He literally didn't.
Your top 5 favourite Manchester United players of all time
- Thread starter Parma Dewol
- Start date
Beckham
Scholes
Charlton
Tevez
Sheringham
Ask me again next week and it'll probably change. My most controversial pick is obviously Tevez but I loved watching him for us. Still do when I see games from the 07-09 era. He gets bonus points for recently saying, yes, Pirlo was great, but he's no Scholes.
Scholes
Charlton
Tevez
Sheringham
Ask me again next week and it'll probably change. My most controversial pick is obviously Tevez but I loved watching him for us. Still do when I see games from the 07-09 era. He gets bonus points for recently saying, yes, Pirlo was great, but he's no Scholes.
Bryan Robson - My first and only footballing hero.
my other favourites changes every week. Currently it's
Hughes
Irwin
Evra
Blackmore
my other favourites changes every week. Currently it's
Hughes
Irwin
Evra
Blackmore
No Di Maria?
It is super difficult to pick just 5. I ll just pick the guys from our 2007-08 season.
Scholes, Rooney, Giggs, Vidic, VDS.
Scholes, Rooney, Giggs, Vidic, VDS.
Coppell
Robson
Hughes
Cantona
Keane
Robson
Hughes
Cantona
Keane
Scholes
Cantona
Keane
Rio
Vidic
Cantona
Keane
Rio
Vidic
Bryan Robson - the reason I initially began supporting Utd, before Fergie arrived actually.
Cantona - a iconic cult hero. Such an important figure in the rise of Utd - both on the pitch and commercially.
Beckham - a great player in so many ways, and another truly iconic star.
Ince - a really important one for me as ‘black British’ kid, just Loved him and how he played.
Rooney - signing him at the exact right time and watching him develop and then into his prime was incredible. Such a great, natural footballer. So pure a player. His prime also coinciding with such a golden era for Utd was magical as well.
And extra 1 because I want one more…
Lee Sharpe! What a star.
Great days. Thinking back on these makes me think of moments like Mark Robbins / Lee Martin’s goal, Utd’s first PL, the Rooney - Ronaldo era.
Cantona - a iconic cult hero. Such an important figure in the rise of Utd - both on the pitch and commercially.
Beckham - a great player in so many ways, and another truly iconic star.
Ince - a really important one for me as ‘black British’ kid, just Loved him and how he played.
Rooney - signing him at the exact right time and watching him develop and then into his prime was incredible. Such a great, natural footballer. So pure a player. His prime also coinciding with such a golden era for Utd was magical as well.
And extra 1 because I want one more…
Lee Sharpe! What a star.
Great days. Thinking back on these makes me think of moments like Mark Robbins / Lee Martin’s goal, Utd’s first PL, the Rooney - Ronaldo era.
George Best
Denis Law
Bobby Charlton
Martin Buchan
Stuart Pearson
Denis Law
Bobby Charlton
Martin Buchan
Stuart Pearson
Club Legend, but he just misses out on the top five.
1. Bryan Robson (the greatest Utd player I have seen in my lifetime).
2. Norman Whiteside (83 and 85 cup final goals were my greatest childhood memories)
3. Roy Keane (he could play and he could fight. What a character!)
4. Eric Cantona (The king who made all our dreams come true)
5. Ryan Giggs (he was their from the start to the finish of the best years of me supporting Utd)
6. Mark Hughes (pre PL) I use to try and replicate his volleys in the Play ground.
I know it was top 5.
But I had to include Sparky !
2. Norman Whiteside (83 and 85 cup final goals were my greatest childhood memories)
3. Roy Keane (he could play and he could fight. What a character!)
4. Eric Cantona (The king who made all our dreams come true)
5. Ryan Giggs (he was their from the start to the finish of the best years of me supporting Utd)
6. Mark Hughes (pre PL) I use to try and replicate his volleys in the Play ground.
I know it was top 5.
But I had to include Sparky !
Last edited:
Scholes, Keane, Beckham, Irwin, Rooney
Best
Law
Cantona
Rooney
Scholes
Law
Cantona
Rooney
Scholes
1. Georgie Best.Incomparable.Iconic. Genius.Unique.
2. Denis Law. Same as.
3. Bobby Charlton .
4. Eric Cantona
5. Roy Keane.
That’s reducing it to 5 which is ridiculously hard.
2. Denis Law. Same as.
3. Bobby Charlton .
4. Eric Cantona
5. Roy Keane.
That’s reducing it to 5 which is ridiculously hard.
Keane
Scholes
Carrick
Beckham
Vidic
Scholes
Carrick
Beckham
Vidic
Rooney, Carrick, scholes, rio, ronaldo
David Beckham
George Best
Wayne Rooney
Dennis Law
Bobby Charlton
In no particular order ..
George Best
Wayne Rooney
Dennis Law
Bobby Charlton
In no particular order ..
Stevie Coppell
Pancho
Robbo
Cantona
Schlolesy/Keano
Pancho
Robbo
Cantona
Schlolesy/Keano
- Rooney
- Scholes
- Ronaldo
- Vidic
- Giggs/VDS
- Sneijder
- Ronaldinho
- Mbappe
- Kane
- Bale
- Ramos
Scholes
Rooney
Ronaldo
Yorke
Evra
Honourable mention to Cantona, started supporting the club because of him.
Rooney
Ronaldo
Yorke
Evra
Honourable mention to Cantona, started supporting the club because of him.
Cantona
Giggs
Ole
Evra
VDS
Giggs
Ole
Evra
VDS
You forgot Di Maria.If I could put Roy Keane in twice I would. He just sums up what's wrong with United the last number of years. I really love the no nonsense players at United who give a solid 8/10 minimum every match.
1) Roy Keane - There has been no better Captain in World football ever or any sport for that matter. If he got the United job tomorrow he'd end up in Jail with the cowboys here at the minute.
2) Rooney - His work rate was out of this World. Just Fantastic all round player. He could do everything.
3) Nemanja Vidic - What a defender. No nonsense approach and would put his head where most others players wouldn't.
4) Eric Cantona - What an ego and what a player.
5) Paul Scholes - Head down, get on with the game and break people up with his terrible tackles. But what a fecking player he was, could land a football on a needle.
1) Roy Keane - There has been no better Captain in World football ever or any sport for that matter. If he got the United job tomorrow he'd end up in Jail with the cowboys here at the minute.
2) Rooney - His work rate was out of this World. Just Fantastic all round player. He could do everything.
3) Nemanja Vidic - What a defender. No nonsense approach and would put his head where most others players wouldn't.
4) Eric Cantona - What an ego and what a player.
5) Paul Scholes - Head down, get on with the game and break people up with his terrible tackles
. But what a fecking player he was, could land a football on a needle.1. Cantona. The nr. 1 reason I'm a United fan. I wasn't a particularly impressionable child but I popped up my collar to be like Cantona.
2. Schmeichel. Grew up in Denmark so my favorite players were Danish and Cantona.
3. Beckham. Popular figure, scored cool goals and I was a right midfielder (wingers were barely a thing at the time). Had more common with Giggs than Beckham but my child brain couldn't associate myself with a left footed player.
4. Solskjær. He overcame my dislike for Norwegian players (side effect of growing up in Denmark). CL 99, all those goals, hard worker and team player. Model professional like Beckham. Always loved those types of players the most.
5. Ji-Sung Park. Doesn't need an explanation.
2. Schmeichel. Grew up in Denmark so my favorite players were Danish and Cantona.
3. Beckham. Popular figure, scored cool goals and I was a right midfielder (wingers were barely a thing at the time). Had more common with Giggs than Beckham but my child brain couldn't associate myself with a left footed player.
4. Solskjær. He overcame my dislike for Norwegian players (side effect of growing up in Denmark). CL 99, all those goals, hard worker and team player. Model professional like Beckham. Always loved those types of players the most.
5. Ji-Sung Park. Doesn't need an explanation.
5 Cantona
4 Cantona
3 Cantona
2 Cantona
1 Cantona
4 Cantona
3 Cantona
2 Cantona
1 Cantona
It's hard to pick only 5.
Schmeichel - the best goalkeeper ever in my opinion.
Beckham - probably one of my favourite players ever.
Keane - just an exceptional player and leader. One of the best midfielders of his generation.
Cantona - what's not to love, you just cannot quantify the aura he had on the pitch, a genius of a player and an absolute madman at times.
Rooney - I forget all the contract nonsense later decline and if he wanted to moved to City. He was fecking awesome.
Schmeichel - the best goalkeeper ever in my opinion.
Beckham - probably one of my favourite players ever.
Keane - just an exceptional player and leader. One of the best midfielders of his generation.
Cantona - what's not to love, you just cannot quantify the aura he had on the pitch, a genius of a player and an absolute madman at times.
Rooney - I forget all the contract nonsense later decline and if he wanted to moved to City. He was fecking awesome.
And Tevez.
No Gaitan?
In no particular order: Scholes, Keane, Mata, Berbatov, Rooney
Vidic, scholes, Keane, Rooney, young Ronaldo.
Van Nistelrooy
Beckham
Ronaldo
Scholes
Rio
Stam
Rooney
Van Der Sar
Veron
No way I can limit it to 5....
Beckham
Ronaldo
Scholes
Rio
Stam
Rooney
Van Der Sar
Veron
No way I can limit it to 5....
Let me put 5 into a squad who can win something and they are Giggs, Backham, Keane, Stam and Ronaldo.
Cantona
Keane
Stam
Bruce
Schmeichel
Keane
Stam
Bruce
Schmeichel
Kanchelskis
Beckham
Carrick
Cantona
Nani
Beckham
Carrick
Cantona
Nani
Beckham
Cantona
Berbatov
Keane
Ronaldo
Cantona
Berbatov
Keane
Ronaldo
Last edited:
Cantona
Robson
Irwin
Keane
Schmeichel
Robson
Irwin
Keane
Schmeichel
Keane
Schmeichel
Beckham
Scholes
Stam
Nearlys/Honorable Mentions
Vidic
Rooney
Herrera
Zlatan
Cantona
Go on I'll throw in a least favourite too:
Lukaku
Maguire
Pogba
Martial
Di Maria
Schmeichel
Beckham
Scholes
Stam
Nearlys/Honorable Mentions
Vidic
Rooney
Herrera
Zlatan
Cantona
Go on I'll throw in a least favourite too:
Lukaku
Maguire
Pogba
Martial
Di Maria
Last edited:
This is really is almost my choice. Loved Hughes when playing for us but my feeling got tainted when he started to manage though. I would swap him for Rio or Irwin.
Can't do 5. Selection changes every time I think about the question.
Robson and Keane always feel like locks, but I'm lying to myself to not add Ince. That would only leave 2 slots, which is impossible.
Robson and Keane always feel like locks, but I'm lying to myself to not add Ince. That would only leave 2 slots, which is impossible.
Robbo
Cantona
Keane
Van Persie
Kanchelskis/Rooney.
Cantona
Keane
Van Persie
Kanchelskis/Rooney.