I'm not normally resistant to change. I welcome positive change but hate change for the sake of it.
Get rid of VAR NOW! We want our game back! (...or not, some are happy)
- Thread starter RedFish
- Start date
Who actually goes out to the pub and talks about football in a serious way?
Yep and I love goal line technology.
This definitely isn't change for the sake of it. There has been calls for technology in football for years now and we've been building up to it.
good post.
And goal line technology is brilliant and instantaneous.
This “decisions even themselves out over the course of the season” has always been the stupidest cliche I’ve ever seen.
Me. I bet most people who spend any significant amount of time on here talks about football both at work and down the pub.
Wish it had been around at the time of ‘the hand of God’.
Nah, "what doesn't kill you can only make you stronger" is the stupidest cliche. Like having limbs torn off by a lion can't happen.
Also, "you can't run away from your problems". You can if your problem is an angry lion with no back legs.
Bastard lions.
I’m pro VAR I think but the usage of the system in the city game today was ridiculous. It shouldn’t be used constantly. Fabianski was about 2 inches off his line, it’s going to start affecting how players play the game
What about if the lion has torn off your legs in order to use them to chase after you. Then you're fecked.
The retake of the pen was given for encroachment by Rice. Not the goalkeeper being off his line.
Except that these professionally trained officials are awful at their job. There’s hardly a game that goes by that a referee/linesman doesn’t make an absolute bowler of a call, especially in England where the referees are probably the worst of any of the top leagues.
VAR is brilliant as you no longer have to hear the fans of the losing club whinge all week, about how they were absolutely robbed.
It will also lessen aggression and violence towards referees.
It will also lessen aggression and violence towards referees.
It’s not meant to be interpreted literally, but there is a lot of merit to “what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.” If you apply it to an extremely hard task at work, something you didn’t think you were capable of, but you get through it, you come out of it stronger on the other side.
I kind of agree with you. I mean who ever heard of lions getting married.
Feck that cup half full nonsense. You're more likely to do your back in, get a hernia or rupture an ACL than actually get stronger from hard work.
90%+ is awful. What a tough standard.
Ah right fair enough.
Now that I think about it, Mufasa seemed to have some sort of weird harem situation going on with those lionesses.
If it works from them fair play.
What about the lions though Cloud7? What about the damn lions?!
Haha no no man. Once viewing figures go down they’ll soon get rid of it
Having fun in their harems apparently.
It won’t get rid of either of those things. Pereyra went nuts at the ref today in the Watford game for a handball. If anything it’s made worse by demands to review it.
They’re cuddly. I like them.
I don’t care because in 10 years it’ll just be a natural part of the game and football will feel wierd without it then.
Watching Saturday 3pm games....was amazed Watford didn't get a penalty for handball.
Maybe it was short range but seen them given for far less in CL.
Maybe it was short range but seen them given for far less in CL.
The decisions were right I thought... just needs speeding up
Rice encroached on the retake as well, braindead
Rice encroached on the retake as well, braindead
I said the same thing earlier but I've just seen that point corrected: apparently in the PL linemen and lineswomen have been told to flag earlier. The idea being to stop the waste of time that comes from waiting for an obvious offside to be flagged.
Which I think is stupid and something this PL version of VAR can be fairly criticised for.
The PL have said they will be less strict on handballs than is the case in the CL, so expect that discrepancy to continue.
This is the best post in this thread by a mileAll these replies make me laugh. Doesnt matter if you agree or not, offside is a matter of fact decision. You are offside or you are onside. 1mm 1cm or a metre. Its offside, an the right decision was made.
Its applied fairly to every team and every game dont see how people are crying about this.
Its applied fairly to every team and every game dont see how people are crying about this.
Last edited by a moderator:
Amazing rebuttal! Forgot basketball was a turn based rpg
. Sorry if basketball is not played at a non stop heart pounding pace but that’s the best example of a sport similar to footy (action back and forth with continuous running, also Rugby for that matter) where replay is implemented rather well. Don’t get upset with VAR bc it’s rather sluggish in its FIRST games. More so, let’s give up on the cell phone as it’s the size of a brick.Fair enough, I hope one day VAR offside checks will be just as good and transparent.
No complex tech in sports is ever perfect(LBW tracking Cricket, hawk eye tennis).
No one complains about goalline technology ever because it's clear and transparent. Offside on the other hand is a lot more complex and time consuming. It's not hard to see why it has it's detractors, nothing to do with age. Who knows, maybe one day, maybe the tech is so advanced the decisions are instant and rendered 3d models are shown to the viewers right away? I would have no qualms about it being so exacting at that point. But right now, it's far from perfect and seems pedantic to me.
Players will quickly learn what they can’t get away with anymore and adjust, which will soon mean far less VAR interventions.
Eg: I doubt many more players will enter penalty box before penalty kick is taken after todays mistake by West Ham.
I think it will carry on being abit annoying for a month or so, until all the pre VAR cheats are identified and punished, and that will lead to a ‘reset’. Which will be great for the game as it will dramatically reduce cheating and improve fairness.
Eg: I doubt many more players will enter penalty box before penalty kick is taken after todays mistake by West Ham.
I think it will carry on being abit annoying for a month or so, until all the pre VAR cheats are identified and punished, and that will lead to a ‘reset’. Which will be great for the game as it will dramatically reduce cheating and improve fairness.
Oh really? That is how it worked last season in most cases. Keep play going and VAR will sort it out later.
In that case the PL version isnt a good version in my opinion, an incompetent ref/linesman (who are plentliful in the EPL) can still have a big impact on the game. I like it when the play just keeps going, it also stops defenders from stop playing and just put their hands up in the air which i think is really annoying during a match.
Agree.
Though I suspect that the PL would argue that both this decision and the decision to be less strict on handballs are simply a response to the concerns of fans who complained about the game being slowed down and impractical decisions being made. It's a matter of what you prioritise, I guess.
The fussy part of my brain really wishes VAR rules were standardised across all competitions but I guess we'll be looking at years of different and ever-changing tweaks to how VAR works.
Yeah all that diving from Salah last year was fine right?