He was in decline before he signed it, not sure why we offered him so much money when there are plenty of better keepers out there.
Living on past glories, much like the club itself.
Living on past glories, much like the club itself.
why was De Gea not dropped by Ole for woeful form that resulted in the club missing a UCL place - @passing-wind
- Thread starter esmufc07
- Start date
- Status
I don't think he has been on the decline at all. He made a big mistake today, but he also made some very good saves.
Overall, his performances haven't been too bad. I think he isn't in the best form, but he will get back to it soon enough.
Overall, his performances haven't been too bad. I think he isn't in the best form, but he will get back to it soon enough.
Delusional.
yeah, he is the best GK in the world. You say he hasn't declined and then he is not in the best form
Because our forward planning has a horizon of a single day. The people in charge are clueless.
Compare that to the way Chelsea handled the transition between Cech and Courtois.
Compare that to the way Chelsea handled the transition between Cech and Courtois.
He redeemed himself today with some very good saves after the mistake. I understand the concern long term, but today is knee-jerk based on one moment. He had a good game otherwise.
The positive side is we have two other very good keepers under contract, so it’s not an area of massive concern.
The positive side is we have two other very good keepers under contract, so it’s not an area of massive concern.
Seriously? He was disgraceful last season, pretty much single-handedly cost us the top four. This season has been an improvement on that but he's still a long way off his best.
Form is something thats temporary.
yeah, he is the best GK in the world. You say he hasn't declined and then he is not in the best form
Decline meaning that he is permanently on his way down, which is what I disagree with.
Nobody knows, and now we a Karius with a Ronaldo’s like wage, impossible to sell, you have to pay him to go and pay the other club to take him, like Sanchez
Pot kettle
He has been on the decline for 2 years. If you think form last 5 years, that is up to you. I also believe Alexis has not declined and will be in world class form again after being useless for the past 2 or 3 years.
The club needs to make a decision anyway by the emergence of Henderson and i hope they remember we are not a charity and owe De Gea nothing.
Over the last two seasons he’s made the joint most errors leading to goals.
He’s obviously past his best, even if he’s been doing a little bit better recently.
He gave us too much to do today again with that error.
He’s obviously past his best, even if he’s been doing a little bit better recently.
He gave us too much to do today again with that error.
Should no longer be immune from being dropped in the league.
Not on the decline the guy has been poor for what? Over a year now. The reason we suck at set pieces come from his inability to come off his fecking line. He’s a goalkeeper who is scared of physical contact.
His distribution has regressed, he never throws it quickly enough so we can counter attack. He just holds his hand up apologising to the runners every single game.
the guy has been poor for what? Over a year now. The reason we suck at set pieces come from his inability to come off his fecking line. He’s a goalkeeper who is scared of physical contact. His distribution has regressed, he never throws it quickly enough so we can counter attack. He just holds his hand up apologising to the runners every single game.
I am intrigued by the fact that we got rid of Emilio Alvarez, who was the Utd goalkeeping coach and specifically DDG’s hand picked coach (based on their time at Atletico) at the same time he signed a new deal
And now we’ve got Hartis back, and hired Mawson... Are we trying to get him to leave potentially via constructive dismissal tactics?
And now we’ve got Hartis back, and hired Mawson... Are we trying to get him to leave potentially via constructive dismissal tactics?
7 mistakes leading to goals this season. This is not a one off, and some saves at the end will not paper the cracks.
I've seen similar performances from Carroll and Tim Howard where they've made a costly mistake and made some good saves at the end. There's definitely some bias from posters here, he's lost it.
Because if we hadn't you would've instead made a thread about the glazers and Woodward being cheap and failing to keep our best players. See Herrera
I would like to see that "plenty of better keepers out there" list from @esmufc07 .
The club had faith he would be back and it was only a blip.Most fans also wanted to keep him. That is not how a football club should make decisions, but then again, we hired Ole when we were in free fall as well. We make decisions based on faith and are surprised if they don't work.
I know the fanbase will be divided on this, because of his god like status in the previous years, but things arent the same anymore.
I know the fanbase will be divided on this, because of his god like status in the previous years, but things arent the same anymore.
Anyone who questioned that ridiculous deal was told that he'd earned it with past performances. Well this is what happens when you reward loyalty over form.
There is at least 2 within 50 miles of us that are better
I'm now firmly in the camp that says that contract was a massive mistake on our part. I love De Gea and consider it a privilege to have watched him at United during his world class form, but throwing such an obscene contract at him out of pure desperation is costing us dear. We have a great young keeper we should be blooding in, instead he's helping Sheffield United to rival us in the league.
Giving De Gea this bumper contract when he's past his prime by a manager under fire is very similar with what Moyes did with Rooney. Just something to galvanize the fans and get them off his back but it's just set us back in terms of team progression. I don't think a club like bayern would've done this. Heck they're already interested in Deano, with Neuer on the decline. Shows how a proper football club should be run.
He has not been in top form since before the world cup in the summer of 2018. I'm just wondering how long someone has to play poorly before it is no longer just "bad form." We saw these same "bad form" arguments for Alexis and Lingard and at some point you just have to accept that this is now the player that he is.
The fella gave a fairly balanced counterpoint to your opinion. Why even fecking bother creating a thread if you don't want to hear any other opinion besides people parroting what you've already said?
On topic, De Gea is still a baby in goalkeeper years, but I am worried that someone so reliant on his reflexes will decline quite a bit sooner than what might be average for a keeper. I don't think it's happened yet, but he could very well be in for more of a Casillas type career trajectory rather than the longevity the likes of Van Der Sar and Buffon got, who relied less on pure shot stopping.
Overreact much.
Who are you?
He made a mistake to day taking to long to kick out... it cost us
BUT
He made several outstanding saves after that to keep us in the game. in decline my arse. Still a top class shot stopper And all round great keeper.
BUT
He made several outstanding saves after that to keep us in the game. in decline my arse. Still a top class shot stopper And all round great keeper.
Post #1: one word dismissal of someone's perfectly reasonable opinion
Post #2: attacking someone's post count
Do you really think the number next to your username means very much if all your posts are shite like this?
Add to that keepers who are realistically available
Compare that to the way Chelsea handled the transition between Courtois and Arrizabalga.
Cost us over 50m in CL money with his feck ups last season and he is on his way to do it again while cashing in 300k a week so that will be about 65m this time around. Something needs to give here Ole cannot keep on praising him and continue to play him Romero should get a chance v City.
Apart from a stupid mistake which is nothing to do with his actual ability as a shot stopper, which is what he's known for, he had good game today and us from a certain defeat at the end.
Knee jerk
And be replaced by who? Romero is not better and always has a gaffe in him. Grant I don't know, never seen the guy - but can't imagine he'd be great shakes either.
Because he's a top keeper? I wonder if Liverpool fans are saying the same after Alisson spilled a simple collect yesterday?
He hasn't been for a while.
He has been, but whatever.
Time for Granty or Bishop to have a chance.
The club were in an awkward spot, I feel. De Gea was making clangers but he still had his reputation behind him.
When he and Mendes started leaks about him being linked to PSG and stuff, we panicked and awarded him with a mega contract. Also agree with points above about loyalty and security — “De Gea was once the best ‘keeper, he’ll get over this slump” etc.
Whilst I do think he’s nowhere near the level he once was, there’s a fair few wasters ahead of him who need to be chopped. Not that that should be how we run things, but it is.
When he and Mendes started leaks about him being linked to PSG and stuff, we panicked and awarded him with a mega contract. Also agree with points above about loyalty and security — “De Gea was once the best ‘keeper, he’ll get over this slump” etc.
Whilst I do think he’s nowhere near the level he once was, there’s a fair few wasters ahead of him who need to be chopped. Not that that should be how we run things, but it is.
- Status