Jadon Sancho| Staying at Dortmund for now

Status
Not open for further replies.

BenitoSTARR

One Minute Man
Scout
Joined
Sep 1, 2015
Messages
13,609
I think, it is a win situation for BVB. Dortmund cannot lose.
If we sell for 120 Mio, we are used to it and we will move on. Maybe with the next player we have a chance to hold him a bit longer.
If he stays for another 3 years and we get nothing, we had him for 3 more years and that would be amazing for us as well.
Everything inbetween is as good as well.
I’d agree with this too.

Dortmund will either keep an emerging world class talent or be paid handsomely.

I still can’t see him staying this season.
 

UncleBob

New Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2014
Messages
6,330
The news about the extension to 2023 has shafted any theories about getting him on the cheap next year, but it's not like it's a surprise to the club as they will have known about the contract situation for a long long time.
 

onemanarmy

Full Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
4,713
Location
Belgium
The news about the extension to 2023 has shafted any theories about getting him on the cheap next year, but it's not like it's a surprise to the club as they will have known about the contract situation for a long long time.
Exactly. As if Utd didn't know about it...
 

TheGodsInRed

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2010
Messages
1,490
Location
Up North
Seriously? Dortmund has communicated with the player that he can move if sum x is paid, apparently 120m. That was the bargain. How on earth are they not holding up their end of that bargain?

Instead, you expect them to sell for 40m less than they bargained with him because of Covid. Why should Dortmund be the party to renounce so that United and Sancho can have their ways?Honestly, if they sold Sancho for 80m now that would be criminal mismanagement given that they can sell him for 120m next year in a recovered market. There is absolutely zero economic reason to do such a thing and they probably had to explain to their shareholders why they do such a dumb thing with their investment.

I'm sorry, but you're just trying to find a scapegoat.

Dortmund can sell thier assets for whatever they think they are worth, that is thier right.

I seriously doubt we will see a recovered market next year though. Club finances are in ruin accross the globe and we are hitting the biggest recession in something like 80 years. We will see more empty stadiums, reduced TV deals and clubs struggling to pay the massive salaries they have on thier books.

I can understand United's hesitance as I don't think any player is worth 120 mill right now considering all this, and no one is quite sure that the 'new' market values will be.
 

TheReligion

Abusive
Joined
Nov 22, 2006
Messages
51,465
Location
Manchester
I think it's totally unrealistic to believe in this day and age Dortmund, who are all about money, will hold on to Sancho for 3 years and run down his contract. It's a nonsense. When does this actually happen in football with top players?

The fact is Sancho doesn't want to be in Germany any more. He's leaving at some point and it's obviously not in 3 years time.
 

El Zoido

Full Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
12,358
Location
UK
I think, it is a win situation for BVB. Dortmund cannot lose.
If we sell for 120 Mio, we are used to it and we will move on. Maybe with the next player we have a chance to hold him a bit longer.
If he stays for another 3 years and we get nothing, we had him for 3 more years and that would be amazing for us as well.
Everything inbetween is as good as well.
Eh, you lose a bit if you sell him at all really. The money doesn’t matter at the end of the day, it’s not like all 120m is going straight back in to the squad. Even if it did, you can’t replace players of a certain calibre. So unless the main joy you take out of following the team is when you profit on your best players, it’s a bit of a lose. We lost by selling Ronaldo to Real Madrid even though it was an insane amount of money at the time, I’d rather we kept him.
 

UncleBob

New Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2014
Messages
6,330
I think it's totally unrealistic to believe in this day and age Dortmund, who are all about money, will hold on to Sancho for 3 years and run down his contract. It's a nonsense. When does this actually happen in football with top players?

The fact is Sancho doesn't want to be in Germany any more. He's leaving at some point and it's obviously not in 3 years time.
Is anyone actually suggested they'll hold on to him for 3 years.
 

Dunkelheit

Full Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2014
Messages
67
Supports
Borussia Dortmund
Woodward must regret saying "We can do things in the market that other clubs can only dream of!" a few years ago.

Such a stupid thing to say, gives selling clubs leverage. (No way would Dortmund ask any other club for £100m. They'd let Bayern have him for a cheese toastie, even if Bayern forgot the cheese) - but we never get a big deal done until the very brow of the transfer window.
Bayern got 3 players from BVB:

1. Lewandowski - probably (no proof, but a lot of signs show in this direction) had a "contract" with Bayern 2 years even before the contract with Dortmund ended. For example Kucharski and Co. already celebrating Bayerns CL victory vs Dortmund in Bayerns lounge -> nothing BVB could have done
2. Götze - bought with the help of a release clause -> nothing BVB could have done
3. Hummels - was sold for 35 Mio, which at that day was a big, big transfer fee for a fullback with 1 year left on the contract. Additionally Hummels asked for BVBs support in this matter, because his wife wanted to migrate to Munich with their unborn child

BVB did not have the financial power at that time, being nearly bankrupt in 2005, to fight against the transfers of Lewandowski and Götze.
I think the times that players from BVB go to Bayern for peanuts are very much over. BVB has grown enormously in finances and can nearly match the big wages in Europe.
BVB and Bayern have a big rivalry, because Bayern bullied (bullied = used their financial power as the leagues undisputed No 1) BVB to give up 3 of their star players when they were a very small and fragile flower. I'd rather give Sancho to Utd for 80 Mio then getting 120 from Bayern, but that might be just me.

So I hope I can help to get rid of this myth that BVB gives away players to Bayern basically for free. Because it is no longer true.
 

Crimson King

Full Member
Joined
May 11, 2013
Messages
3,086
I’d agree with this too.

Dortmund will either keep an emerging world class talent or be paid handsomely.

I still can’t see him staying this season.
I think that if Dortmund start to hold on to all this young talent longer than they want to be there then their carefully crafted image of being a good place to go and get first team football will start to evaporate.

Let's not kid ourselves, Sancho didn't join BVB to be there for 5+ years, and neither did Bellingham or Haaland.

If they start to compete for the bundesliga and CL again like under Klopp then that might help, but even then their best players wanted to move on to clubs with more renown.

They're in a tricky spot; quite rightly they don't want to be "bullied" or seen as a selling club, but that's what they've set themselves up as. If the only way you can leave is to run down your contract like Lewa did, then there's a chance players will think twice before switching there in the future.
 

The Man Himself

asked for a tagline change and all I got was this.
Joined
Feb 12, 2013
Messages
22,406
Anyone seen Dortmund’s latest tweet? They are taking the piss out of United once again.

With a combination of Kagawa, Micky, Haaland, Bellingham and now Sancho. They are making us looks like idiots.
We are in our worst period in long time, still since SAF retired we have got more trophies to show than them. Dortmund meanwhile are seemingly always on the up, supposedly a big club, by far 2nd best domestically but keep selling their players and won only 1 domestic cup since 2012 I think. Are also known to be bitch of their biggest rival. Smart arse tweets are all they can do. No point getting angry or sad with that. I mentioned it before but it was lovely that Mkhi scored in final and won Europa league when all Dortmund could do is sarcastically tweet "best of luck in Europa league" to the departing player.
 

Ventura

Full Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2014
Messages
1,628
Location
Location
I would rather not deal with this club, to be honest. There's a trend of young players choosing Dortmund or similar clubs as a stepping stone and expect to be bought by a bigger club for absolutely stupid money a couple of years later, instead of going straight to the bigger club. The next sagas are Haaland (he was smart enough to get a release clause though) and Bellingham. These three players all had the option to join United, but chose Dortmund instead. I say let's forget about them instead of being extorted and being used in this silly game.
 

Sad Chris

New Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2014
Messages
1,641
I think, it is a win situation for BVB. Dortmund cannot lose.
If we sell for 120 Mio, we are used to it and we will move on. Maybe with the next player we have a chance to hold him a bit longer.
If he stays for another 3 years and we get nothing, we had him for 3 more years and that would be amazing for us as well.
Everything inbetween is as good as well.
I‘m sure everybody understands that it‘s a great situation that Dortmund have themselves in. They scouted a fantastic talent, signed him and have increased his value more than tenfold. What‘s not to love about that as a Dortmund supporter.

Muppet depression leads to selective blindness and ignorance and increased levels of hope. It‘s the closest I can ever come to understanding religion.
 

VP89

Pogba's biggest fan
Joined
Dec 6, 2015
Messages
31,649
I would rather not deal with this club, to be honest. There's a trend of young players choosing Dortmund or similar clubs as a stepping stone and expect to be bought by a bigger club for absolutely stupid money a couple of years later, instead of going straight to the bigger club. The next sagas are Haaland (he was smart enough to get a release clause though) and Bellingham. These three players all had the option to join United, but chose Dortmund instead. I say let's forget about them instead of being extorted and being used in this silly game.
In fairness to Dortmund, they are doing exactly what they are reasonably expected to and playing the market as much as we are. They have a track record of getting big talents and moving them on to bigger clubs, so all parties are pleased.
As annoying as Zorc is, we can't really expect them to bend over just because we want their player. He will try and get the best fee possible and that's what he's doing.
We will end up paying the 120m EUR, but if Sancho played for other clubs it would still be a very difficult task to reach a fee agreement with the selling club. He's a superb once in a generation player and potential balon d'or winner.
 

Terminator

Full Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2015
Messages
1,928
I‘m sure everybody understands that it‘s a great situation that Dortmund have themselves in. They scouted a fantastic talent, signed him and have increased his value more than tenfold. What‘s not to love about that as a Dortmund supporter.

Muppet depression leads to selective blindness and ignorance and increased levels of hope. It‘s the closest I can ever come to understanding religion.
Thats what fans love. Increasing a players value tenfold.:lol:
 

Infra-red

Full Member
Joined
May 4, 2010
Messages
13,423
Location
left wing
Is anyone actually suggested they'll hold on to him for 3 years.
Nope. Assuming we fail this year, they will sell him next summer for approximately €120m, when there will be more suitors.

Contrary to reports that have been doing the rounds for the past six months, Sancho still has three years left on his deal, so he will hold his value next summer.
 

LonelyFire

Full Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2009
Messages
4,565
Location
Scotland
It was Watzke who said it about leaving all three players at once. Which then wasn't true, and was explained that it was cause of Mkhitaryan, who didn't keep his word. Which btw fits to the image Raiola has in here. But i can write and explain what i want, people will scratch after every little glimpse of hope, unitl Oktober. Do yourself a favor and let it go.
The facts have changed: Sancho got one more year contract, all the post about "hey yeah they have to sell they have to sell cause blabla" are nonsense, Sancho got more years of contract then we though. And Zorc made a clear statement. Your argument is even against you: Watzkes words of the past did hurt them a lot (proof: post like yours), and they never ever will make this error twice. If Zorc said Sancho is staying, after theyir own deadline, then Sancho will stay. I don't know where exactly this is rocket science. It isn't hard to understand isn't it?
It was Watzke on Aubameyang - the others were Zorc. I have absolutely no idea what you’re saying regarding words against me. You think it’s a fact he’s staying - I’m merely pointing out that your club have said the same thing about 3x other players in recent history and you sold them all. That’s not hard to understand is it?
 

SATA

Full Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2005
Messages
15,223
Location
We all love United
I hope in two years after we buy Sancho, we waltz into Dortmund again, pay Haaland's release clause like a boss and make him a United player and a star. Small time stepping stone of a club they are
 

kirk buttercup

Full Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2016
Messages
2,484
Location
wickla!
Ofcourse it's not off yet. It's all sides flexing Muscles at the moment. We could always walk away and spend that money (plus a bit) on Rice , Grealish and VdB and look to make Greenwood our Sancho. In a nutshell if we get Sancho great he looks to be a perfect fit ,lf not there are loads of options out there to strengthen our Squad in a time when money is going to be hard to come by , and plenty of clubs will realise that sooner rather than later .
 

Sphaero

Struggling to explain his genius to the hoi polloi
Joined
Nov 24, 2012
Messages
4,620
Location
Potsdam, Germany
Supports
Borussia Dortmund
So I hope I can help to get rid of this myth that BVB gives away players to Bayern basically for free. Because it is no longer true.
Yeah, good luck with that :lol:

This myth has been proven wrong half a dozen times in this very thread alone and it is still brought at least once every two pages. It is kinda amazing, actually. At the end of the day people will choose to believe what they want to believe.

The most ironic part about this whole argumentation of "if it would be this club they would have sold already" or "United tax" has a very strong possibility of being completely inconsequential as Dortmunds demands could have nothing to do with the other club but would be set terms between Sancho and Dortmund under which he is allowed to leave. That is still the only explanation I can think of why they went against their usual way of handling sales and made details of their demands so obviously public.
 

UncleBob

New Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2014
Messages
6,330
Nope. Assuming we fail this year, they will sell him next summer for approximately €120m, when there will be more suitors.

Contrary to reports that have been doing the rounds for the past six months, Sancho still has three years left on his deal, so he will hold his value next summer.
Yup. They might not have a shitload of suitors next summer, but given the length of his contract it simply means that they won't be forced to budge on their valuation. Difficult to see Dortmund losing out here.

If we want him, we'll have to pay what they want.
 

Coops73

Full Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2013
Messages
3,340
It was Watzke on Aubameyang - the others were Zorc. I have absolutely no idea what you’re saying regarding words against me. You think it’s a fact he’s staying - I’m merely pointing out that your club have said the same thing about 3x other players in recent history and you sold them all. That’s not hard to understand is it?
Seriously, you’re wasting your time he ain’t listening.
 

Infra-red

Full Member
Joined
May 4, 2010
Messages
13,423
Location
left wing
Yup. They might not have a shitload of suitors next summer, but given the length of his contract it simply means that they won't be forced to budge on their valuation. Difficult to see Dortmund losing out here.

If we want him, we'll have to pay what they want.
Exactly. I don't think there's any chance of a discount here - the only question is whether we are willing/able to come up with a payment structure for the €120m that has enough of the money upfront to satisfy Dortmund.
 

UncleBob

New Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2014
Messages
6,330
Exactly. I don't think there's any chance of a discount here - the only question is whether we are willing/able to come up with a payment structure that has enough of the money upfront to satisfy Dortmund.
No idea why the knobhead sign a contract extension in the first place.
 

2ndTouch

Full Member
Joined
Mar 13, 2015
Messages
2,644
Supports
Bayern München
I hope in two years after we buy Sancho, we waltz into Dortmund again, pay Haaland's release clause like a boss and make him a United player and a star. Small time stepping stone of a club they are
 
Status
Not open for further replies.