Is Steven Gerrard a top 5 all time PL c**t?

[Tarrou]

I have a clear top 4 of;

Terry
Suarez
Keown
Barton

Stevie's battling it out with the likes of Ashley Cole, Fabregas, Gallas, Mings, and Fellaini for a place in the top 5

probably some I'm forgetting

 

[Berbaclass]

I'd put Azpilicueta in there TBH. Can't stand him.

 

[T00lsh3d]

I have a clear top 4 of;

Terry
Suarez
Keown
Barton

Stevie's battling it out with the likes of Ashley Cole, Fabregas, Gallas, Mings, and Fellaini for a place in the top 5

probably some I'm forgetting

Really?

 

[peridigm]

You forgot Costa

 

[Tarrou]

Really?

you think he's clearly top 5?

 

[Berbaclass]

Also, Fernandinho

 

[T00lsh3d]

you think he's clearly top 5?

No I didn’t think he was all that bad!

 

[Tarrou]

You forgot Costa

he's almost artistic about it, I can't help but admire it

 

[Tarrou]

No I didn’t think he was all that bad!

he threw a pizza at Fergie, the little weasel

 

[moses]

Nowhere near. He's just a scouser.

 

[T00lsh3d]

he threw a pizza at Fergie, the little weasel

Im thinking about serial hatchet merchants like Ben Thatcher & Joey Barton being higher on the cnut list. Plus generally I don’t mind receiving pizza in any manner, so he’s welcome round mind anytime

 

[horsechoker]

Don't think he makes top 5 but maybe top 10.

Do we also count off field conduct too? In that case Mendy (allegedly) and Adam Johnson should be on the list.

 

[Red-Man-Walking]

Tbf Keano probably gets in ahead of Gerrard; he was a bit of a twat but he never went out with a premeditated plan to "do" someone.

Can't argue with full kit racist, bitey racist or assaulting your own teammate. Keown is definite top 10 but dunno if there's someone else being forgotten who might edge him out.

 

[Tarrou]

Im thinking about serial hatchet merchants like Ben Thatcher & Joey Barton being higher on the cnut list. Plus generally I don’t mind receiving pizza in any manner, so he’s welcome round mind anytime

I forgot about Thatcher, good shout

now I'm not saying this is conclusive evidence or anything, but Stevie has two entries on is-a-cnut.com, read into that what you will

 

[2cents]

Don’t think Gerard makes the top 5 on an individual basis, it was more that he was representative of Liverpool and it was fun to see him humiliated.

Other candidates in addition to those above:

Dennis Wise
Neil Ruddock
El Hadj Diouf
Lee Cattermole
Kevin Davies
Lee Bowyer
Ben Thatcher

 

[The Plump Poet]

Robbie Savage? Lee Bowyer? Ryan Giggs is a monumental cnut. As is Ben Thatcher.

Gerrard probably wouldn't crack my top 20.

 

[P-Ro]

I'd put Azpilicueta in there TBH. Can't stand him.

I can get that he's annoying to oppos but there's no way he should be mentioned in the same breath as some of the cnuts this league has seen. He's not a cnut off the pitch and whilst he moans a lot & exagerates injuries, it's not like he tries to injure other players. He's not even close to being the most dislikeable person in our team considering we've got [Irrelevant point], Lukaku and Pulisic.

 

[Red4Ever]

Gerrards not up there for me
The passage of time has eased my hatred of him
Seems a good manager too

 

[Tarrou]

Don't think he makes top 5 but maybe top 10.

Do we also count off field conduct too? In that case Mendy (allegedly) and Adam Johnson should be on the list.

if we're counting off-field stuff I'd concede Stevie would lose out

although he did beat up that guy who wouldn't put Phil Collins on the juke-box

 

[T00lsh3d]

I forgot about Thatcher, good shout

now I'm not saying this is conclusive evidence or anything, but Stevie has two entries on is-a-cnut.com, read into that what you will

Yeah that’s quite an achievement

 

[T00lsh3d]

Don’t think Gerard makes the top 5 on an individual basis, it was more that he was representative of Liverpool and it was fun to see him humiliated.

Other candidates in addition to those above:

Dennis Wise
Neil Ruddock
El Hadj Diouf
Lee Cattermole
Kevin Davies
Lee Bowyer
Ben Thatcher

Quite the list there….that’s most of the way to an all-time pl cnut 11

 

[youngrell]

A few more for the list, some a bit more low-key:

Craig Bellamy (but loved him for Wales)
Robbie Savage
Michael Brown
Alan Shearer

 

[Berbaclass]

I can get that he's annoying to oppos but there's no way he should be mentioned in the same breath as some of the cnuts this league has seen. He's not a cnut off the pitch and whilst he moans a lot & exagerates injuries, it's not like he tries to injure other players. He's not even close to being the most dislikeable person in our team considering we've got [Irrelevant point], Lukaku and Pulisic.

He's a despicable character.

 

[Stobzilla]

Adam Johnson
Barton
Giggs
Ben Thatcher

Gerrard might crack top 20 but there are a fair few ahead of him.

 

[Tarrou]

Gerrard might crack top 20 but there are a fair few ahead of him.

very similar to the top 5 CM discussion then

 

[P-Ro]

He's a despicable character.

I think this video shows his better side. Think you'll enjoy x

Tweet

— Twitter API (@user) date

 

[Steve Bruce]

Dennis wise, rudduck, Jones, Keane, John fashanu, batty, sol campbell, keown, milner.... I can go on and on....
.

 

[Klopper76]

El Hadji Diouf was a piece of work. Carragher's had his moments as well. That's if you're really desperate to have another Liverpool player in there.

 

[Tarrou]

El Hadji Diouf was a piece of work. Carragher's had his moments as well. That's if you're really desperate to have another Liverpool player in there.

I feel like Mascherano could have been in the conversation if he had more time

 

[Ayoba]

What about that prick Lee bowyer! Always hated him at Leeds

 

[Mike Smalling]

Besides the diving (which, let’s be fair, has almost become the norm) and the camera kissing, was he really all that bad?

 

[moses]

Diouf, Ruddock and Suarez would be the three dippers in a PL 11

 

[Grylte]

Vinny Jones, or was he before the PL started?

 

[Tarrou]

Besides the diving (which, let’s be fair, has almost become the norm) and the camera kissing, was he really all that bad?

yes

 

[P-Ro]

Vinny Jones, or was he before the PL started?

He was Wimbledon's captain during the PL era.

 

[P-Ro]

Wimbledon had a few pretty brutish players in both the crazy gang era and in the late 90s. The worst of the lot of them was Fashanu and Ben Thatcher. Vinnie was pretty nasty but those two went out to put people in ambulances.

 

[Red the Bear]

I would imagine that several of our players are on that list from a neutral's point of view.

 

[Cloud7]

Are we talking on the field or off it? There were guys like Drogba who I couldn’t stand on the field but were exemplary guys off it, then people like Giggs who are the reverse.

 

[Heardy]

Almost a full page and nobody mentioned Jonjo Shelvey?

 

[Rhyme Animal]

“Ehhhmm”