Presume he will be playing against Dortmund tomorrow so we can all do a bit of scouting.
Jules Koundé | Signs for Barcelona
- Thread starter MyOnlySolskjaer
- Start date
- Status
He’s stronger than Lindelof, quicker than Lindelof and much better in one on one situation. His ball playing is also better, so not only he is the answer to Lindelof’s weakness but also an upgrade.
Being a top-class defender requires both, Carlos lacks one side and Lindelof the other, you see? Not that difficult.
Ok so you’re saying if we had a defender who wasn’t all out physical and was defending with rationale and skill that would be good?
So why the hell does everyone hate on Lindelof?
Essentially my point is Kounde isn’t the answer. He’s a good CB but no our solution
Koundé is quicker and physically stronger than Lindelof and actually has some bottle. They aren't comparable.
Is he though? Or is it just Lindelof is coming up against on average stronger opponents?
I’ll give you quicker.
Better 1vs1 is subjective and also relative quality is an issue.
Ball playing better again I’m not sure passing wise unless you mean on the ball as in dribbling?
I don’t see him moving to United and being the solution I think it’s another press hype after a great solo goal.
I agree it requires a bit of both. Kounde doesn’t have both yet.
We already have 3 very good CBs in Maguire, Lindelof and Bailly if we want to progress we can’t just add good ones with potential but flaws.
He is
Keeping teams away from your goal is the best way to defend set pieces.
keeping the ball is the best way to defend against any teams.
these 2 reasons are why we’ve struggled over the last few years as others have got better at it while we ignored it. We are getting there slowly but ole needs to stop worrying about fast counter attacks and we need to learn how to play a high line better.
players like Kounde are playing that exact game pressing game for sevilla right now, and they’ve had 7 clean sheets in the last few games in a row.
it’s no coincidence nobody good sits deep defensively.
Who is top of La Liga?
Can check him out tomorrow against Haaland. That's a big test.
I have watched Kounde in 7 full matches this season, I can guarantee you he’s better ball playing, better one on one, and stronger. How many games have you watch Kounde this season?
Süle might be available.
You’ll laugh but 8 and I don’t think you can make that guarantee.
I like Kounde I just don’t think he’s the solution for United.
How many games have you watch Kounde this season? I’m not asking you whether you like or dislike him.
You provide nothing to counter my argument though, at least provide stats or something to prove me wrong.
Well he's not got a single post in the La Liga thread so I'd hazard a guess at [X]
Thank you. Our single biggest issue as a squad (contrary to popular belief about needing a striker) is the inability to play a high line confidently. There's a reason we looked so solid when Bailly was fit a while back because we could defend much more aggressively and higher up the pitch, which in turn means that even if our attack is off of it we are consistently pinning the opponent in and having more cracks at creating chances than a team who defends deeper might.
Most fans don't seem to understand this though and I can't for the life of me understand why, as it's the reason both Liverpool and City have been so dominant in recent years. City isn't hoarding possession like Barca in '11, but they win the ball back so quick and high up the pitch that it makes attacking relentless on the opposition until they break down.
I've been banging this drum for years now and i've dedicated numerous posts to the subject.
Without repeating what i've said for a long time in its entirety, our current starting CBs don't allow us to play a 2-4-4 in possession. City and Liverpool can or have been successful in implementing the formation with their CBs, hence creating overloads in multiple offensive zones and thus putting the smaller teams to the sword.
Our teams attack would improve more with a Kounde or Konate than a RWF as things stand IMO. Because either Kounde or Konate are strong at defending the channel on their own as the RCB. That would then open up the opportunities for the RB and Right sided forward to overload the opposition with support from the right sided CM. We can't do this effectively currently and resort to dropping deeper with the double pivot and fullbacks in support of the CBs and the counter attack becomes the default setting. The counter press is also off the menu due to how deep we're.
Last edited:
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
You obviously don't watch much of Atletico, they don't play defensively unless it's against teams they know they can't keep possession against.
They are one of the most drilled teams on the planet though, and certainly the odd 1 out compared to the rest. Do you want us to play like Atletico?
You seem to watch every single team in the world an awful lot...
No I don’t. But the point stands. Top teams can defend deep but I agree we should now be ready to play higher up the pitch (which we have done this season hence our better goalscoring record but worse defensive record)
So I have to post in the La Liga thread if I watch La Liga?
Does this mean I have to post in the Eredivise for AZ, Bundesliga for Leipzig/Dortmund, Ligue 1 for AS Monaco etc?
8 games.
Consider you've got no issue commenting in every other thread you clearly have some knowledge in, I find it unusual that your thirst for discussion doesn't extend to the relevant threads. In a word, yeah, I think you're chatting bollocks.
Yes I watch a lot of football - for somebody who seems to have an opinion on everything and everybody I thought you'd do the same
At times you can't always play with a high line, but how often do you see City camped in their box having to defend an onslaught? it just doesn't happen. They defend from the front, keep a high line and any balls over the top get swept up by Ederson.
It feels like Ole wants to adapt to play this way but it's not possible with our personnel.
Pilger is also reporting in the piece below that the two targets are Kounde and Konate. Konate's injury history may go against him or Sevilla's asking price may be deemed too high by the club.
I'm beyond caring now, just hope Ole gets the player he desires.
I'm beyond caring now, just hope Ole gets the player he desires.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
It you absolutely must know I don’t go into those league threads because the chat is very sporadic and you get better discussion usually from individual player or transfer threads.
If you would like me to discuss in the La Liga thread and this is an invite I’m more than happy to do so but it’s not active enough for my liking.
Im sad enough to like chatting about football on RedCafe but not sad enough to lie about who I do or do not watch.
Would you like me to list the games
Yes, I'd like a comprehensive analysis and post mortem report on all those games. I want it written and on my desk by this afternoon, and I don't accept any excuses like "your dog ate it".It you absolutely must know I don’t go into those league threads because the chat is very sporadic and you get better discussion usually from individual player or transfer threads.
If you would like me to discuss in the La Liga thread and this is an invite I’m more than happy to do so but it’s not active enough for my liking.
Im sad enough to like chatting about football on RedCafe but not sad enough to lie about who I do or do not watch.
Would you like me to list the games
Should be our target no 1 for me. Has everything you want and we are looking for. Ever since we played them, i was convinced of his qualities.
Was really impressed with him when we last played them. Would be a good signing and certainly an upgrade on Lindelof.
I hate to jinx these things, but what’s his injury record like?!
I hate to jinx these things, but what’s his injury record like?!
Real Madrid are also strongly rumoured to be interested in him and are reported to be ready to offer fringe players like Isco and Diaz into the deal.
Yeah we can have all the Caf scouts running their expert eyes over him.
In reality they will check stats websites / Fifa21 to form an opinion and freak out over his 5'10 frame.
I hate all the stats that appear on here. Probably because I haven't a clue what they are talking about, or the stats look OK and someone on here is trying to tell us actually they are terrible.
Milenkovic?
That's not fair, we don't have players like Isco to add into a deal.
Being dishonest just to console yourself in the argument is pointless, but either way, it doesn’t really matter whether you are honest or no because I believe the issue here is that you don’t understand the problem with our centre back. Think of why Lindelof and Maguire cannot work together not just focus on Lindelof alone. They both are not mobile centre back and passive, they are too similar as Lindelof strength doesn’t compliment Maguire’s weakness at all while Maguire strength doesn’t compliment Lindelof’s weakness apart from the physical strength and the aerial presence.It you absolutely must know I don’t go into those league threads because the chat is very sporadic and you get better discussion usually from individual player or transfer threads.
If you would like me to discuss in the La Liga thread and this is an invite I’m more than happy to do so but it’s not active enough for my liking.
Im sad enough to like chatting about football on RedCafe but not sad enough to lie about who I do or do not watch.
Would you like me to list the games
To put it in short, you can’t play those two together.
Kounde has pace and aggressiveness (not fully aggressive like Bailly but he still able to play both aggressive and passive CB and he also can commit towards the ball rather than wait like Lindelof/Maguire), these compliment Maguire’s weakness. On top of it, he is a better ball playing centre back than lindelof (not talking about dribble but ball distribution is playing more risky passes and long ball, check stats below) and he is physically stronger and more muscular than Lindelof (check pic below). If you watch him, you should know these. He’s very good with his one on one, he’s not just good in positioning and decision making but he also combine those with his pace to be better than Lindelof in one on one.
I've a strong suspicion they'll end up signing him. Their allure is too strong.
I do agree from the little i've seen off him he's strong and can be very aggressive if needs be. He also doesn't skip leg day with the size of those quads.Being dishonest just to console yourself in the argument is pointless, but either way, it doesn’t really matter whether you are honest or no because I believe the issue here is that you don’t understand the problem with our centre back. Think of why Lindelof and Maguire cannot work together not just focus on Lindelof alone. They both are not mobile centre back and passive, they are too similar as Lindelof strength doesn’t compliment Maguire’s weakness at all while Maguire strength doesn’t compliment Lindelof’s weakness apart from the physical strength and the aerial presence.
To put it in short, you can’t play those two together.
Kounde has pace and aggressiveness (not fully aggressive like Bailly but he still able to play both aggressive and passive CB and he also can commit towards the ball rather than wait like Lindelof/Maguire), these compliment Maguire’s weakness. On top of it, he is a better ball playing centre back than lindelof (not talking about dribble but ball distribution is playing more risky passes and long ball, check stats below) and he is physically stronger and more muscular than Lindelof (check pic below). If you watch him, you should know these. He’s very good with his one on one, he’s not just good in positioning and decision making but he also combine those with his pace to be better than Lindelof in one on one.
It does feel something of an inevitability, thankfully there's not a shortage on CB talent at the moment.
PSG willing to pay his release clause apparently. We're not.
We got something better, we got Lingard or Pereira to sweeten te deal!
Honestly, I know the owner is rich but I‘m still not sure if PSG needs a very expensive centre back when they have Marquinhos and Kimpembe. They should be aiming to sign a much cheaper centre back to provide back up for those two.
Anything else would be a huge surprise.
- Status