Mason Greenwood | Please be respectful and stay on topic

Wibble

In Gadus Speramus
Staff
Joined
Jun 15, 2000
Messages
89,275
Location
Centreback
“These days”, when society is more accepting than ever before in history?

Not sure which rosey days you are looking back to? The days being gay was frowned upon? The days of Sean Connery and his “give em a little slap”? The apartheid days? The World Wars days? Queen Vic? Napolean?

Or in fact, for 99% of human history where people would barely blink twice at a man hitting his missus?
“These days” society is better than ever, but not all people think the same, never have, never will, and society certainly isn’t down the toilet due to that.
Things may have got a bit better but we still have a huge way to go when it comes to all things DV and sexual crimes related.
 

Wibble

In Gadus Speramus
Staff
Joined
Jun 15, 2000
Messages
89,275
Location
Centreback
That's actually a fair representation of how ridiculous this thread is right now.

We need a Loan Watch thread like we usually do for our players.

Meantime, if there's little will to discuss football in this thread, it'd make more sense to move this to the general forum and rename it accordingly.
No. We tried that and it was far worse.
 

United888

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Dec 4, 2023
Messages
240
Talented footballer with potential world class, 2 footed, best finisher in the club right now, and his general play is very matured and far above Rashford imo. With his talent, it is not difficult to find buyer who is willing to spend money on him and his wages is 75k pw. But I have a strong feeling Greenwood is going to be in United squad next season instead of being sold. We need a goalscorer, the manager always indicate to welcome him to his squad, the club doesn’t take into action to release him. The moment the club decided not to release him by paying 7.8m remaining his contract last summer indicates that the club still see valuable assets in him means the club prioritise the asset over the action he did. The club probably loan him out because the club felt he needs to get out of England for at least a season to cool down the hates and he needs a full match fitness.

I will feel nothing if he end up playing for this club again. I judge footballer based on what they do on the pitch not what they do outside the pitch. I judge Greenwood differently as a footballer and as a person. The same how I view Ryan Giggs, legend of the club and brilliant footballer, but I don’t rate him as a person.
 

Wibble

In Gadus Speramus
Staff
Joined
Jun 15, 2000
Messages
89,275
Location
Centreback
Apparently, Mason Greenwood is a special case. His transgression has to be discussed with his football ability, or randoms might think the Caf condones his alleged actions.
You know the reasons as they have been explained numerous times by GB and others yet you continue to deliberately misrepresent things

And by random I assume you mean numerous long term poster who have said exactly that and a number of mods who think that is how it appeared even if it wasn't the intent.

So stop it.
 

MackRobinson

New Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
5,134
Location
Terminal D
Supports
Football
You know the reasons as they have been explained numerous times by GB and others yet you continue to deliberately misrepresent things

And by random I assume you mean numerous long term poster who have said exactly that and a number of mods who think that is how it appeared even if it wasn't the intent.

So stop it.
Stop misrepresenting what? You even said it yourself:
There was (imo) no way either approach (1 or 2 threads) could succeed so going back to one thread was the only way of limiting the scale of the modding task I'd say (also problematic of course).

The biggest issue with a perform only thread in effects makes the Caf complicit in ignoring his demonstrably despicable behaviour.

Hopefully he will not be a United player soon so it is no longer a problem for the Caf.
I'm a random as well if it makes you feel better. I don't understand the hostility.

EDIT: I see you think I'm purposely omitting the issue of moderating two threads. Well, I'm not. I'm just commenting of what it seemed was the "biggest issue". That's all.
 

rimaldo

All about the essence
Joined
Jan 10, 2008
Messages
41,125
Supports
arse
where were all of you when epstein was arrested? he was excellent at building paedo islands. for that, we should have been able to look past all his transgressions, like building a paedo island.
 

Fridge chutney

Full Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2016
Messages
8,968
where were all of you when epstein was arrested? he was excellent at building paedo islands. for that, we should have been able to look past all his transgressions, like building a paedo island.
Can you please just focus on his performance as a stockbroker? We don't need to be reminded about his transgressions all the time.
 

Bright_Eyes

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Aug 31, 2015
Messages
128
Talented footballer with potential world class, 2 footed, best finisher in the club right now, and his general play is very matured and far above Rashford imo. With his talent, it is not difficult to find buyer who is willing to spend money on him and his wages is 75k pw. But I have a strong feeling Greenwood is going to be in United squad next season instead of being sold. We need a goalscorer, the manager always indicate to welcome him to his squad, the club doesn’t take into action to release him. The moment the club decided not to release him by paying 7.8m remaining his contract last summer indicates that the club still see valuable assets in him means the club prioritise the asset over the action he did. The club probably loan him out because the club felt he needs to get out of England for at least a season to cool down the hates and he needs a full match fitness.

I will feel nothing if he end up playing for this club again. I judge footballer based on what they do on the pitch not what they do outside the pitch. I judge Greenwood differently as a footballer and as a person. The same how I view Ryan Giggs, legend of the club and brilliant footballer, but I don’t rate him as a person.
Would you feel the same "nothing" though if he'd done what he was accused of to a family member of yours, your wife, your daughter? I think it'd be a bit harder to seperate and just enjoy his football then? I think people who can separate these things just don't feel empathy for strangers.
 

Pronewbie

Peep
Joined
May 17, 2004
Messages
6,701
Location
In front of My Computer
where were all of you when epstein was arrested? he was excellent at building paedo islands. for that, we should have been able to look past all his transgressions, like building a paedo island.
Isn't that what mainstream media, power structures and large swathes of society are doing - sadly enough - because the VVIPs who enjoyed their time on the island are still in their positions of power and get nowhere near the kind of pillorying MG gets despite their transgressions and denials.

The world is messed up as it is and there are a fair few of us who use football to unplug from all the politics, social injustices, warmongering, culture wars and whatnot because it's exhausting.
 

United888

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Dec 4, 2023
Messages
240
Would you feel the same "nothing" though if he'd done what he was accused of to a family member of yours, your wife, your daughter? I think it'd be a bit harder to seperate and just enjoy his football then? I think people who can separate these things just don't feel empathy for strangers.
I wouldn’t feel nothing for that, I would feel very upset. But that’s because I know how my family would react, and in reality my family would react differently to how the girlfriend and her family reacted. So the question you should ask yourself is If the victim feels nothing towards but still in love with Greenwood now, why should other people care more and feel something? The one who got involved don’t care, why should I need to feel something towards people who don’t care? It makes zero sense for me to feel bad towards her and her family when they act like this actually didn’t happen.

If she and her family feels something, they shouldn’t drop the charge, she shouldn’t live with Greenwood, they shouldn’t hang out anymore, they should have break up now, and she shouldn’t be posting smile and happy video with Greenwood in social media like they are lovely couple, and they shouldn’t be thinking to become a parent (she’s pregnant right now).
 

moses

Can't We Just Be Nice?
Staff
Joined
Jul 28, 2006
Messages
43,686
Location
I have no idea either, yet.
Apparently, Mason Greenwood is a special case. His transgression has to be discussed with his football ability, or randoms might think the Caf condones his alleged actions.
What do you mean 'apparently'?

You do know why he's on loan?

It's a pretty unique situation.

If your only contribution to this thread is to continuously reiterate how shit it is, maybe stay out of it?
 

Bondi77

Full Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2019
Messages
7,370
I wouldn’t feel nothing for that, I would feel very upset. But that’s because I know how my family would react, and in reality my family would react differently to how the girlfriend and her family reacted. So the question you should ask yourself is If the victim feels nothing towards but still in love with Greenwood now, why should other people care more and feel something? The one who got involved don’t care, why should I need to feel something towards people who don’t care? It makes zero sense for me to feel bad towards her and her family when they act like this actually didn’t happen.

If she and her family feels something, they shouldn’t drop the charge, she shouldn’t live with Greenwood, they shouldn’t hang out anymore, they should have break up now, and she shouldn’t be posting smile and happy video with Greenwood in social media like they are lovely couple, and they shouldn’t be thinking to become a parent (she’s pregnant right now).
When was her first kid born?
 

Rood

nostradamus like gloater
Scout
Joined
Jun 21, 2008
Messages
21,374
Location
@United_Hour
I see the names of Barton & Epstein appearing for some bizarre reason - interesting that those moaning about false equivalence are keeping quiet on these absolutely irrelevant comparisons!
 

flameinthesun

Full Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2014
Messages
2,089
Location
London
No. We tried that and it was far worse.
It definitely wasn't worse. For most of its life it was pretty chill, then near the end because some people were upset that it existed and that he was starting to perform well they did their best to derail it (even gloating in the general united thread about doing so) and it got closed (again with said posters gloating about its closure). This thread for example in general is a lot more chaotic than the loan one was. All the loan thread needed was those derailing it to be banned from it and it would have been like any other player discussion.
 

Wibble

In Gadus Speramus
Staff
Joined
Jun 15, 2000
Messages
89,275
Location
Centreback
It definitely wasn't worse. For most of its life it was pretty chill, then near the end because some people were upset that it existed and that he was starting to perform well they did their best to derail it (even gloating in the general united thread about doing so) and it got closed (again with said posters gloating about its closure). This thread for example in general is a lot more chaotic than the loan one was. All the loan thread needed was those derailing it to be banned from it and it would have been like any other player discussion.
It was far far worse. I'd say the modding effort was about 5x more than now. We thread banned many posters on both "sides" (which is a manual hassle in of itself) and that helped very little. Which is why it needed to be shut.
 

flameinthesun

Full Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2014
Messages
2,089
Location
London
It was far far worse. I'd say the modding effort was about 5x more than now. We thread banned many posters on both "sides" (which is a manual hassle in of itself) and that helped very little. Which is why it needed to be shut.
Fair enough.
 

Wibble

In Gadus Speramus
Staff
Joined
Jun 15, 2000
Messages
89,275
Location
Centreback
Absolutely, but pretending that suddenly society is in the toilet “these days” when we as a society have never been better with all of these matters is just plain idiotic.
Agreed. Many things have improved hugely. Although I'm of an age now where I should be grumbling as if civilisation totally went down the toilet in the 80's (ish)
 

moses

Can't We Just Be Nice?
Staff
Joined
Jul 28, 2006
Messages
43,686
Location
I have no idea either, yet.
Agreed. Many things have improved hugely. Although I'm of an age now where I should be grumbling as if civilisation totally went down the toilet in the 80's (ish)

Yeah I'm the same, we're moving in the right direction on almost all topics.
 
Last edited:

redcucumber

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2022
Messages
3,259
The one thing that this thread has thought me, and reading all the posts on social media with regards to Joey Barton and his opinions on women, is that I'm shocked at the amount of men out there who really don't give a shite about women, that they will find any excuse to defend the man in situations like this one with Greenwood. I mean is there really that many men out there that hate women that much?
It's utterly depressing.

This thread and Barton outing himself as an even bigger c**t (amongst many others) have made me question the way in which society is going.

Society is going in a grim direction.
It is utterly depressing seeing the nonsense of Barton and such like being supported.

But there’s a hell of a lot of people who are disgusted by the actions. Enough to get him banned from the club. So let’s not lose all perspective!
These unsubtle shitty arse kind of comments are precisely why this thread is a divisive cesspit. Because people on redcafe don't hold the same opinion as you on Mason Greenwood = society is fecked and men hate women. You sound like a bunch of fecking dolts. Cop on.

I've said before that if the club + ten Hag decide to show him the door then great, we can move on. But the way some carry-on in here it's no wonder this thread needs nuking. And it definitely comes from both sides, it's just one side seems to get pulled up on the antagonistic spiel a hell of a lot more than the other.
 

Yagami

Good post resistant
Joined
Jan 27, 2013
Messages
13,584
I think he's regaining some of his lost weight which is helping him as the season wears on. Getafe are however not helping his cause given the level of quality he is surrounded by and some of the manager's tactical choices. His confidence is definitely improving and one gets the impression he would benefit greatly from being surrounded by better players.
Agreed. It's coming together nicely for him. I see a bit more thrust in his play too, just based off highlights of course.
I actually think playing for this Getafe team will work out for him in the long run for the simple fact that he has to get involved in their general play there (often coming deep) because, otherwise, they don't do much.

Here, whilst we're not great ourselves, he could afford to drift out of games and still get a chance because we had the likes of, Martial, Rashford, Bruno, Pogba, etc at different points in form. At Getafe, there's no such luxury, and, as a result, he's already becoming the teams focal point which should elevate his general play to the next level. He's already trying to dictate things in a way he never did for us.
 

rimaldo

All about the essence
Joined
Jan 10, 2008
Messages
41,125
Supports
arse
These unsubtle shitty arse kind of comments are precisely why this thread is a divisive cesspit. Because people on redcafe don't hold the same opinion as you on Mason Greenwood = society is fecked and men hate women. You sound like a bunch of fecking dolts. Cop on.

I've said before that if the club + ten Hag decide to show him the door then great, we can move on. But the way some carry-on in here it's no wonder this thread needs nuking. And it definitely comes from both sides, it's just one side seems to get pulled up on the antagonistic spiel a hell of a lot more than the other.
totally agree. my fellow holocaust deniers and i are always met with derision and scorn but the same levels aren’t reserved for those who believe in it.
 

redcucumber

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2022
Messages
3,259
totally agree. my fellow holocaust deniers and i are always met with derision and scorn but the same levels aren’t reserved for those who believe in it.
:lol: fair. Greenwood is obviously a scumbag. Anyone that says it was make-up etc is def also a weapon. I don't think advocating for him to be at United means you are plotting to kill all women in society, though. Or maybe it does feck knows.
 

rimaldo

All about the essence
Joined
Jan 10, 2008
Messages
41,125
Supports
arse
:lol: fair. Greenwood is obviously a scumbag. Anyone that says it was make-up etc is def also a weapon. I don't think advocating for him to be at United means you are plotting to kill all women in society, though. Or maybe it does feck knows.
if your side of the fence contains the most weapons, it’s a good indication you might need to reconsider which side of the fence you’re on. i spent a lot of my time in here mocking people’s incorrect points of view and horrible takes, but for the record, i don’t blame greenwood. the jews are clearly responsible. i just haven’t pieced it all together yet.
 

sepulturite

Full Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2014
Messages
2,259
Go on then, tell me the time period that society wasn’t down the toilet? Back up your “these days” claim.
Show me a time when we as a society have been better at understanding and dealing with DV for example.

As Wibble says, we’ve still a long way to go, but undoubtedly we’ve never been better.
Nah I won't bother engaging with you, your a ridiculously aggressive, arseholey poster and always have been, I remember your shite in the COVID thread. So no I won't give you the time of day apart from this reply.
 

Fridge chutney

Full Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2016
Messages
8,968
I see the names of Barton & Epstein appearing for some bizarre reason - interesting that those moaning about false equivalence are keeping quiet on these absolutely irrelevant comparisons!
I'll let you figure out the difference here, Sherlock!
 

MackRobinson

New Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
5,134
Location
Terminal D
Supports
Football
What do you mean 'apparently'?

You do know why he's on loan?

It's a pretty unique situation.

If your only contribution to this thread is to continuously reiterate how shit it is, maybe stay out of it?
I've never once complained this is a shit thread. Only called out a poster for aggression towards someone with a differing opinion. Not sure why you made that up.

On that note, why are you so aggressive? You've done this before and it's tiresome.
 

moses

Can't We Just Be Nice?
Staff
Joined
Jul 28, 2006
Messages
43,686
Location
I have no idea either, yet.
I've never once complained this is a shit thread. Only called out a poster for aggression towards someone with a differing opinion. Not sure why you made that up.

On that note, why are you so aggressive? You've done this before and it's tiresome.
What's tiresome, and has been pointed out several times is moderation on this topic.

You being one of the reasons, so you won't be getting the patience from me that Wibble showed you.
 
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
23,016
Location
Somewhere out there
Nah I won't bother engaging with you, your a ridiculously aggressive, arseholey poster and always have been, I remember your shite in the COVID thread. So no I won't give you the time of day apart from this reply.
You should remember me backing up Sweden’s scientists and have a read of https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/coronavirus-excess-deaths-tracker.
Should make you rethink, though I doubt it will.

The guy who thinks society is down the toilet calls me agressive, like it. As always, and likely with Covid, if everyone doesn’t agree with you, society is shite.

You don’t need to engage, plenty did and agree that society is clearly in a better place than ever and whilst still has a way to go is moving in the right direction.
 
Last edited:

golden_blunder

Site admin. Manchester United fan
Staff
Joined
Jun 1, 2000
Messages
120,358
Location
Dublin, Ireland
You should remember me backing up Sweden’s scientists and have a read of https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/coronavirus-excess-deaths-tracker.
Should make you rethink, though I doubt it will.

The guy who thinks society is down the toilet calls me agressive, like it. As always, and likely with Covid, if everyone doesn’t agree with you, society is shite.

You don’t need to engage, plenty did and agree that society is clearly in a better place than ever and whilst still has a way to go is moving in the right direction.
Probably the wrong place to talk about this but I think that very much depends on what part of society you’re talking about. For example politically it’s been moving globally to the right. Not a great thing for society