SAFMUTD
New Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2018
- Messages
- 11,787
United Academy and I were discussing wether having an experienced third goalkeeper on the squad is necessary or not.
My opinion is that the scenario of having the first and second choice GKs injured and needing third keeper is so unlikely that we should get rid of Grant and just use the U23 GK if needed.
Just to add to the context, Grant has played a grand total of 2 games since his arrival and none of them had been because needed but mostly just to give him some minutes and make him feel part of the team.
United Academy on the other hand, says that by having the U23 as third choice you are stalling the players progress and that player should be loaned instead of playing in the U23.
So whats your opinion? Is it necessary to have an experienced goal keeper or not?
If the mods can add a survey that be great.
My opinion is that the scenario of having the first and second choice GKs injured and needing third keeper is so unlikely that we should get rid of Grant and just use the U23 GK if needed.
Just to add to the context, Grant has played a grand total of 2 games since his arrival and none of them had been because needed but mostly just to give him some minutes and make him feel part of the team.
United Academy on the other hand, says that by having the U23 as third choice you are stalling the players progress and that player should be loaned instead of playing in the U23.
So whats your opinion? Is it necessary to have an experienced goal keeper or not?
If the mods can add a survey that be great.