Combined Man Utd Liverpool 11
- Thread starter Sigma
- Start date
Exactly the same other than 4-2-3-1, maybe swap Salah for Martial/Rashford, he gets in great positions but he misses a boatload of chances.
Robertson a strange choice. Ordinary player in comical defence, even though left back is our weakest spot I feel it's stronger than Liverpools and think if Robertson was at united he wouldn't start.
Coutinho and mane are the only that would actually
Coutinho and mane are the only that would actually
The same Robertson that doesn't play ahead of Moreno and doesn't get on the bench ahead of Milner? He must not be very impressive in training. I'd stick with Ashley Young at LB, who has been very impressive this season, and surely that's what this team should be based on.
I saw him a few times when he as at Hull and impressed me quite a lot.
Mane & Coutinho are shoe-ins obviously.
Their defence is so poor as is their keeper situation so it’s better to discount it all together.
Their defence is so poor as is their keeper situation so it’s better to discount it all together.
Only Mané and Coutinho would get in.
I'd have Martial in for Saleh and Blind at LB (as drastic as that is).
That's fair, just my take on him
De Gea
Valencia - Bailly - Jones - Blind
Pogba - Matic
Mane - Coutinho - Martial
Lukaku
Valencia - Bailly - Jones - Blind
Pogba - Matic
Mane - Coutinho - Martial
Lukaku
3-5-2 as the fullbacks are meh except Valencia
De Gea
Bailly Matip Rojo
Valencia Pogba Matic Mane
Coutinho
Lukaku Rashford
De Gea
Bailly Matip Rojo
Valencia Pogba Matic Mane
Coutinho
Lukaku Rashford
-----------De Gea-----------
Valencia-Jones-Bailly-Clyne
-------Matic--Pogba--------
--Salah--Coutinho--Mane--
-----------Lukaku-----------
Valencia-Jones-Bailly-Clyne
-------Matic--Pogba--------
--Salah--Coutinho--Mane--
-----------Lukaku-----------
Robertson is decent but nothing special yet. I've watched a lot of him and wouldn't of minded us signing him with more of a long term view - he could end up a very good left back. Assuming neither side has injuries this would be mine.
De Gea
Valencia - Bailly - Rojo - Blind
Pogba - Matic
Mane - Coutinho - Martial
Lukaku
Think the only real debates are Martial/Rashford/Salah, the left back position and does Matip start.Valencia - Bailly - Rojo - Blind
Pogba - Matic
Mane - Coutinho - Martial
Lukaku
...................De Gea
Valencia - Bailly - Jones - Young
...............Matic - Pogba
......Mane - Coutinho - Martial
..................Lukaku
Mane and Coutinho are the only ones that make it from Liverpool. I am still confused why Jose didn't buy Mane, as he tore his Chelsea side apart a few times while at Southampton.
Valencia - Bailly - Jones - Young
...............Matic - Pogba
......Mane - Coutinho - Martial
..................Lukaku
Mane and Coutinho are the only ones that make it from Liverpool. I am still confused why Jose didn't buy Mane, as he tore his Chelsea side apart a few times while at Southampton.
That’s the one.
Matip isn’t ahead of Smalling let alone Jones.
This.
Big Dave
Valencia - Bailly - Jones - Young
Matic
Salah - Coutinho - Mkhi - Martial
Lukaku
Valencia - Bailly - Jones - Young
Matic
Salah - Coutinho - Mkhi - Martial
Lukaku
Yup. The only 2 who get into our squad tbh with maybe Salah.
Doesn't it look beautiful
They’d also be two of our best players along with Pogba so that’s not insignificant.
Dave in goal. Valencia over Clyne. Best left back is highly debatable - take your pick from Shaw, Milner, Blind, Robertson, Young, Darmian. Would take Bailly and probably Jones over Matip though close. After that I'd say it's pretty easy and obvious really - Matic and Pogba in midfield with Coutinho in front, Mane on the right and Martial on the left and Lukaku up top. Nice team.
So biased. Young should be over Shaw on current form.
You cannot seriously pick Mkhi over Coutinho and Mata over Mane, come on.I had just started uploading the same team, but with Rojo instead of Shaw.
Last edited:
I think it's fair to say it's between 2-4 from Liverpool; with Mane and Coutinho the most likely with Salah and Robertson in with a chance.
The big question is do Mig or Karius get a place in a combined squad ahead of Joel Pereira?
The big question is do Mig or Karius get a place in a combined squad ahead of Joel Pereira?
I'd also go with this.
Sure does.
My team consists of only players who are available for the match.
De Gea
Valencia Bailly Jones Young
Herrera Matic
Salah Coutinho Martial
Lukaku
Valencia Bailly Jones Young
Herrera Matic
Salah Coutinho Martial
Lukaku
Yup, look at all that flaming red
None of that pinkish crapAnd that is because you are telling me how I have to think, or presumably I'm still allowed my own opinion
Gotta have Mata and Blind there guys.. Remember their goals
First time in a few years I wouldn't have a single Liverpool player. Maybe, maybe Mane would get it on the right over Mata.
For those choosing Coutinho...if you think Miki is inconsistent...
For those choosing Coutinho...if you think Miki is inconsistent...
Fair point, but imagine he's in a team in which he isn't asked to single-handedly provide spark from midfield. There've been Liverpool games where Mane is on the fringes of the game, which can happen to a wide forward, and Coutinho isn't quite doing it and literally nothing happens.
This thread reminds me how liverpool fans can be deluded. For me they have 2 players who would go straight in our first 11. Mane and coutinho. Besides that we can argue about full backs. And maybe, just maybe martial / salah( for me martial of course but i accept that they can have their reasons for salah). On six positions we can't even be in same sentence. But on rawk i guess only de gea would be in combined 11.
Ddg
Valencia jones bailly young
Pogba matic coutinho
Mane lukaku rashford
I am going to rawk. Now i am curious do they have the same thread.
Ddg
Valencia jones bailly young
Pogba matic coutinho
Mane lukaku rashford
I am going to rawk. Now i am curious do they have the same thread.
Last edited: