Frenkie de Jong | The last muppeting lap

Frenkie to United?


  • Total voters
    2,033
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

UnitedSofa

You'll Never Walk Away
Joined
Jul 12, 2013
Messages
6,796

Adam-Utd

Part of first caf team to complete Destiny raid
Joined
Sep 10, 2010
Messages
39,954
I was under the assumption he’s coming here to be the box to box roll rather than the Rodri roll.
Well it depends if we play a 4-3-3 or a 4-2-3-1, but I suspect he will be the deeper CM with Fred/Fernandes pushing on.
 

TuzlaUnited

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Apr 5, 2022
Messages
102
no top player right now is going to jump as soon as we show interest. We won't compete for the league next season, we aren't in champions league, we are in another rebuild. If players like Pogba and his team had of sat down with the club during negotiations, and properly assessed the clubs goals, transfer policy, proposed style of play, where he would play etc, it would have saved both parties a lot of bother in the end. More complications arise in players jumping right in, when we wave money at them. We have to sell the club to players like De Jong, players who have no affiliation with the club, that's the way it is unfortunately.
Club should have plan what kind of football wants to play and buy players who fits in that idea.Managers should only be the "drivers" of the team.
This method of give the keys to the manager is outdated.If ETH crash and burns club will stuck with his players,just like with previous managers.
 

UnitedSofa

You'll Never Walk Away
Joined
Jul 12, 2013
Messages
6,796
Name a player who wouldn't need to be convinced to join us in our current state.
Our own fans have this over the top warped reality that United are such a disgusting prospect that literally NO PLAYER would jump at the chance to sign for us.

A lot of it is more “it looks worse than it actually is” yes we’re in a dire state but it’s not as bad as we fans make it out to be in reality
 

Nicoseth

Full Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2013
Messages
2,610
Location
Andrei Kanchelskis made me fall in love with Unite
Our own fans have this over the top warped reality that United are such a disgusting prospect that literally NO PLAYER would jump at the chance to sign for us.

A lot of it is more “it looks worse than it actually is” yes we’re in a dire state but it’s not as bad as we fans make it out to be in reality
Mate, I am sure that a lot of players would jump at the chance. But would any player who falls into that category make us better? Can we name a top player, someone who will take us up a level, who wouldn't need convincing to join us right now? Chances are, anyone who falls in to that category is wanted by other clubs, who could offer more stability and UCL football. We have just come off our worst premier league season ever, with a dressing room torn apart by infighting. The reality is, if we want to add real quality to the squad, we will need to convince players to join us.
 

Adam-Utd

Part of first caf team to complete Destiny raid
Joined
Sep 10, 2010
Messages
39,954
This could impact this deal.
It wont really. Either way they're like 1bn in debt. They need to pay it off and it doesn't matter if they refinance it, it's still there.

one way or another they're paying it off, but it means they won't be spending more than they earn put it that way.
 

Bojan Djordjic

Full Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2018
Messages
1,650
Our own fans have this over the top warped reality that United are such a disgusting prospect that literally NO PLAYER would jump at the chance to sign for us.

A lot of it is more “it looks worse than it actually is” yes we’re in a dire state but it’s not as bad as we fans make it out to be in reality
Yeah but its different for players already at Superclubs like FdJ. He's got everything he would have at United (pay, facilities, international exposure) but is probably going home after training to a villa with an outdoor pool and is guaranteed champions league football once the club doesn't actually go belly up. Don't know why people are being over sensitive about him "not wanting United". The fact is he has a better deal already so it's not unreasonable that he wouldn't want to move to a lesser proposition unless he absolutely has to. For these guys in their early twenties, United just aren't the superpower or force of attraction that an 80s kid like me has them internalised as.
 

Mr Pigeon

Illiterate Flying Rat
Scout
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
Messages
26,344
Location
bin
I'd be more worried about players who are eager to come here after the shitshow of last season. Even Ten Hag had to be given assurances before accepting the job.
I'm the same as you. The club has felt for a while now to be somewhere that players go when they want an easy ride and lots of cash. If he needs to be persuaded and after that he wants to join then how is that a bad thing? It would only be bad if he has zero interest in joining even after learning about the "project", and it turns out he's only signed up because he's a massive Disney fan.
 

DSG

Full Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2014
Messages
2,463
Location
A Whale’s Vagina
It's an awful lot of money for someone who doesn't do much
Getting De Jong would be the sign of our team changing to actually play quick possession based football. There aren't many midfielders out there like him - I haven't watched him the past two seasons but I would say he has similarities to Verratti.

He can get the ball to Bruno in good positions to play the through balls. We just need another midfielder next to him to help, Fred gets pushed around too easily sometimes.

Like Liverpool spent big on GK and CB to complete the jigsaw, that's what we need to do here so worth it.
People will need to understand the role he plays in a team.
Really interesting article about Pogba here and whether or not his time at United was a flop:
https://www.espn.com/sports/insider...g-paul-pogba-man-united-career-flop-not-fault

Disclosure: By season 3 I was over Pogba and wanted him gone

A lot of interesting facts about Pogba and his transfer:
* Pogba appeared in roughly 60% of PL league minutes while at United. When compared with other 100m transfers, that is actually on the high side! Other than Mbappe and Ronaldo, the other 100m transfers were a bust: Neymar at 45% of league minutes, Coutinho, Dembele, Felix, Hazard, Lukaku, all way below that!
* At Juventus, Pogba averaged 0.44 non-penalty goals plus assists per 90 min. United? Same, 0.44 per 90 min! Defensively, he was down a bit, but not much.
* United were +0.76 goal differential with Pogba on the field and +0.36 with him off the field.

Finally, of the 50 most expensive transfers of all time, just three were classic midfielders. Pogba, Arthur (was basically an accounting deal swap with Pjanic, so doesn’t count), and… wait for it… Frenkie De Jong. Generally, attackers and CBs tend to go for more money, whereas midfielders just cost less.

So, why are we again blowing our budget on another CM? Not that he’s not a good players, but look at The top clubs. They spend less on midfielders, but pay big money for attackers and CBs, sometimes FBs.

What are we doing? Is this a smart way to spend your money? And we still won’t have a DM to pair with FDJ?
 

joobier

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Messages
82
Location
Dharmaville
I wouldn't chase after a guy that doesn't want to be chased, no matter who he is. If a player has to be convinced to join United, it will never work.
The club is in shambles. The team and the hierarchy are just starting a rebuild after almost a decade of mediocrity. It’s arrogant to believe players shouldn’t need to be convinced to join us. We should be trying to convince everybody.
 

Devil may care

New Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2010
Messages
35,976
John Woo directs our transfer dealings! :D I think a reality check is needed when peple say we shouldn't need to convince players, the way the club has been run post Fergie has been farcical, we've not sniffed a PL or CL win in a decade, Liverpool and City are miles ahead of us and last season we saw the true toxicity within this squad bleed out into the open with numerous shameful performances, you're damn right a player at a top club is going to need some convincing to buy into United at the moment.


The anti-McTominay
Out of curiosity, Who else is in that 8%?
 

ZIDANE

Full Member
Joined
Jul 20, 2007
Messages
7,540
Location
Manchester
Supports
The Philosophy.
Really interesting article about Pogba here and whether or not his time at United was a flop:
https://www.espn.com/sports/insider...g-paul-pogba-man-united-career-flop-not-fault

Disclosure: By season 3 I was over Pogba and wanted him gone

A lot of interesting facts about Pogba and his transfer:
* Pogba appeared in roughly 60% of PL league minutes while at United. When compared with other 100m transfers, that is actually on the high side! Other than Mbappe and Ronaldo, the other 100m transfers were a bust: Neymar at 45% of league minutes, Coutinho, Dembele, Felix, Hazard, Lukaku, all way below that!
* At Juventus, Pogba averaged 0.44 non-penalty goals plus assists per 90 min. United? Same, 0.44 per 90 min! Defensively, he was down a bit, but not much.
* United were +0.76 goal differential with Pogba on the field and +0.36 with him off the field.

Finally, of the 50 most expensive transfers of all time, just three were classic midfielders. Pogba, Arthur (was basically an accounting deal swap with Pjanic, so doesn’t count), and… wait for it… Frenkie De Jong. Generally, attackers and CBs tend to go for more money, whereas midfielders just cost less.

So, why are we again blowing our budget on another CM? Not that he’s not a good players, but look at The top clubs. They spend less on midfielders, but pay big money for attackers and CBs, sometimes FBs.

What are we doing? Is this a smart way to spend your money? And we still won’t have a DM to pair with FDJ?
When you say clubs don't spend this much on midfielders....

Barca paid good money for....... De Jong!
City paid similar that we're talking about here for Rodri.
At the time Madrid paid good money for Modric, Chelsea/Kante, PSG pay Verratti a good salary.

Transfer budgets are hard to compare over time and factor in so many other aspects. Maguire cost the same as Ronaldo. I bet if PSG didn't flop in the CL and won it then Neymar would be seen as a success - same as Bale.
 

Yagami

Good post resistant
Joined
Jan 27, 2013
Messages
13,532
My boy Darder would've been higher had he not been moved further forwards in the final third of the season. Boy was killing it as the best midfielder in la liga in a deeper role.
 

USREDEVIL

Full Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2018
Messages
4,898
Location
California U.S.A.
If he comes here it would be the modern footballing equivalent of a caveman knocking out a sexy cavewoman with his club and dragging her to his cave for a "shagging" (added english slang for full effect).
 

ForeverRed1

Full Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2013
Messages
5,484
Location
England UK!
One thing that will favour frenkie coming to united.. is he will be wanted and needed here. Our fans still sang the names and clapped the dross last season so he will be idolised here, especially if he does well.

He could be the face of modern united, possibly captain. The catalyst that everything runs through. He hasn’t been used properly at Barca and they look at Gavi as more important. Our fan base is very good to our players compared to other clubs so he would feel that. Not many fan bases do that as well as united.
 

Natener

Full Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2011
Messages
1,930
He's said he prefers not to leave his dream club. I've yet to hear him say anything remotely negative regarding United. Don't get why some are so hung up about him not being keen to leave. If a deal is done he'll move and I expect to be professional at performing under ETH. Certainly more so than some of the useless primadonnas we have seen in our squad recently.
 

Rozay

Master of Hindsight
Joined
Oct 22, 2012
Messages
27,199
Location
...
One thing that will favour frenkie coming to united.. is he will be wanted and needed here. Our fans still sang the names and clapped the dross last season so he will be idolised here, especially if he does well.

He could be the face of modern united, possibly captain. The catalyst that everything runs through. He hasn’t been used properly at Barca and they look at Gavi as more important. Our fan base is very good to our players compared to other clubs so he would feel that. Not many fan bases do that as well as united.
We’re no better than anyone else tbh.
 

UnitedSofa

You'll Never Walk Away
Joined
Jul 12, 2013
Messages
6,796
One thing that will favour frenkie coming to united.. is he will be wanted and needed here. Our fans still sang the names and clapped the dross last season so he will be idolised here, especially if he does well.

He could be the face of modern united, possibly captain. The catalyst that everything runs through. He hasn’t been used properly at Barca and they look at Gavi as more important. Our fan base is very good to our players compared to other clubs so he would feel that. Not many fan bases do that as well as united.
Is this a joke? The CAF constantly overly criticises our own players, as do people on social media. Look at the treatment Maguire & Lingard get/got for an example.

Now I know the fans online are very different to match going fans but we’re no angels.
 

RedPed

Whatabouter.
Joined
Jun 24, 2015
Messages
14,558
Ten Hag had to be convinced.
What about a manager?
I'd be more worried about players who are eager to come here after the shitshow of last season. Even Ten Hag had to be given assurances before accepting the job.
Of course, it's slightly different for a manager and I fully doubt that ten Hag had to be 'convinced'. This is still Manchester United we're talking about and 98% of managers would take the job. All ten Hag needed was some clarity and assurances given the previous years of chaos around the club. No way was he going to turn it down.
 

Rozay

Master of Hindsight
Joined
Oct 22, 2012
Messages
27,199
Location
...
Is this a joke? The CAF constantly overly criticises our own players, as do people on social media. Look at the treatment Maguire & Lingard get/got for an example.

Now I know the fans online are very different to match going fans but we’re no angels.
Our matchgoing fans also boo our players when they fancy it. All fans tend to think they are better than others but I don’t see it here.
 

Withnail

Full Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2019
Messages
30,246
Location
The Arena of the Unwell
Problem with Pogba is he tried to spread himself to wide, if De Jong can be the center of a united side that dictates most games he'll be seen as a good buy.
He didn't try to do that. He just has zero positional discipline and needs someone in his ear the whole time.
 

edcunited1878

Full Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2014
Messages
8,935
Location
San Diego, CA
Woah, Valverde ranks so high, modric is to be expected.
Thanks, a few unexpected names in that list!
That chart isn't representing those passing stats that rank him in the top 8% of succssful passes under pressure. The article doesn't state who the other 8% are.

This chart is ball carriers/dribbling. But FDJ is a very good ball carrier and very good passer in La Liga. So he's one of the best midfielders in his respective league when it comes to advancing the ball overall and accurately/efficiently.
 

RedPed

Whatabouter.
Joined
Jun 24, 2015
Messages
14,558
Not true at all, is it? They just have to be convinced that we are getting things right again. They don't want to waste their career. You think City were able to lure Aguero and David Silva over with just a paycheque? They had a project that they sold to them and they became legends there. Top players will look at what happened to Pogba and worry for themselves. It's up to the club to convince them that is no longer the case and we are stopping the decline. Ten Hag is a much bigger lure than the club name at this point for someone like De Jong, who is at an equally big club already.
Yeah fully agree. I'm talking about when players have had that talk and they're still dithering. Though no-one knows what conversations have taken place at this stage so it's all speculation...as usual.
 

Ted Lasso

Full Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2021
Messages
1,930
Is Frenkie De Jong really 80m Euros better than giving Donny a proper go?
Donny and Frankie were both integral parts of the Ajax side coached by ETH that was seconds away from a Champions League final having defeated no small fish in Juve and Madrid en route to that semi. They out possessed both teams at home and had very competitive showings away. That was in 2019.

The idea of a paying $120M combined three seasons on for that pairing, knowing what they accomplished together under the same manager is honestly pretty reasonable in today's market. If anything time has shown is that Donny is the odd man out without a proper system and midfield partnership. Just trying Donny out would be far more likely to fail than bringing in FDJ.

The third player in that trio, Schone, we could probably get away with Fred in that role for this season. A player with a lot of potential in the right system.

This is an absolutely phenomenal transfer if it can happen.
 

jesperjaap

Full Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2014
Messages
5,743
Feel a bit sorry for him really, at his dream club and maybe forced out to pay debt from how awfully they have been run.

No doubt for me he is one of the best midfielders in the world and if Rice/Bellingham are £100m players then £60m for DeJong is a great deal (if he was to come with the right mindset)

But it does concern me the biggest links so far sem to be with DeJOng and Nunez (who Im not so enthused about)......we must be looking at £130-150m for those two, add in maybe Timber and we are near £200m on three players, where does that leave us in terms of signing a defensive midfielder as that isnt DeJong, or a right back or attackign wide player. We cant sign them all of course but we should learn from last season, three quality signings papaers over cracks when there are several holes.

I still dont think he comes anyway as great as he would be but a part of me wants to see more hidden gems though I know little about them such as an Enzo Fernandes for example.

I dont think we can do two big signings this summer and srot out our weaknesses, I think we can only do one, DeJOng is certainly of tha ilk, not sure Nunes is, think we should be looking elsewhere there (partly wonder if that is already it, if we fail for DeJOng then we spend the big fee on him)
 

bond19821982

Last Man Standing champion 2019/20
Joined
Oct 26, 2008
Messages
10,427
Location
Nnc
Donny and Frankie were both integral parts of the Ajax side coached by ETH that was seconds away from a Champions League final having defeated no small fish in Juve and Madrid en route to that semi. They out possessed both teams at home and had very competitive showings away. That was in 2019.

The idea of a paying $120M combined three seasons on for that pairing, knowing what they accomplished together under the same manager is honestly pretty reasonable in today's market. If anything time has shown is that Donny is the odd man out without a proper system and midfield partnership. Just trying Donny out would be far more likely to fail than bringing in FDJ.

The third player in that trio, Schone, we could probably get away with Fred in that role for this season. A player with a lot of potential in the right system.

This is an absolutely phenomenal transfer if it can happen.
Agree. Fred or even Scott would take that DM role next to him. Add Sancho and Bruno in the wide roles , we really have something to build on.
 

jesperjaap

Full Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2014
Messages
5,743
Agree. Fred or even Scott would take that DM role next to him. Add Sancho and Bruno in the wide roles , we really have something to build on.
Disagee, we have seen neither are intelligent or good enough for that role and if they are our only options, we are still weak. DeJong isnt a defensive midfielder, he presses but he is all about his ability with the ball, DeJong and one of McFred and we still have the same problem in my opinion of gettign completely over ran and countered irrespective of what is improved tactially by the new manager.

A quality defensive midfielder is paramount this summer, I am genuinely baffled people think we can make do with half of McFred after the last two seasons of them playing there, shocking from any fan who has watched us, its our biggest priority
 
Status
Not open for further replies.