I think you're both right and wrong here. Yes, he is good at playing the ball out of defence - as you say, his size makes him look a bit clumsy sometimes but his feet are actually very good. And yes, Lindelof is good at it too (and Shaw, obviously). But the problems we've had in recent matches playing it out aren't because Fred and McT aren't good enough on the ball. It's because their movement off it is not intelligent enough, so they take too long to get open when Maguire and Lindelof are looking for them. And Maguire and Lindelof, for their part, just do everything much too slowly and deliberately. It makes them far too easy to close down. They need to be more confident in their own ability and more the ball forward more decisively, and McT and Fred need to work on that Scholes thing of always being free for the ball.