You both got tied up on reaching civilization and forgot that any civilization in the desert would have to be linked to a water source, and that's the priority, not people. Once you have found your water source, you have food, water, shelter and respite, you make your way to civilization afterwards. I'll explain in depth later.
Complete Mental Obliteration V2
- Thread starter Hectic
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
Actually, I assumed that civilisation inferred that there'd be water, as wherever I end up is civilised. There are water sources all over once you're out of the desert, the job would be cleaning them. Also when I'd found civilisation, it'd be easier to contact 'the outside world', or are the phones down again?
That's it though, you don't need to reach civilization first, you can cut into the water source which is obviously going to be closer to you, and then follow that down to civilization. You're missing the point, the civilization there would have a clean water source running from it, and we aren't talking about a muddy spring or dried up river bed which you can dig into.
Aren't most water sources going to be a natural oasis or some form of well ?
Following a river would lead to civilisation eventually but you don't get many in your average desert.
Following a river would lead to civilisation eventually but you don't get many in your average desert.
Exactly, and you won't find a civilization in the desert that doesn't have a natural water source connected to it, i.e a river.
The burning issue is the map and the knee and the problem combined by them.
Well, finding civilisation would be easier than a water supply, probably. Clean water could be obtained later.
Water isn't an issue, you have enough to get you to civilisation, the issue is the wounded knee and the map. If you can't move, you'll die, if you don't follow the map, you'll die, because the water will obviously run out and there is only one civilisation for you to find.
What?! How?
Not really. It's no dilemma, either cover your knee up, or die.
Laim...that is a dilemma. That is a dilemma with bells on.
There is no civilisation in the desert without a water supply.
You seem to think that dilemma means choice.
It's an easy choice to cover your leg up, it's the only thing you can do or you will die. However, you are now left in a dilemma because of the water situation, which will also see you die.
That is exactly what it is.
This 'water source' could be a little well, hidden behind a sand dune, the village or town would be much more visible.
Right, you have two choices, cover your knee up, and potentially wander aimlessly around the desert, or let your knee bleed, but know where you're going, roughly, but die through bleeding, definitely.
I suppose it's not a dilemma if you have already accepted death.
So in the middle of a desert, a whole civilization has sprung up, based around a little well?
I plan on getting out of the desert.
A dilemma being a very difficult choice, this is even slightly difficult. The water thing isn't a matter of choice, but judgement. You can't choose whether to find water or not.
Liam147 said:
We still on this... It looks like he's not even fecking begun.
You'd easily have bled to death just thinking about what to do ages ago.
You'd easily have bled to death just thinking about what to do ages ago.
Yes, but it's a dilemma.....
A dilemma is is a problem offering at least two possibilities, neither of which is practically acceptable. Both of these possibilities involve death. It is a dilemma.
Yes... that is a dilemma, I'd say.
The problem to solve here isn't the water, there is only the water you have, solving the map/leg issue, or at least...attempt to solve that issue is the key to everything.
A commendable goal, but given the fact that every desert I can think of is hundreds of miles long, your not doing it unassisted.
The question was a bit misleading. I was under the assumption that the task at hand was to get out of the desert, not to find a village within the desert.
What the shit? What are you talking about? I've already said I'd cover up my knee, that much is obvious. Finding water is about a lot of luck.
The chance of finding a usuable animal carcass, something big enough to skin (how without a knife I'm not sure) in the desert is fecking astronomical. It's a desert, it's giant.
Doing anything else other than working out the map/knee problem is tantamount to death.
Doing anything else other than working out the map/knee problem is tantamount to death.
I know, but as I've said, trying to sleep in the desert unprotected will equal certain death.
The map/knee thing isn't difficult. The map is nearly useless if you don't know where you are on it.
Liam, you keep saying it is not a dilemma, what we are saying is it very clearly is, unless you don't understand the definition, which is what it looks like.
There is something, very, very important you have both overlooked. This will not be revealed until the game moves on.
I reckon there are two things they have missed which are very important, reading through the question again.
I pm'd you Hectic, have a read.
Did I involve it in my story?
It's fair to say you attempted to solve the two main issues in a better way, so in that sense yes, but you still missed what I consider to be the most important thing. As I said though, your answer seemed a far better way of surviving.
Your answer is easily better than either so far Burrow, but also has many flaws.
Well, obviously it has flaws. It's hard to predict situations like that though, so it's a generally good idea for a "standard" encounter with the desert (if there is such a thing). But as long as I dont try to kill a camel with my bare hands to find a play to sleep, or to write a map in the sand every 100 meters then I think I would find a water-source eventually
Hmm, if you run out of water eventually, you can even drink your own piss as your last resort. Not unheard of you know
It's a desert, the major plant surviving in the desert the cacti has a way of storing water, unless i am wrong.
It's a desert, the major plant surviving in the desert the cacti has a way of storing water, unless i am wrong.
The crowing water you guys. It is in something - a bottle, better hope it is in a skin pouch or something, draw the map on it first - if you have nothing use your fingernails to scratch the map on the pouch - and then wash your wound with whatever water you can spare, then tie the map cloth around your knee. Then walk at night and try not to kill camels to take their skin. This might mean you survive assuming that the map shows where you are at the start, else you are dead anyway.
Sorry but this is incredible, dumb and dumber rather than mental obliteration.
Sorry but this is incredible, dumb and dumber rather than mental obliteration.
If they are naked, do they have footwear?
If not then highly unlikely one can walk for more than day barefooted in the scorching heat.
And one could always piss on the wound.
If not then highly unlikely one can walk for more than day barefooted in the scorching heat.
And one could always piss on the wound.
Nonsense Harshad, body urine has salts and stuff.The saying "rubbing salt on one's wound" is true to the core
Even the most heartless bastard would provide footwear if they need the chance to survive in the desert.
Even the most heartless bastard would provide footwear if they need the chance to survive in the desert.
Somebody forgot to tell that to Morarji Desai.Nonsense Harshad, body urine has salts and stuff.The saying "rubbing salt on one's wound" is true to the core
The situation provided by Addzz says that you are naked. Doesn't say that you have your leg wear.
Will be difficult to decide whose answer is better.
Not really, I've been stripped and dumped in the desert. Not just to die, but to die slowly it seems.Nonsense Harshad, body urine has salts and stuff.The saying "rubbing salt on one's wound" is true to the core
Even the most heartless bastard would provide footwear if they need the chance to survive in the desert.