Williams

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney overhead kick
2. RvP volley vs Villa
3. Rashford freekick vs Chelsea
4. Evra vs Bayern
5. Martial debut goal

 

[sullydnl]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Carrick
3. Rooney
4. Van Persie
5. Valencia

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. Winning the PL in 2013
2. Winning the PL in 2011
3. Juanfield (particularly the second goal)
4. The brief moment of joy sparked by Evra's goal against Bayern.
5. Rooney's goal against City.

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Van Persie
3. Hernandez
4. Ibrahimovic
5. Romero

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. Schneiderlin
4. Depay
5. Schweinsteiger

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney v City
2. Mata v Liverpool
3. RvP volley
4. Martial v Liverpool
5. Evra v Bayern.

 

[adam118]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1.Rooney
2.De Gea
3.van Persie
4.Rashford
5.Zaltan

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. Van Persie hattrick to seal 20th title
2. Rooney overhead kick vs City
3. Europa League
4. Beating City 3-2 2012 - Van Persie free kick
5.PSG victory

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. Pogba
3. Giggs
4.Mctominay
5. Lingard

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. de Gea
2. van Persie
3. Herrera
4.Pogba
5. Zaltan

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Depay
3. Di Maria
4. Schweinsteiger
5. Schneiderlin

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Gomes
3. Williams
4. Tuanzebe
5. Garner

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney Overhead kick v City
2. van Persie Volley v Villa
3. Rooney halfway line goal v West Ham
4. Berbabtov Overhead kick v liverpool
5. Rashfordv Chelsea

 

[Vooon]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. Carrick
2. Rooney
3. Vidic
4. Ferdinand
5. Scholes

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. PL win 2010-11
2. PL win 2012-13
3. FA cup win 2015-16
4. Euro League win 16-17
5. PSG away 2018-19 CL

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Scholes
2. Rashford
3. Fletcher
4. Greenwood
5. Giggs

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. Van Persie
2. Chicharito
3. De Gea
4. Herrera
5. Zlatan

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. Fellaini
4. Darmian
5. Fred

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Rashford
2. Greenwood
3. McTominay
4. James
5. Williams

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney bicycle v City
2. Van Persie volley v Villa
3. Van Persie freekick v City
4. Van Persie v Liverpool Away 2012-13
5. Rafael away v QPR 2012-13

 

[joker00]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De gea
2. Rashford
3. Nani
4. Rooney
5. Vidic

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. Rashford penalty vs PSG (18/19)
2. Nani 3rd Goal vs Manchester city community shield 2011
3. Beckham's goal vs Bayern in the charity game
4. Mkhitaryan 2nd goal vs Ajax 2017
5. RVP 3rd goal vs Manchester city (12/13)

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. Greenwood
3. Januzaj
4. Mctominay
5. Pogba

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Van Persi
3. Herrera
4. Pogba
5. James

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Bebé
2. Sanchez
3. Fellaini
4. Lukaku
5. Blind

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greendwood
2. Williams
3. Tuanzebe
4. Gomez
5. Chong

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Van Persi 3rd goal vs Aston villa 2013
2. Valencia goal vs Everton 2017
3. Mkhitaryan goal vs Sunderland 2016
4. Rooney's Bicycle Kick v Man City Goal 2011
5. Nani goal vs Arsenal 2010

 

[harms]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Van Persie
3. Rooney
4. Carrick
5. Herrera

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. van Persie's volley to seal our 20th
2. 10/11 title
3. Comeback against PSG
4. Rooney's overhead kick
5. Gone in 38 seconds

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. Pogba
3. Scholes
4. Giggs
5. Evans

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Van Persie
3. Herrera
4. Zlatan
5. Pogba

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Fellaini
3. Di Maria
4. Falcao
5. Schweinsteger

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Gomes
3. Williams
4. Garner
5. Laird

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Van Persie vs Aston Villa
2. Rooney vs Manchester City
3. Mata vs Liverpool
4. Berbatov vs Liverpool
5. Nani vs Manchester City (Community Shield 2011, the winning goal)

 

[Sokz]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade (which I read as biggest impact this decade, not best that has played in this decade)
1. Wayne Rooney
2. David de Gea
3. Michael Carrick
4. Tony Valencia
5. Marcus Rashford

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade (which made me feel most euforic at that particular moment)
1. PL 2013
2. PL 2011
3. Rashford's debute run of scoring in every game
4. POGBACK
5. Ole's first 10 game run

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Marcus Rashford
2. Paul Pogba
3. Scott McTominay
4. Jesse Lingard
5. Adnan Januzaj?

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. David de Gea
2. Robin van Persie
3. Anders Herrera
4. Martial
5. Aaron Wan Bissaka

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. Schneiderlin
4. Darmian
5. Depay

 

[Offside]

Best player - 1. Rooney 2. RVP 3. De Gea 4. Vidic 5. Valencia

Best moment - 1. RVP volley v Villa 2. RVP freekick v City 3. Beating Chelsea 2011 4. Man City league cup tie 2010 5. Fergie final home game

Best home grown - 1. Rashford 2. Scholes 3. Giggs 4. Evans 5. Pogba

Best transfer - 1. RVP 2. De Gea 3. Hernandez 4. Mata 5. Pogba

Worst transfer - 1. Sanchez 2. Falcao 3. BFS 4. Di Maria 5. Darmian

Easy and spot on.

 

[Offside]

Mental people putting Dan James and Romero as better signings than Chicharito. In terms of value he’s close to number 1.

 

[bosnian_red]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Carrick
3. Rooney
4. Van Persie
5. Valencia

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. Winning title #19 (2010/11)
2. Winning title #20 (2012/13)
3. Winning FA Cup 15/16
4. Winning Europa League 16/17
5. Beating PSG (18/19)

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. Pogba
3. McTominay
4. Lingard
5. Evans

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. Van Persie
3. Hernandez
4. Ibrahimovic
5. Herrera

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. Falcao
4. Darmian
5. Bebe

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player: (judging this one based on how highly they were rated at any point in their first few years, peak value)
1. Greenwood
2. Rashford
3. Januzaj
4. Gomes
5. McTominay

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney vs Man City
2. Van Persie vs Aston Villa
3. Rashford vs Chelsea (free kick)
4. Berbatov vs Liverpool
5. Mata vs Liverpool

 

[kudiak]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. van Persie
3. Carrick
4. Valencia
5. Rashford

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. #20th
2. #19th
3. Europa League Champions
4. A Night at Paris
5. Ole as Caretaker

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. Pogba
3. McTominay
4. Lingard
5. Greenwood

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. van Persie
2. De Gea
3. Zlatan
4. Chicharito
5. Martial

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Falcao
3. Di Maria
4. Memphis
5. Bebe

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Rashford
3. Gomes
4. McTominay
5. Adnan

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney bicycle kick vs City
2. van Persie vs Villa
3. Martial's debut goal
4. Berbatov vs Blackburn
5. Rooney FK vs City 2013

 

[Stobzilla]

Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. de Gea
2. Carrick
3. Valencia
4. Rooney
5. Nani

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. League title win 2012/13
2. League title win 2010/11
3. FA Cup win 2015/16
4. Europa League win 2016/17
5. Paris St Germain (Away) 2018/19

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Pogba
2. Rashford
3. Evans
4. Lingard
5. Greenwood

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. de Gea
2. Hernandez
3. Wan Bissaka
4. Martial
5. Ibrahimovic

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Di Maria
2. Schneiderlin
3. Schweinsteiger
4. Darmian
5. Depay

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Greenwood
2. Gomes
3. Garner
4. Williams
5. Levitt

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. van Persie Vs. Aston Villa (H) (12/13)
2. Rooney Vs. Man City (H) (10/11)
3. Berbatov Vs. Liverpool (H) (10/11)
4. Nani (1st) Vs. Man City (N) (11/12)
5. Nani Vs. Chelsea (H) (11/12)

 

[Web of Bissaka]

Thank you. Good thread.

1st
Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. Carrick
2. De Gea
3. Valencia
4. Rooney
---
5. Fellaini
6. Herrera
(surely longevity is a key criteria since it's "decade")

2nd
Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. 99 Charity game vs Bayern.
2. 2016/17 is a fun season.
3. Caretaker Ole's 3-5 months(?).
4. The many comeback winnings games.
5. Rashford debut and runs of games under LVG.
6. The many big games where we raised the roof and sort of dominate to win, post-SAF (under lvg, mou and Ole).
7. Fergie genius 7 defenders vs Arsenal (2011 FA Cup?)

3rd
Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Rashford
2. McTominay
3. Lingard
4. Evans
5. Pogba
(best youth? Pog lower because he's not really "grown" here at top level)

4th
Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. De Gea
2. RVP
3. Herrera
4. Chicharito
5. Zlatan
6. Romero

5th
Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Bebe
3. Schneiderlin
4. Schweinsteiger
5. Di Maria
6. Depay

6th
Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Rashford
2. Greenwood
3. Pogba
4. Januzaj
5. McTominay
(promising factor level during their earliest run of games, Pog when he's back 2016)

7th
Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Mkhitaryan scorpion
2. Chicha backwards header
3. RVP volleys and goals
4. Team play goals (too many to specify, majority counter attacks)
5. Rashford's Freekicks
(don't remember when)

 

[anant]

1. Manchester United's best player of the decade:
1. DDG
2. Carrick
3. Rooney
4. Herrera
5. Valencia

2. Manchester United's best moment of the decade:
1. Win vs PSG
2. 12/13 title
3. EL win
4. FA Cup win
5. 8-2 vs Arsenal

3. Manchester United's best home grown player of the decade:
1. Pogba
2. Rashford
3. McTominay
4. Januzaj
5. Lingard (counting only those who graduated from the academy this decade and including contributions for other clubs as well)

4. Manchester United's best transfer of the decade:
1. Dave
2. RVP
3. Herrera
4. Martial
5. AWB

5. Manchester United's worst transfer (incoming) of the decade:
1. Sanchez
2. Di Maria
3. Mkhi
4. Depay
5. Bebe

6. Manchester United's most promising youth player:
1. Rashford
2. Januzaj
3. Greenwood
4. Wilson
5. McTominay (assuming the promise player showed in first 5 games)

7. Manchester United's goal of the decade:
1. Rooney vs City
2. RVP vs Villa
3. Mata vs Pool
4. Rashford vs Chelsea freekick
5. Martial vs Pool

Honourable mentions: Rooney vs West Ham, Rashford vs PSG, Martial vs Stoke, Martial (?) vs Cardiff, Rooney #250,