Sergio Reguilón

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
May 22, 2017
Messages
13,122
If this happens feels like such a panic buy, we weren't even linked with him before the EL final
I’m not sold on the guy, but who cares if we weren’t ‘linked’ with him. We monitor hundreds of players, and it’s nice to see transfers get done without tones of speculation, which 99% of which is BS anyway.
 

charlenefan

Far less insightful than the other Charley
Joined
Aug 17, 2005
Messages
33,052
Why's that? We need a quality fullback so when someone who fits the profile becomes available you go for it no?
Just seems to go against the extensive scouting and due diligence behind our signings under Ole and back to the scatter gun approach that was our transfer windows under LVG and Mourinho
 

Rozay

Master of Hindsight
Joined
Oct 22, 2012
Messages
27,201
Location
...
I would love to get a documentary or something where we can get a better understanding of Woodward's and Matt Judge's incompetence.
I imagine you’d end up very impressed and fascinated if you actually got to watch how they run a giant football club on a daily.
 

DON’T PANIC ™

Full Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2011
Messages
1,210
Location
Ireland
Are you old enough to remember the last 12 months RVN was at United?

We didn’t lose RVN to Real, we actively wanted him gone, anywhere. I loved RVN, but he had lost his place at the club, and he was even dropped for the League Cup Final. We actually sold him for a low fee given his record, and the fact he was still a good striker, just Fergie needed him to be sold.

No doubt Real are a big club. You would have been far better using Ronaldo as an example, instead you have just highlighted how we have used Real as an outlet to get rid of players we didn’t want, including RVN, Heinz and Hernandez.
I think Ruud falling out with Carlos Queiroz and Ronaldo was the main reason he was sold. Apparently he also took Keane’s departure badly.
 

dove

New Member
Joined
May 15, 2013
Messages
7,899
Would he be able to displace Shaw or would only be a backup to him? Can he actually defend too or is like Dalot? I have zero recollection how he did against us in the EL. We desperately need a LB because Shaw is injured a lot and Williams is nowhere near good enough to cover him but at the same time I wouldn't want want to sign another Dalot.
 

Kearnkoff69

Full Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
2,687
Location
yank
Would he be able to displace Shaw or would only be a backup to him? Can he actually defend too or is like Dalot? I have zero recollection how he did against us in the EL. We desperately need a LB because Shaw is injured a lot and Williams is nowhere near good enough to cover him but at the same time I wouldn't want want to sign another Dalot.
I only saw him play for Sevilla a handful of times last year - maybe 15-20 games over the course of the season - so take my opinion with a grain of salt. But I think he's a classic La Liga fullback. He is wicked going forward but lacks the defensive ability and nous of Shaw. I was reading up on him when we were first linked to see if my impressions were at all on point, here is the most succinct breakdown of how he compares to our current fullbacks:

That attacking focus would come at a cost though for United as Reguilon is a far weaker one-on-one defender than Shaw, whose tackling ability — which you can think of like a duel win-rate that’s weighted depending on how good the players you’re tackling are — is rated by Smarterscout as 73 to Reguilon’s 13. The Spaniard would improve the side but his possible addition would ask a lot from the person playing at left centre-back (more on that later).

Liverpool and, to a lesser degree, Manchester City (more so when Vincent Kompany was there) work well with advanced full-backs because they possess mobile defensive midfielders to stop the flow of attacks when their teams lose possession. Or, failing that, a robust centre-back who can dart out of the defensive line to deal with nascent counter-attacks before they become dangerous three-v-one situations.

Manchester United’s defensive midfielders are either not mobile enough (Matic) or strong enough (Fred) or do not possess the requisite ability when in possession (McTominay) to do the tactical fouling job as well as the Liverpool/Manchester City duopoly, and neither Maguire nor Victor Lindelof possesses the match-reading or ambition to dominate high-risk one-v-ones with any consistency.

(Carl Anka and Tom Worville, "Manchester United’s squad depth: the good, the bad and the weird," The Athletic, Sept. 3, 2020)
My conclusion: he'd be a good addition to the side, and a great weapon to bring on against low block sides when we need more attacking firepower, but he wouldn't displace Shaw completely, as we lack the defensive solidity to afford ultra-attacking fullbacks.
 
Last edited:

dove

New Member
Joined
May 15, 2013
Messages
7,899
I only saw him play for Sevilla a handful of times last year - maybe 15-20 games over the course of the season - so take my opinion with a grain of salt. But I think he's a classic La Liga fullback. He is wicked going forward but lacks the defensive ability and nous of Shaw. I was reading up on him when we were first linked to see if my impressions were at all on point, here is the most succinct breakdown of how he compares to our current fullbacks:



My conclusion: he'd be a good addition to the side, and a great weapon to bring on against low block sides when we need more attacking firepower, but he wouldn't displace Shaw completely, as we lack the defensive solidity to afford ultra-attacking fullbacks.
Ah, a bit underwhelming then but for the fee mentioned might be worth a try I guess.
 

Paxi

Dagestani MMA Boiled Egg Expert
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Messages
27,678
Ignore the text and watch the vid. Fergie IMO is referring to Ruud..

Goose bumps. Best manager ever without a shadow of a doubt.

Was talking about David Villa wasn’t he?
 

Woodenlung

Full Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2013
Messages
2,463
The reports coming from Spain are encouraging, but I'll wait for Manchester based journalists before thinking this is a sure thing. So far all they're saying is we're monitoring and that Matt Judge has met with Reguilons agent.
 

0le

Full Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2017
Messages
5,806
Location
UK
I've watched that Fergie clip many times in the and it still inspires me.
 

Phil

Full Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2003
Messages
11,404
I'm pretty excited about this one. I'm convinced that we need attacking fbs to help break teams down and support our forwards and it looks like he could be that.

There's been a lot of smoke on this one, knowing my luck there's no fire.
 

lysglimt

Full Member
Scout
Joined
Jun 1, 2008
Messages
15,319
If this happens feels like such a panic buy, we weren't even linked with him before the EL final
So if a manager watches a player impress against United - it is a panic-buy. But if a manager is sent reports from his scouts about a player - it is good scouting, and well planned ? Ronaldo, Saha, Tevez - examples of panic buys in United-history :)
 

charlenefan

Far less insightful than the other Charley
Joined
Aug 17, 2005
Messages
33,052
So if a manager watches a player impress against United - it is a panic-buy. But if a manager is sent reports from his scouts about a player - it is good scouting, and well planned ? Ronaldo, Saha, Tevez - examples of panic buys in United-history :)
Saha and Tevez weren't panic buys. Saha especially we scouted for years before we signed him
 

Kearnkoff69

Full Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
2,687
Location
yank
Ah, a bit underwhelming then but for the fee mentioned might be worth a try I guess.
He could prove my snap judgment wrong and obviously he's young enough to continue adding to his game. But I do agree with the analysis that we aren't properly set up to play with attacking fullbacks the way Barca, Bayern, Madrid, Pool, etc. do. Throw a more athletic CB like Dayot in the back line and replace Matic with a more mobile DM and it would be much more sustainable. That said, for the fee being bandied about I'd take Reguilon here as an intriguing alternative option to what we have.
 

0le

Full Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2017
Messages
5,806
Location
UK
He could prove my snap judgment wrong and obviously he's young enough to continue adding to his game. But I do agree with the analysis that we aren't properly set up to play with attacking fullbacks the way Barca, Bayern, Madrid, Pool, etc. do. Throw a more athletic CB like Dayot in the back line and replace Matic with a more mobile DM and it would be much more sustainable. That said, for the fee being bandied about I'd take Reguilon here as an intriguing alternative option to what we have.
Yes you are probably correct. I do think Ole recognises this though, based on the profile of the CB we seem to be looking for and the fact he sees someone like McT (who covers a lot of ground) to replace Matic.
 

7even

Resident moaner, hypocrite and moron
Joined
Jun 4, 2006
Messages
4,218
Location
Lifetime vacation
In some games I think (hope) we will see a Maguire - Shaw center back partnership with Reguilón as a hybrid fb/wb with license to bomb forward and with AWB in a more conservative position next Maguire/Shaw.

Luke has excellent acceleration and speed, I strong in duels and his reading of the game is underrated.

On a side note.
Jack Grealish would be a ideal left side offensive partner to Reguilón and O,e needs more offensive options if we don’t get Sancho.
 

led_scholes

Full Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2012
Messages
2,464
Just seems to go against the extensive scouting and due diligence behind our signings under Ole and back to the scatter gun approach that was our transfer windows under LVG and Mourinho
What extensive scouting?? Maguire? A player we wanted a year before? Wan Bissaka? The regular RB for another PL team? James, a player who was proposed by his national manager? Van Beek and Bruno players that everyone knows?
 

Canuckred64

Full Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2007
Messages
3,637
Location
Canada
If the reports are true, he has his heart set on Real Madrid and doesn't want to leave Spain. Throw in Real wanting a buy back clause and this should be a non-starter.
 

cyberman

Full Member
Joined
May 26, 2010
Messages
37,331
Just seems to go against the extensive scouting and due diligence behind our signings under Ole and back to the scatter gun approach that was our transfer windows under LVG and Mourinho
Coronavirus. Madrid need money and have to sell to balance the books.
These are the out of the blue opportunities that have come from it. Im sure we didnt have VDB in mind last February when he was a cert for Madrid.
 

Santoryo

ripping the reward
Joined
Apr 10, 2014
Messages
6,302
I said ages ago I thought this summer would be a repeat of 2018

GK 2018 Grant / 2020 Henderson
CM 2018 Fred / 2020 VDB
FB 2018 Dalot / 2020 Ruguilon

Failed to build on a 2nd place finish in 2018 and we'll fail to build on a 3rd place finish now
Not even remotely similar. That's summer we ended on a downward slop. We basically started the season better and progressively got worse so without much reinforcement we just ended up a.disaster the following season.

This season is completely different. We started bad and got better as the season progressed. Not to mention people don't realize how massive adding qualities of the likes of Pogba and Bruno improves us from the rubbish we were in the first part of the season.

People are judging and seeing this team as of the whole of last season when in reality this team is more akin to post lockdown form where.we showed the best or joint best form with City.

We've added VDB, Pogba and Bruno coming in or back, the improvement of Martial, the emergence of Greenwood post lockdown. When we factor all of this we are a far better and improved team. People will be surprised by how well we do this season reinforcement or not.
 

Rolaholic

Full Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2016
Messages
11,163
I'm pretty excited about this one. I'm convinced that we need attacking fbs to help break teams down and support our forwards and it looks like he could be that.

There's been a lot of smoke on this one, knowing my luck there's no fire.
I feel like quite a few fans will bee surprised at how lethal our attack would look with a full/left back who can overlap well regularly and actually pick his head up to cross accurately in the squad once again. It's probably because we've been lacking that for so long.

It's those simple things that we've sorely lacked on a consistent basis during the post-Fergie years as the game has evolved.
 

K Stand Knut

Full Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2008
Messages
5,213
Location
Stretford End
Not even remotely similar. That's summer we ended on a downward slop. We basically started the season better and progressively got worse so without much reinforcement we just ended up a.disaster the following season.

This season is completely different. We started bad and got better as the season progressed. Not to mention people don't realize how massive adding qualities of the likes of Pogba and Bruno improves us from the rubbish we were in the first part of the season.

People are judging and seeing this team as of the whole of last season when in reality this team is more akin to post lockdown form where.we showed the best or joint best form with City.

We've added VDB, Pogba and Bruno coming in or back, the improvement of Martial, the emergence of Greenwood post lockdown. When we factor all of this we are a far better and improved team. People will be surprised by how well we do this season reinforcement or not.
Wow.

Bold statement but loving the optimism
 

charlenefan

Far less insightful than the other Charley
Joined
Aug 17, 2005
Messages
33,052
Not even remotely similar. That's summer we ended on a downward slop. We basically started the season better and progressively got worse so without much reinforcement we just ended up a.disaster the following season.

This season is completely different. We started bad and got better as the season progressed. Not to mention people don't realize how massive adding qualities of the likes of Pogba and Bruno improves us from the rubbish we were in the first part of the season.

People are judging and seeing this team as of the whole of last season when in reality this team is more akin to post lockdown form where.we showed the best or joint best form with City.

We've added VDB, Pogba and Bruno coming in or back, the improvement of Martial, the emergence of Greenwood post lockdown. When we factor all of this we are a far better and improved team. People will be surprised by how well we do this season reinforcement or not.
Not even remotely similar?

17/18 - fell over the line to finish 2nd and ended the season losing a cup final
19/20 - fell over the line to finish 3rd and ended the season losing a cup SF

Summer 2018, sign a GK, midfielder and a cheap defender
Summer 2020, bring a GK back from loan, sign a midfield and if this thread is true a cheap defender

Not even remotely similar? Think you need to look that term up
 
Status
Not open for further replies.