is this the greatest goal ever disallowed?
- Thread starter jdmufc
- Start date
Schmeichel's wasn't bad
I was going to propose this, but Keegan's is probably better
However, this might be a contender...
However, this might be a contender...
This one was brilliant and nothing wrong with it.
Stephen Carr v Man Utd?
I'll put forward this sublime effort from Hristo Stoichkov against Spain at Euro 96 for consideration:
i´m still struggling to see why the keegan goal i started this thread with was disallowed.
Just to laugh at Mascherano
Think it was back in the day before the "active in play" part of the offside rule was introduced, so the teammate that was in front of the goalkeeper was offside.
maybe i´m being a bit dim here but isn´t the ball headed out by a united player?
The player is offside right after Keegan strikes the ball.
so you couldn´t even stand in an offside position? i used to play a bit myself back then and i dont remember it being like that*
*to be fair to me,my memories so bad i´d even forget my balls if they weren´t in a bag.
That one was allowed, unless you're on about a different great Stephen Carr goal against us, which would seem unlikelyI assume he ment Pedro Mendes, when Carroll fecked up, which wasn't a great goal but more a great mistake.
Funny because it was Keegan though
Even funnier because it was against United
Even funnier because it was against United
Ole's goal v. villa was class. It was the last or second last year of his career. Sick goal.
It's certainly not the greatest ever, but I was always pissed off this never stood.
oops, yeah I meant that one
One of the disallowed goals that annoyed me the most was Best v Banks when he took the ball as Banks tossed it to kick. At that stage they hedn't 'clarified' the law to make it illegal either.
This was the one I thought of when I saw the thread, difficult to say either way whether it should have been allowed. Nani does look marginally offside but I'm not sure whether he gets a head to the ball before it crosses the line.
Cavani's , wow !!
I can't see the vids at work.
Has anyone posted the Ronaldo goal (for Portugal), where Nani f'd him off no end
?
Maybe not the greatest ever, but Ron's fury at Nani is priceless
Has anyone posted the Ronaldo goal (for Portugal), where Nani f'd him off no end
?Maybe not the greatest ever, but Ron's fury at Nani is priceless
Yeh someone posted that one. Funny as feck.I can't see the vids at work.
Has anyone posted the Ronaldo goal (for Portugal), where Nani f'd him off no end
Maybe not the greatest ever, but Ron's fury at Nani is priceless
Still can't believe Nani did that!
That is crazy and pointless from Nani. What to head the ball 1 yards in front of the empty net. Any decent footballer would know the ball would go in anyway.
Nani - what a twat!!!
This one pissed me off more than any...
Fixed.
Awful awful decision. Video technology anyone?
When Nani headed the ball I think it already crossed the line.It should have stood but it was still extremely stupid from him to touch it
It was idiotic on Nani's part but wasn't the defender that Ronaldo left on his arse playing him onside anyway?
I don't think so but it's impossible to tell. Nani's not on screen when the ball is played. There's another Portugese player in the 6 yard box who is onside but it looks as though Nani might be another yard or two closer to the byline (albeit out of shot).
Michel Platini's disallowed goal vs Argentinos Juniors:
Platini best goal Argentinos jr. 1985 - YouTube
George Best Disallowed Goal v England's Gordon Banks at Windsor Park (15 May 1971):
George Best Disallowed Goal v England's Gordon Banks at Windsor Park (15 May 1971) - YouTube
Platini best goal Argentinos jr. 1985 - YouTube
George Best Disallowed Goal v England's Gordon Banks at Windsor Park (15 May 1971):
George Best Disallowed Goal v England's Gordon Banks at Windsor Park (15 May 1971) - YouTube