Rory 7
Full Member
As I've said repeatedly in answer to this very question. Giggs succeeding LVG provides stability and continuity.So why not skip this next time and just hire, as you said, and experienced coach ?
As I've said repeatedly in answer to this very question. Giggs succeeding LVG provides stability and continuity.So why not skip this next time and just hire, as you said, and experienced coach ?
But the board do, it would seem.I don't think he has the personality, temperament, or leadership skills to do it.
All things that you aren't in a position to actually judge yourself. You found them stats yet?I don't think he has the personality, temperament, or leadership skills to do it.
That's what it looks like. Let's hope it turns out a bit better than Moyes.But the board do, it would seem.
By being 2nd in command, a tier bellow ceo for a long time and consistently performing.You still haven't answered my question about how someone is appointed CEO of a business for the first time. Funny that, is it because you know the answer?
I can't take this relentless nonsense any more.I dont even think giggs can manage an excel or outlook express, let alone time management, human management, tactical analysis, behavioral approach, etc. He can't dribble his way out of rooney demand for new contract can he?
Sir Alex does & I'd guess he knows Giggsy far far better as a person than anyone on the caf.I don't think he has the personality, temperament, or leadership skills to do it.
Fergie choosing the next manager again isn't exactly the best idea is it.Sir Alex does & I'd guess he knows Giggsy far far better as a person than anyone on the caf.
Boom! We finally have a poster comparing him to the tea lady! Congratulations @Sky1981 you win a prize. Not sure what it is yet. We'll have to source something appropriate in our local Dealz.By being 2nd in command, a tier bellow ceo for a long time and consistently performing.
Giggs is just 3 years into the 2nd position. His playing time and knows the club inside out means nothing. The tea lady might be the longest servant of thw club. Doesn't mean we'll employ her.
I dont even think giggs can manage an excel or outlook express, let alone time management, human management, tactical analysis, behavioral approach, etc. He can't dribble his way out of rooney demand for new contract can he?
He isn't choosing though, he's not the only person to endorse him. Yes he endorsed Moyes, but also had a few that he thought would be a better match, the board had the final decision & went for what they could attain easily.Fergie choosing the next manager again isn't exactly the best idea is it.
And that's not even the most ridiculous thing in his postBoom! We finally have a poster comparing him to the tea lady! Congratulations @Sky1981 you win a prize. Not sure what it is yet. We'll have to source something appropriate in our local Dealz.
Aye and the day he signed Ralph Milne we should have stopped him from having an influence on signings ever again.Fergie choosing the next manager again isn't exactly the best idea is it.
I chose to ignore the really spiteful stuff.And that's not even the most ridiculous thing in his post
It's ALL logic and reason pal, just like Raoul said.I chose to ignore the really spiteful stuff.
What does that have to do with Fergie choosing the next manager ?Aye and the day he signed Ralph Milne we should have stopped him from having an influence on signings ever again.
@Rory 7So to continue the analogy, you don't think three years as assistant manager will provide Giggs with the requisite skill set to make the step up?
Oh i don't know, nobody knows - not you, not me. Let's try him out and see.By being 2nd in command, a tier bellow ceo for a long time and consistently performing.
Giggs is just 3 years into the 2nd position. His playing time and knows the club inside out means nothing. The tea lady might be the longest servant of thw club. Doesn't mean we'll employ her.
I dont even think giggs can manage an excel or outlook express, let alone time management, human management, tactical analysis, behavioral approach, etc. He can't dribble his way out of rooney demand for new contract can he?
It means Fergie makes mistakes too. But he rarely made the same mistake twice.What does that have to do with Fergie choosing the next manager ?
You're saying because he got Moyes wrong (who apparently wasn't his first choice anyway) then we shouldn't trust him on future manager advice. Well he got the odd signing wrong as well, doesn't mean we should disregard his opinion on them.What does that have to do with Fergie choosing the next manager ?
Buddy, I told you i'm not going to find stats. We're having a discussion and don't need to get into a dueling google search standoff to participate.You're saying because he got Moyes wrong (who apparently wasn't his first choice anyway) then we shouldn't trust him on future manager advice. Well he got the odd signing wrong as well, doesn't mean we should disregard his opinion on them.
You found any stats to support your bollocks yet or still trying to keep your logic airtight by not allowing any new information to enter your head?
Until he actually does, then what ?It means Fergie makes mistakes too. But he rarely made the same mistake twice.
The great thing about Google is it means that people can't just say things that blatantly aren't true and get away with it any more because they are easily proven wrong. You should try it some time instead of hating on it.Buddy, I told you i'm not going to find stats. We're having a discussion and don't need to get into a dueling google search standoff to participate.
You're dead right @Raoul. These discussions are much more meaningful when posters just make up 'facts' that they don't need to back up.Buddy, I told you i'm not going to find stats. We're having a discussion and don't need to get into a dueling google search standoff to participate.
Let's get beyond this fatuous strain of providing stats vs no providing stats and try to heighten the substance of the discussion a bit.The great thing about Google is it means that people can't just say things that blatantly aren't true and get away with it any more because they are easily proven wrong. You should try it some time instead of hating on it.
That's the nature of the forum though - we provide and discuss opinions, which are interpretative and qualitative in nature.You're dead right @Raoul. These discussions are much more meaningful when posters just make up 'facts' that they don't need to back up.
BrilliantThat's the nature of the forum though - we provide and discuss opinions, which are interpretative and qualitative in nature.
The thing you said that I've taken exception to is not a matter of opinion. You're either wrong or your right and if you're right then you should be able to back it up with some evidence.That's the nature of the forum though - we provide and discuss opinions, which are interpretative and qualitative in nature.
Its been like that since the beginning.Brilliant
Well not really - if I'm right and i develop an argument about why I'm right, and you do the same for your position, then that's all that's necessary. It's a football forum, not a research paper.The thing you said that I've taken exception to is not a matter of opinion. You're either wrong or your right and if you're right then you should be able to back it up with some evidence.
I'd love him to manage us if he went off and managed a mid sized club elsewhere. That would tell us a lot about whether he has the temperament to manage anywhere, let alone at United.Its too much of a risk too soon after the Moyes debacle. I still think we should put him in charge of the reserves and see how he does there.
You said this:Well not really - if I'm right and i develop an argument about why I'm right, and you do the same for your position, then that's all that's necessary. It's a football forum, not a research paper.
That is not a matter of opinion.In the absence of prior CEO experience, you generally don't. I'm sure there are one off examples but its hardly a standard practice.
Nor is it definitive to quickly lasso one firewalled article in google. There is no doubt there is more research in that particular area (which I won't be looking for), and then there is also this idea that football is differently nuanced than what suit wearing executives at corporations look for in one another, but the general idea of having skills, experience, and accomplishments can't be casually dismissed because you're dealing with a likeable candidate.You said this:
That is not a matter of opinion.
No it doesnt. You are just ignoring the points people are bringing up and calling others irrational. BTW I hope we dont appoint Giggs as the next manager, he needs more experience.On the contrary - every single argument for Giggs as a manager is based on a delusional fantacism that suspends logic for feel good romance. Not only is that rampantly irresponsible, but its also bad business. Let's hope more rational minds prevail in the end.
Can't disagree. I do find the idea that Giggs is qualified because he's a likeable club legend quite irrational.No it doesnt. You are just ignoring the points people are bringing up and calling others irrational. BTW I hope we dont appoint Giggs as the next manager, he needs more experience.
Today I learned that logic is making up "facts" that you can't actually prove. I'm off to sleep now (which by the way was invented by Albert Einstein in 1556 - that's a qualitative statement).Nor is it definitive to quickly lasso one firewalled article in google. There is no doubt there is more research in that particular area (which I won't be looking for)
Good night.Today I learned that logic is making up "facts" that you can't actually prove. I'm off to sleep now (which by the way was invented by Albert Einstein in 1556 - that's a qualitative statement).
But it's not, though. The aforementioned are United greats who have gone into management, and not done overly well. Even though who have done well are not of the standard we are looking for. So why is Giggs going to be different? Why should we take the risk?Again the same old shtick. Bruce, Hughes, Keane, Robbo etc. It's a non argument lads. Giggs' situation is incomparable.