Who are the 6 players Mourinho is saying lack desire?

Bestietom

Full Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2013
Messages
8,021
Location
Ireland
The problem is that either Mourinho's comments just don't ring true with the likes of Lingard and Mata. Yes they were underwhelming yesterday, but I don't see how anyone could accuse either of lacking professionalism. To me, they both have been exemplary in that respect, showing no sulking or negativity, despite regularly being assigned to the substitutes bench. If the comment was that six players just didn't play to the required standard yesterday, then I would definitely include Lingard and Mata, but Jose seems to be hinting at something darker and more sinister.
Transfer window is coming up. This is his antics to get more money to spend. He needs to have a good look at his tactics and change the way he wants us to play football.
 

Inigo Montoya

Leave Wayne Rooney alone!!
Joined
Oct 1, 2008
Messages
38,543
Transfer window is coming up. This is his antics to get more money to spend. He needs to have a good look at his tactics and change the way he wants us to play football.
We will need to spend though. it's all good and well saying his style needs to change but the board needs to back him with funds for players in positions that are either ageing( Valencia) or not strong enough at the highest level eg LB , an attacking left sided player and another CM
 

Fully Fledged

Full Member
Joined
May 23, 2013
Messages
16,300
Location
Midlands UK
Ruling the ones out:

Matic
Mctominay
Lukaku
Romero

So I’d say it’s the other 6:
Mata
Lingard
Martial
Shaw
And 2 of Smalling, Bailly and Valencia
He actually singled out Valencia and said the only reason he didn't take him off as well was because changing 2 fullback would have been overkill.
 

gavdim2002

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Nov 25, 2016
Messages
285
Location
Arctic
Mourinho should be able to motivate his players instead of running them down in Public.
First you scare the shit out of every player, making them afraid to make any mistakes in a ultra defensive setup. You then spend a day or two training attacking football - you win the match, but you are not impressed – then you go out in public and blast them for ”being afraid to play” … a comment made by a sane persone? I am not so sure.
 

Bestietom

Full Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2013
Messages
8,021
Location
Ireland
We will need to spend though. it's all good and well saying his style needs to change but the board needs to back him with funds for players in positions that are either ageing( Valencia) or not strong enough at the highest level eg LB , an attacking left sided player and another CM
I agree with you 100% about needing players. But Mourinho also needs to change his tactical approach in big games. No good bringing in Top players to play football in our own half.
 

Hullyback

New Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2016
Messages
1,343
Location
Yorkshire
Supports
Liverpool FC
Can't help but think Mourinho's in his meltdown stage already, I thought he'd have done it next season but seems it's coming a bit premature.

If I was a cynical man I'd say he's woken up to the fact he's not wanted at United, he's not good enough to get that squad competing with City and never will, and he's hoping for the boot between now and June so he can go off to Barca or PSG and back to looking great again. He just has the air of a man that's in above his head and he knows it, doing the classic narcissistical thing of deflecting blame onto everyone else, and still has the brass neck to humblebrag about his past achiements whilst doing it. I for one will be glad to see the back of him out of England, hopefully that'll be the last we see as well as none of the other big clubs would touch him. Horrible, odious little toad. As a rival I'd rather see United actually competing with City than playing catch up with that egotistical cretin in charge. If we ask nicely he might take Moyes, Pardew and Hughes with him cos they're all deluded, hateful individuals.
 

Inigo Montoya

Leave Wayne Rooney alone!!
Joined
Oct 1, 2008
Messages
38,543
I agree with you 100% about needing players. But Mourinho also needs to change his tactical approach in big games. No good bringing in Top players to play football in our own half.
He does however want players to take responsibility. I get coaching is part of it but when you have senior players you don't need to do their thinking for them.

Look at his best Chelsea squad: Terry,Drogba,Lampard,Robben,Makelele,Carvalho. Add Matic to that list and you have the character and skill to win without being told how to!

I agree with his point that this is Utd they're playing for, not even Chelsea. It's more than a club. It's a fecking football institution alongside Liverpool and bit like the All BVlacks in rugby union.

Both demand you give everything...and a bit more. It's found out better players than we saw yesterday.
 

Garethw

scored 25-30 goals a season as a right footed RW
Joined
Feb 7, 2005
Messages
17,066
Location
England:
If they lack desire either motivate them or drop them.

Either way keep your fecking mouth shut and stop airing your dirty linen in public you muppet!

His stupid comments are likely turning the whole squad against him, which is the last thing we need when CL qualification is not yet guaranteed.
 

Di Maria's angel

Captain of Moanchester United
Joined
Mar 19, 2014
Messages
14,825
Location
London
Did he? When? I remember Nani after a Chelsea match we lost when he gave the ball away, which felt very out of place.

Fergie was amazing at blaming everyone but the players, because he knew that to do that would not in anyway be beneficial, regardless of how rubbish they were.
Fergie:

Ronaldo: "It's hard when a player who wants to entertain doesn't get everything his own way,” Ferguson explained. “But you can't get everything your own way.”

Evans: "F*****g wake up," Ferguson screamed at the 22-year-old defender. "I was just giving him a bit of gentle advice," Ferguson said later.

Rooney: "I don’t know what Wayne was trying to do with the penalty," Ferguson fumed. "I was dumbstruck by that one."

"I think Wayne is the type of player who has to play on the edge in a game really," Ferguson told MUTV. “When it's a really close and competitive game. When it gets to that casual bit, he's worse than the rest of them. He gets so casual about it.”

Smalling: "If you lose a goal at a set-piece you only have yourself to blame at this level," Ferguson said. He later admitted it was a mistake to single out Smalling.

Rooney: "He is very stocky, he is going to have to train well all the time, there is no doubt about that.”

Nani: "We were playing really good football at that point and all we needed to do was see the game out by keeping possession. "But Nani decided to try and beat a player, lost the ball and they got a penalty kick against us.”

Rooney: "I took him off because Villa were a very fast, young side, full of running, and their substitute was running past Wayne."

How dare Mourinho criticise our poor handsomely paid players!?
 

Bestietom

Full Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2013
Messages
8,021
Location
Ireland
He does however want players to take responsibility. I get coaching is part of it but when you have senior players you don't need to do their thinking for them.

Look at his best Chelsea squad: Terry,Drogba,Lampard,Robben,Makelele,Carvalho. Add Matic to that list and you have the character and skill to win without being told how to!

I agree with his point that this is Utd they're playing for, not even Chelsea. It's more than a club. It's a fecking football institution alongside Liverpool and bit like the All BVlacks in rugby union.

Both demand you give everything...and a bit more. It's found out better players than we saw yesterday.
Yes, we have still got some dead wood that needs to go and need some top players in certain areas, But we could look to bring in a Top Football coach also IMO.
 

tombombadil

Full Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2010
Messages
2,898
Location
Some god forsaken part of Middle Earth
Fergie:

Ronaldo: "It's hard when a player who wants to entertain doesn't get everything his own way,” Ferguson explained. “But you can't get everything your own way.”

Evans: "F*****g wake up," Ferguson screamed at the 22-year-old defender. "I was just giving him a bit of gentle advice," Ferguson said later.

Rooney: "I don’t know what Wayne was trying to do with the penalty," Ferguson fumed. "I was dumbstruck by that one."

"I think Wayne is the type of player who has to play on the edge in a game really," Ferguson told MUTV. “When it's a really close and competitive game. When it gets to that casual bit, he's worse than the rest of them. He gets so casual about it.”

Smalling: "If you lose a goal at a set-piece you only have yourself to blame at this level," Ferguson said. He later admitted it was a mistake to single out Smalling.

Rooney: "He is very stocky, he is going to have to train well all the time, there is no doubt about that.”

Nani: "We were playing really good football at that point and all we needed to do was see the game out by keeping possession. "But Nani decided to try and beat a player, lost the ball and they got a penalty kick against us.”

Rooney: "I took him off because Villa were a very fast, young side, full of running, and their substitute was running past Wayne."

How dare Mourinho criticise our poor handsomely paid players!?
Thank you. Perspective is a little bit lacking these days.
 

Alabaster Codify7

New Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2015
Messages
6,553
Location
Wales
He's right in many cases, we've got too many passengers in this squad who don't have the backbone to get stuck in and man up.
 

IRELANDUNITED

Full Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2014
Messages
2,363
No to megathreads and no to any in depth Mourinho analysis. For speculation purposes, name a minimum of six players who you think Mourinho meant when saying 'minimum of 6 players lacked desire'? I will start.

1. Shaw
2. Martial
3. Smalling
4. Lingard
5. Valencia
6. Mata
This boy annoys me, he has had a good season but you get the impression that its all a big joke and a laugh to him and he doesn't take football overly seriously all the time.
 

Massive Spanner

The Football Grinch
Joined
Jul 2, 2014
Messages
28,521
Location
Tool shed
Thank you. Perspective is a little bit lacking these days.
Is that it? 7 examples and 3 are the same player. He's also not exactly going near to the levels Mourinho has been here. Fergie 99% of the time would defend the team after losses and deflect blame to everyone else. He was a master at it. Mourinho does that sometimes but he also happily throws not just one of two players, but the whole team under the bus, when things aren't going his way.

Also I don't recall SAF ever having issues with keeping the dressing room in his side after criticism of players. Mourinho however...
 

Di Maria's angel

Captain of Moanchester United
Joined
Mar 19, 2014
Messages
14,825
Location
London
Is that it? 7 examples and 3 are the same player. He's also not exactly going near to the levels Mourinho has been here. Fergie 99% of the time would defend the team after losses and deflect blame to everyone else. He was a master at it. Mourinho does that sometimes but he also happily throws not just one of two players, but the whole team under the bus, when things aren't going his way.

Also I don't recall SAF ever having issues with keeping the dressing room in his side after criticism of players. Mourinho however...
Most of those were in the period of 2009-2013. I am sure there are more.

Just to add a little extra. The Ronaldo criticism came a few days before he scored a screamer against Porto. The Smalling one was during the title decider against City.

He also dropped Beckham against Leeds for arriving late to training a few days before.
 

Massive Spanner

The Football Grinch
Joined
Jul 2, 2014
Messages
28,521
Location
Tool shed
Most of those were in the period of 2009-2013. I am sure there are more.

Just to add a little extra. The Ronaldo criticism came a few days before he scored a screamer against Porto. The Smalling one was during the title decider against City.
It's still very little and you're really clutching at straws if you're using quotes like that to try and claim that SAF criticised his players like Jose does.
 

Di Maria's angel

Captain of Moanchester United
Joined
Mar 19, 2014
Messages
14,825
Location
London
It's still very little and you're really clutching at straws if you're using quotes like that to try and claim that SAF criticised his players like Jose does.
In their United careers, there's not a lot between them. Jose has rarely singled out a player and criticised him.

What I am saying is that it isn't something new.
 

AngliaRed

Full Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2015
Messages
2,297
Location
Norwich,UK
The problem is that either Mourinho's comments just don't ring true with the likes of Lingard and Mata. Yes they were underwhelming yesterday, but I don't see how anyone could accuse either of lacking professionalism. To me, they both have been exemplary in that respect, showing no sulking or negativity, despite regularly being assigned to the substitutes bench. If the comment was that six players just didn't play to the required standard yesterday, then I would definitely include Lingard and Mata, but Jose seems to be hinting at something darker and more sinister.
I agree mate, Mata, althogh he hasnt scored many he’s looked sharp this season and always able to pick a good pass out. As for Lingard he’s improved so much from a good 16/17 season, scoring important goals in big matches. Last night was an off night for everyone except Matic and Lukaku.
 

Massive Spanner

The Football Grinch
Joined
Jul 2, 2014
Messages
28,521
Location
Tool shed
In their United careers, there's not a lot between them. Jose has rarely singled out a player and criticised him.

What I am saying is that it isn't something new.
But my post wasn't specific to when it's about single players. Jose has this nasty tendency to blame everyone but himself, i.e. his team, when things are going badly. SAF never did that. He'd blame everyone else, but never the team.
 

breakout67

Full Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2017
Messages
9,050
Supports
Man City
Jose Mourinho, pre-Madrid virtually never blamed his players. It was only after he had the battle with Casillas, Ramos etc. that he started publicly blaming his players. When the players downed tools at Chelsea he became even worse in that aspect.

It seems to me, that modern players seem to take protection from managers as granted, and will basically ride out the manager when things are going bad because player power is so strong. It's happening at virtually every top club, when the players under perform they just wait until the end of the season for a new manager and start winning again.

At least it bodes well for the future, that we at least have players like Sanchez and Pogba that are underperforming. If worse comes to worse, we can get rid of the manager and they will at least have a point to prove.
 

rique_don

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Nov 26, 2017
Messages
64
In their United careers, there's not a lot between them. Jose has rarely singled out a player and criticised him.

What I am saying is that it isn't something new.
You need to see this man's behaviour at Real
He is classless and a narcissist. He never does these things for players. He does it for himself. Telling a team that has won 3/4 Champions Leagues without him that they would never do it says a lot. The man is a horrible man manager and extremely self serving. The next appointment has to be right and we need to not allow glitz and money making to affect our planning for our season or buying players. I am sorry but Fergie was nothing like Mourinho. He protected his players more than crushing them.
 

fallengt

Full Member
Joined
Jul 27, 2011
Messages
5,618
Fair play fo Mou to call them cnuts out publicly tbh. Some players think they won lottery when United signed the contract.
 
Last edited:

rique_don

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Nov 26, 2017
Messages
64
Fair play fo Mou to call them cnuts out publicly tbh. Some players think they won lottery when United signed the contract.
When will he call himself out? He has fallen short himself. Certainly as it relates to Man Management. He is a huge part of the problems we face, not the solution. I have been resentful of those who have said Pep would be doing better with the players that we have but it's true. Klopp is playing far better football with a joke of a midfield and after losing his best player in January. Mourinho is tactically flawed but of course who wouldn't throw himself beneath the bus. He was an ass to the Real Madrid players including Cristiano and lost that battle because he wanted Ronaldo to work harder defensively and caused a civil war within the dressing room, was an ass at Chelsea including to De Bruyne and was embarrassed by Chelsea last season and now De Bruyne playing for Pep. The top two Prem players now were discarded by him and he will lose this battle too. He is too self serving. Man United and his players are secondary to his own ambitions.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Listar

Full Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2014
Messages
1,147
Whoever that doesn't name Shaw and Valencia is not worth their salt. Mourinho even name them in his post match conference. I seriously doubt some of you actually understand what is going on. Its like you were given two numbers to a winning lotto ticket and you still choose to pick other numbers. Shocking.
 

buchansleftleg

Full Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2014
Messages
3,778
Location
Dublin, formerly Manchester
I think everyone would acknowledge that Jose is a great defensive coach. It must be awful to be managing a team where he can easily see our own tactical weaknesses.

Two old wingbacks who can put in great performances one week but can be found out or tired another game.

No attacking threat down the right wing / lack of genuine movement.

It doesn't take a tactical genius to stop us and we arrive in the box in 2s or 3s.

With attacking fullbacks and a right winger we would be overwhelming opposition with 4 or 5 players arriving in the box.

I think these comments are actually aimed at the money guardians at Old Trafford who refused to sanction extra cash for these positions.
 

Murray3007

Full Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2015
Messages
1,746
most of the team lack desire, most look lost and have no confidence. cant be all the players fault, surely the buck has to stop with the manager. so far its been city have spent to much money, we aint spent enough, the players aint good enough, bullys the younger players, breaks the transfer record for a player and has no idea how to play him, signs a player for LW despite it being a area we have had pretty decent success this season with Martial and Rashford. says he only wants to play players in there proper position then does not do it. the mans excuses are embarrassing.
 

Smores

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2011
Messages
25,665
Reading posts i always wonder why people can't seperate the criticism and topics, so single track minded. It's always "yeah but Mou" as if only one person can be at fault.

I don't like the scale or criticism at the moment but i don't disagree with it. Matic interview on sky sports is spot on, basically Jose is difficult to work with because he always wants more but the players need to get used to it as they're at Man Utd.

That along with the LvG story again about players not reading his emails leads me to think some need to go. Keane would strangle half of this lot.
 

tombombadil

Full Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2010
Messages
2,898
Location
Some god forsaken part of Middle Earth
Does criticism of Ronaldo not remind of you something or someone? Paul... P

Or what about down the bottom about Rooney? Sounds a lot like Shaw.
I know, right? We really gotta get rid of the rose tinted lenses sometimes.

Is that it? 7 examples and 3 are the same player. He's also not exactly going near to the levels Mourinho has been here. Fergie 99% of the time would defend the team after losses and deflect blame to everyone else. He was a master at it. Mourinho does that sometimes but he also happily throws not just one of two players, but the whole team under the bus, when things aren't going his way.

Also I don't recall SAF ever having issues with keeping the dressing room in his side after criticism of players. Mourinho however...
I'm sure there are more examples. The main point still stands.
 

Decomposing In Paris

Full Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2014
Messages
1,318
Location
Belfast
Fergie:

Ronaldo: "It's hard when a player who wants to entertain doesn't get everything his own way,” Ferguson explained. “But you can't get everything your own way.”

Evans: "F*****g wake up," Ferguson screamed at the 22-year-old defender. "I was just giving him a bit of gentle advice," Ferguson said later.

Rooney: "I don’t know what Wayne was trying to do with the penalty," Ferguson fumed. "I was dumbstruck by that one."

"I think Wayne is the type of player who has to play on the edge in a game really," Ferguson told MUTV. “When it's a really close and competitive game. When it gets to that casual bit, he's worse than the rest of them. He gets so casual about it.”

Smalling: "If you lose a goal at a set-piece you only have yourself to blame at this level," Ferguson said. He later admitted it was a mistake to single out Smalling.

Rooney: "He is very stocky, he is going to have to train well all the time, there is no doubt about that.”

Nani: "We were playing really good football at that point and all we needed to do was see the game out by keeping possession. "But Nani decided to try and beat a player, lost the ball and they got a penalty kick against us.”

Rooney: "I took him off because Villa were a very fast, young side, full of running, and their substitute was running past Wayne."

How dare Mourinho criticise our poor handsomely paid players!?
Good post.
 

el3mel

New Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2016
Messages
43,736
Location
Egypt
Fergie:

Ronaldo: "It's hard when a player who wants to entertain doesn't get everything his own way,” Ferguson explained. “But you can't get everything your own way.”

Evans: "F*****g wake up," Ferguson screamed at the 22-year-old defender. "I was just giving him a bit of gentle advice," Ferguson said later.

Rooney: "I don’t know what Wayne was trying to do with the penalty," Ferguson fumed. "I was dumbstruck by that one."

"I think Wayne is the type of player who has to play on the edge in a game really," Ferguson told MUTV. “When it's a really close and competitive game. When it gets to that casual bit, he's worse than the rest of them. He gets so casual about it.”

Smalling: "If you lose a goal at a set-piece you only have yourself to blame at this level," Ferguson said. He later admitted it was a mistake to single out Smalling.

Rooney: "He is very stocky, he is going to have to train well all the time, there is no doubt about that.”

Nani: "We were playing really good football at that point and all we needed to do was see the game out by keeping possession. "But Nani decided to try and beat a player, lost the ball and they got a penalty kick against us.”

Rooney: "I took him off because Villa were a very fast, young side, full of running, and their substitute was running past Wayne."

How dare Mourinho criticise our poor handsomely paid players!?
Rooney got the most of it. :lol: