The tactics were all wrong — not for the first time, simply sticking with a winning formation and lineup regardless of circumstance or opponent didn’t produce the hoped for outcome — and not rotating at all after the exertions of Sunday night and after a month of extreme fixture congestion was foolishly naive as well. Leaving Christian Pulisic on the bench was an especially hilarious choice, especially given his jaw-dropping impact when introduced on the hour-mark.
And then, there’s Kepa Arrizabalaga, who’s once again the lightning rod for all the criticism because he doesn’t dive helplessly and instead just stares helplessly. People of course appreciate effort. But the one thing we should appreciate more than just raw effort is actually good defending, strong midfield play, and not making stupid mistakes. Firmino getting between Zouma and Azpilicueta for a free header is not on Kepa. Willian turning the ball over to Keïta, with Jorginho and Kovačić both ahead of the ball already and Rüdiger not stepping up to give a free shot from 20 yards is not on Kepa — we seemingly can’t play Liverpool without someone scoring a worldie. Speaking of which, Trent Alexander-Arnold producing a world class free kick from what was, at best a questionable foul, is not on Kepa. Jorginho handling a Giroud clearing header on a corner and the ball falling to Wijnaldum for a snap-shot is not on Kepa.
Kepa’s of course not faultless, and certainly not flawless. He’s a non-presence in the six-yard box and on crosses and he has this amazing ability to make himself seem smaller than his nearly six-foot frame. His statistics are trash, and it’s been decided that he’s the worst. At this point, the narrative’s set to hound him out even if he improves. But Kepa’s far from the team’s only problem, and maybe not even the biggest problem, despite the deluge of criticism and constant overdue attention on him from all quarters, online and off, fans, media, Twitter, everyone.
Conceding five goals is a collective failing. Finding someone to blame might make it easier to handle things, but it’s far too narrow a view to be actually useful. It would be amazing and rather convenient if all we needed to do was change the goalkeeper to suddenly turn Chelsea into a title-contending team, consistent, confident, mistake-free. But that’s going to take time. It might of course involve jettisoning Kepa — if we can work that out somehow — but he probably should have company as we light that one-way rocket into the Sun. However, that’s not the focus right now and nor should it be. We have two games left, with two goals to accomplish: finishing in the top four and winning the FA Cup.
Kepa or not Kepa, Chelsea will have to do a lot better the next two weekends to finish the season in the top-four and with the FA Cup trophy as well.