I am delighted but can anyone make a serious case for that not being a penalty. What do we think ?
Was it a penalty?
- Thread starter Ayush_reddevil
- Start date
No . It wasn’t .
Maybe
Never been given and happens all the time. Typical ABU pundits screaming for a penalty just to whip up the neutrals.
No.
Obvious pen, Onana was nowhere near the ball
At the world cup that one against Messi was given. Closest thing I can remember.
Nope.
Yes. The same way the martinez one against us last year should have been
It was 100 percent a pen, the ref has to go to screen. Crazy, delighted but they were robbed.
Happens every week and never gets called for a penalty. Dodgy decision making by Onana but i didn't think it was a pen.
Stonewall
I don't even know anymore.
No.
Their keeper clattered into Antony as well, so if one is a pen, so is the other.
Their keeper clattered into Antony as well, so if one is a pen, so is the other.
I feel like keepers are quite regularly doing things like that and more often than the attacker is given a penalty, the keeper is awarded a free kick.
Penalty clear as day
Stone wall penalty. The only saving grace was the ball had already been headed.
It would have never been given against Ederson or Alisson, so no.
Not sure if it is, but pretty sure it should be.
It was, but we never get given them so I don't feel guilty. Always thought goalkeepers get far too much leeway with those types of challenges.
It would be if he stopped the player from winning the header but that's not what happened. Plus both his arms went either side of the wolves player.
I would have given it.
Honestly I don't even know. At first I thought no as he didn't lead with his fists implying he tried to pull out/minimize damage but then thought it was cos he obviously missed the ball
It should be but rarely do you see the goalkeeper penalised for that type of challenge.
It happened in the Brentford v Spurs game, the player shot (I think it was Mbeumo) and the keeper took him out. There was no drama or hissyfits about it.
Coming together
Blatant penalty. Was shocked that it wasn’t given.
I was expecting it to be given to be honest. It's hardly the worst foul you'll ever see but you never know these days 
. The only things that saved him were he didn't catch him in the face with his gloves and the ball had gone before the contact.
. The only things that saved him were he didn't catch him in the face with his gloves and the ball had gone before the contact.Not sure how anyone can argue it shouldn't be a pen. So what if other keepers get away with it, those incidents should be pens too.
100% penalty. Was surprised VAR didnt ask referee to check
Yes it was. We were incredibly lucky that was not given
I’d want it if it was the other way. He was nowhere near.
The ball had gone by the time Onana got there. It was nothing. It’s not like he’d have scored if he hadn’t been clattered.
I thought so, and I'd be miffed if we didn't get it if the roles were reversed.
Come on
Why WASN'T it given? Was it because they already headed the ball away so Onana didn't effect what happens after that?
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Was very similar to the Vicario incident yesterday
No it was not.
He's in his 6 yards box. Keepers are very protected and have extra privileges in that box. No ref gonna give a pen if a keeper collides with opponent players inside the box catching a cross. Unless he hit the said opponent player in the face/head I think.
He's in his 6 yards box. Keepers are very protected and have extra privileges in that box. No ref gonna give a pen if a keeper collides with opponent players inside the box catching a cross. Unless he hit the said opponent player in the face/head I think.
Definitely a penalty, also Onana would have definitely saved it. So who cares?!