No matter how critical I am towards Israel, I am on the side of peace and honestly hope to see these two peoples live side by side, in peace, in my lifetime. Both are great peoples.
I understand the Israelis posting here trying to defend their country, and remind us that they suffered a horrendous attack on 10/7. I truly do, even if I mightily disagree with some of them. Given their millenias long history of displacements, persecutions, pogroms and genocide, I get where they coming from and the siege mentality they've developped along the centuries. I have a great deal of respect for people like
@Amir, who despite everything tries to stay objective, and informs us about the pulse of the Israeli society. This is invaluable information and I hate it when people gang up on him.
I however doesn't have the single shred of consideration for the willfull ignorants, especially the ones who have no skin in the game, who deliberately ignore the roots of the conflict and try to be more papist than the Pope whilst selling their (unconscious or not) racist views under the pretense of defending Israel. Just like I find people using anti-Zionism (which is legitimate, Zionism being just an ideology) to cover up for their antisemitic views, utterly abhorrent.
What simultaneously amazes and terrifies me, isn't so much the complete and assumed racist stances like Haley's (and she's by far not the only one) or the genocidal takes of high ranked Israeli officials, but the absolute apathy and lack of meaningful pushback. That it became some kind of okay-ish opinion one could have as a US presidential candidate is mind-blowing. Just imagine the Russians, or anyone else, spouting this kind of discourse and the outrage it would cause. That's not even speaking about the active and successful attempts at shutting down any meaningful support to the Palestinian cause. This isn't happening in some backwater dictatorship, but in the heart of the West. There is an institutionalized anti-Arab sentiment that's transpiring through every single major political pore in the West, and it's been amped up since 9/11.
Massive shout-out to the Scots and the Irish though, their support for the Palestinian cause is heart-warming. You'd say they know a thing or two about occupation. But the major players in Europe, the UK, France and especially Germany, should hang their heads in shame.
The alliance between American Evangelical Zionists and Israel is as "unholy" and insane as it gets. From what I've read and understood, the Evangelicals believe that Jesus Christ can only come back and start Armageddon when the Jews regain of full control of the biblical Israel. You can imagine that the Palestinians are actually in the way. It also implies that the Jews heads will also be on the choping block if they don't embrace Christianity. Israel on the other side, and this is my personal opinion, doesn't believe a single word of this prophecy (who would?) and sees them as useful idiots who can provide money and firepower to achieve the conquest of Eretz Israel. After that, suck it up buttercup. If I'm wrong, anyone please correct me.
The Trump supporters and MAGA nuts are by essence isolationists, which isn't an uncommon stance in US history. They primarily focus on their own borders and reluctantly involve themselves international matters. They see themselves, and are more less geographically justified, as an island. "America first" is much more than an empty slogan and something every presidential candidate has to take into account. Preventing evil foreigners, who will undoubtedly corrupt the righteous Christian American way of life, to get through is God's work. The US is notoriously schizophrenic and has a godlfish memory, as well as a history of discriminating whatever new wave of immigrants that (perceivedly) untimely arrives. Irish, Italians, Jews, Poles, etc... Currently it's the South-Americans and Muslims, tomorrow it will be something else. Maybe aliens. Who knows.
You can't support Ukraine and be in favor of Israel's current response without critically endangering your brain through excess of mental gymnastics. And you won't find any better thread than this one on the net, in my opinion, if you want a level headed and informed discussion about the topic. Props to the moderators and administrators of this website.