Nobodies giving any answers for fear of being shut down I think, but i'll give some;
Thomas Tuchel -
PRO's
- Plays very attractive football, winning football
- Teams play well together as a cohesive unit
- Gets best out of players that aren't necessarily 'World Class'
- Brilliant recorded work with young players and getting the best out of them, particularly attacking ones
- Great and respectable finishes with Mainz, a club limited by a very poor squad and little to no money.
- Would of won Dortmund the league in 1st season if not for a mesmerising Bayern campaign, Lost Pokal only on penalties
- 2nd season won the Pokal after beating Bayern in the semi's
- Only 44, time to learn, grow, and settle in a long term appointment
NEG's
- Perhaps a little naive defensively at Dortmund sometimes, something he would need to iron out of his game, if he hasn't already done so during his time off
- Can be a little argumentative or combatative, but then his sacking was because he was angry at the selling of Hummels, Gundogan and Mkhitaryan despite him being promise they wouldn't all leave
- Perhaps hasn't won enough to be a contender in some people's eyes
He also tried to replace some of the big name players at the club due to their ageing and average performances but Watzke didn't like this and so Tuchel's relationship with said players and Watzke fractured, leading to his sacking, he also wasn't allowed to sign the players he wanted, having numerous transfers blocked by Watzke and chief scout at the time Sven Mslintat, now at Arsenal.
Leonardo Jardim
PRO's
- Also plays attractive, winning football
- Does very well against teams like PSG with unlimited resources
- Gets the best out of the players he has on the squad
- Perhaps even better than Tuchel at utilising young players, as evidenced by his league win last year with one of the youngest and most exciting attacking squads seen
- Good CL runs with this squad
- Still having a respectable league run, in 2nd, against PSG and other teams, despite selling of players like Bernardo Silva, Mbappe and Bakayoko
- Only 44, like Tuchel, plenty of time to learn, grow and settle into a long term appointment
NEG's
- Perhaps also hasn't won enough to be a candidate in some peoples eyes.
This is leaving out the likes of Sarri etc.
Not sure what else I can say, for me, this brand of manager represents a brand of football I know that every supporter of Manchester United would relish watching, we might not win every match, but at least we won't cower against the supposed 'big boys', and it's not like we are winning every match serving up the dross we are currently seeing either is it? With the squad we have, the young attacking talent we have, we should be taking a punt on what I would consider a classic Manchester United manager and would embody everything that made us so successful as a club to begin with.
I know people will say well they've won nothing, we shouldn't be recruiting people that have won nothing, well recruiting managers that have won loads doesn't seem to have the desired effect either, and I don't count Moyes, because he clearly wasn't a good enough manager for us prior to his appointment. We should be giving these managers the chance, they are the future of football, in a more modern direction that, to be honest, seems to have eluded Mourinho completely.