Kalvin Phillips

GazTheLegend

Full Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2014
Messages
1,306
I think we need to get a functioning system before we start buying players to fit into it

I'm pretty sure that if our midfield was comprised of Henderson, Milner, Keita and Wijnaldum we'd be saying that they were not good enough as they'd look useless in our non-system
I feel like we have a player problem not a system problem.

Tell me that our results wouldn’t improve if we didn’t replace Lingard with de Bruyne, or Young with TAA.

Or you could even go to lower level clubs and say would we not improve with Neves and Grealish instead of Lingard and Fred?

Our system makes chances and restricts teams, it’s just that bit of quality in midfield we are struggling badly with imo
 

jackal&hyde

Full Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2018
Messages
1,120
I feel like we have a player problem not a system problem.

Tell me that our results wouldn’t improve if we didn’t replace Lingard with de Bruyne, or Young with TAA.

Or you could even go to lower level clubs and say would we not improve with Neves and Grealish instead of Lingard and Fred?

Our system makes chances and restricts teams, it’s just that bit of quality in midfield we are struggling badly with imo
We would have been top at this point had we had Pogba and Martial fit for the season.
 

Zed 101

Full Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2014
Messages
446
would be keen on him but would Leeds sell to us???? especially when trying to get promoted??? if it were possible definitely, just think yet another pie in sky player akin to Maddison and Grealish, not sure if Woodward is working on anything but focusing on players are not realistic is our modus operandi
 

Danny Roberts

Full Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2017
Messages
1,228
Location
Watching the game
I've watched a lot of leeds and I'd say he's good but nowhere near the quality for a title push. He's only just 24 though so he could develop a fair bit but they turned down £20m in the summer so I can't see him going to us for less than £35m which would be far too much.
 

Mainoldo

Full Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2004
Messages
14,331
He won’t play like that for us. Ole would ruin his progression.
 

Rocknrolla69er

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Mar 15, 2015
Messages
288
Yes a player who could not break into the Brighton team 4 months ago is better than Lindelöf.

People seem to have short memory at times. Lindelöf has always struggeled in the first half of the season, but been better in the second half of the season. At the moment he is our best CB as Maguire looks tired.

Phillips was solid today, but is he a average player in a good system or is he really class? Would have him over Matic tbf.
Just because a young player couldnt break into a team doesnt mean hes not good, i remember a certain Maguire who couldnt get a game at Hull city when it was obvious he was better than Curtis Davies at the time and look how that turned out.

I rate White and Phillips as better currently than Lindelof and Matic

Lindelof gets bullied
 

Powderfinger

Full Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2015
Messages
723
Supports
Arsenal
I was impressed by him yesterday. He did a very nice job moving for the ball, losing his marker, and getting them started in possession and he was pretty good shielding the defense in general. I don't think he has an elite ceiling or anything like that but he might be good enough to be a quality squad player at a top side.

Its hard for me to imagine Leeds selling in January though, especially after last year when they fell apart during the run-in and missed the automatic promotion places. They have a nice cushion right now and I doubt they'll be eager to take any chances by weakening the side in a key position.
 

arthurka

Full Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2010
Messages
11,436
Location
Rectum
I´ve said it before think we should go in for this guy, he has great abilities and the right attitude.
 

Inigo Montoya

Leave Wayne Rooney alone!!
Joined
Oct 1, 2008
Messages
23,642
I hope you are kidding.
He’s not! Just about every post is rubbishing Utd in every way. He’ll see a negative in everything that we do or is reported about us.

If you were in a pub with him, you’d soon feck off as it would bore you and start bringing you down :lol:
 

devips

Full Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
782
He’s not! Just about every post is rubbishing Utd in every way. He’ll see a negative in everything that we do or is reported about us.

If you were in a pub with him, you’d soon feck off as it would bore you and start bringing you down :lol:
Is he actually a United fan?
 

Mainoldo

Full Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2004
Messages
14,331
I hope you are kidding.
I wish I was. I’m negative around anything around Ole. Other than that.. I’m good. I actually like the players other than some people but get criticised for not liking the manager. Even though he’s clearly shite.
 

theklr

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Aug 8, 2019
Messages
403
I wish I was. I’m negative around anything around Ole. Other than that.. I’m good. I actually like the players other than some people but get criticised for not liking the manager. Even though he’s clearly shite.
But dont you think Ole has contributed at least somewhat to Mason, Williams and maybe Martial and Rashford’s improved form?
 

Mainoldo

Full Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2004
Messages
14,331
But dont you think Ole has contributed at least somewhat to Mason, Williams and maybe Martial and Rashford’s improved form?
Yes contributing as in picking them. I’ll give him credit for that. But there is going to be a point as with many young players we’re they need to develop and kick on. Like Jose’s claim as he gave Rashford minutes same for Ole it won’t be enough. Jose tactically stifles youth development Ole allows the players to express themselves which is why Rashford is benefiting but they also need to work on aspects of there game which Ole hasn’t and can’t improve.

In my opinion that is.
 

ash_86

Full Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2013
Messages
5,525
Yes contributing as in picking them. I’ll give him credit for that. But there is going to be a point as with many young players we’re they need to develop and kick on. Like Jose’s claim as he gave Rashford minutes same for Ole it won’t be enough. Jose tactically stifles youth development Ole allows the players to express themselves which is why Rashford is benefiting but they also need to work on aspects of there game which Ole hasn’t and can’t improve.

In my opinion that is.
It's not just about freedom is it. I can see Ole setting Rashford specific targets that Rashford is hitting pretty well. For starters, Rashford was severely one footed when Ole came in. Several times Ole has mentioned that he is working with Rashford to improve his left foot. Fast forwarding to today, Marcus has vastly improved his shot with his left. Goals against Sheffield , Partizan(at home) all allude to this fact. As a next, Headers is being improved upon. It's clear as day to see the improvements.

Our front 3 of Martial, Rashford and Greenwood has more goals than Livepool's front 3 this season. You cannot just dismiss the feat as "Ole asked them to Express themselves and thats it". There are also major developments on players like Fred who was bound to be a waste of space before Ole came in.
 

spiriticon

Full Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2013
Messages
2,467
When I see this thread I keep thinking of the deadly ex-Sunderland striker who's about 50 years old now.

He probably could still score more than Lingard.
 

Mainoldo

Full Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2004
Messages
14,331
It's not just about freedom is it. I can see Ole setting Rashford specific targets that Rashford is hitting pretty well. For starters, Rashford was severely one footed when Ole came in. Several times Ole has mentioned that he is working with Rashford to improve his left foot. Fast forwarding to today, Marcus has vastly improved his shot with his left. Goals against Sheffield , Partizan(at home) all allude to this fact. As a next, Headers is being improved upon. It's clear as day to see the improvements.

Our front 3 of Martial, Rashford and Greenwood has more goals than Livepool's front 3 this season. You cannot just dismiss the feat as "Ole asked them to Express themselves and thats it". There are also major developments on players like Fred who was bound to be a waste of space before Ole came in.
His finishing is not the part of the game that’s been concerning and he still finishes like he did 24 months ago, I don’t see anything different in his style he is still instinctive. What he severely lacks is a football brain.. and he’s yet to improve on that. Against Wolves was probably the most recent explain. We was on the attack on the left hand side with Williams making a perfect run on the outside of him.. instead of waiting to give that ball he cuts inside into traffic and loses possession trying to play the eye of a needle pass.

The way we play these attacking plans should happen every game.. he should already know Williams/Shaw/Young is making that run and screwing at them if they don’t.. But instead he continues to make stupid decisions. Man City at home last season.. completely ruined any counter attack with poor selections of passing. Love him as a player but he really does need programming on what to do on the pitch.

Fred again.. all he needed was more game time he did well when he came in at this stage last season then was banished. He only started this season because we had no one else. It’s more of Ole falling on him instead of some master plan of development. Nothing wrong with that.. that’s how we got Rashford I’m just not going to give him credit for it.
 

ash_86

Full Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2013
Messages
5,525
His finishing is not the part of the game that’s been concerning and he still finishes like he did 24 months ago, I don’t see anything different in his style he is still instinctive. What he severely lacks is a football brain.. and he’s yet to improve on that. Against Wolves was probably the most recent explain. We was on the attack on the left hand side with Williams making a perfect run on the outside of him.. instead of waiting to give that ball he cuts inside into traffic and loses possession trying to play the eye of a needle pass.

The way we play these attacking plans should happen every game.. he should already know Williams/Shaw/Young is making that run and screwing at them if they don’t.. But instead he continues to make stupid decisions. Man City at home last season.. completely ruined any counter attack with poor selections of passing. Love him as a player but he really does need programming on what to do on the pitch.

Fred again.. all he needed was more game time he did well when he came in at this stage last season then was banished. He only started this season because we had no one else. It’s more of Ole falling on him instead of some master plan of development. Nothing wrong with that.. that’s how we got Rashford I’m just not going to give him credit for it.
Decision making comes with age. Watch Jesus at Man City who's of Rashford's age . He messes up a lot of easy passes and goes for the extraordinary when an easy option was waiting in front of goal. Sterling was also the same probably a year or two back. He used to do too much by himself and spoof the shot at the end. These players are being trained by the best in the game and still you can see them do the same thing you see Rashford do. It's a learning curve and that's how young players progresses, by making mistakes. Rashford decision making has severely improved this season than previous ones. Even last match against Norwich , he released Brandon Williams that led to the penalty call (). You also don't see him run into a blind ally anymore like he used to do a season or two back.

It's not that simple to say Fred just needed game time. Fred of last season was a major failure an utter waste of 50m pounds. If the manager had no intention of playing him, he would have brought in some other midfielder atleast as a backup if things didn't work out. IMO Ole saw something in Fred and he gave him an important Role to play in the team. Now all our attacks flow through him all of a sudden. Credit has to be given where its due. We can't just keep exchanging phrases like "Scott and Fred are playing well because they was given time" . There was a clear plan for Scott and Fred and what's exactly wanted out of them. They are executing it to a Tee
 

He'sRaldo

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2019
Messages
975
I agree, certain coaches have systems that make players better than their skill should allow, Klopp is the master of this. His teams have had players like Mkhitaryan, Henderson and Kagawa to name a few as key players in title and cup winning teams. Bielsa is absolutely that type of coach as well, from what I remember of that Bilbao team and his current Leeds team, I would add though that Phillips does seem very highly thought of and he does look the part as well. There are certainly worse players to be linked with.
A bit pedantic, but Mkhitaryan was Tuchel's system player, not Klopp.
 

Mainoldo

Full Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2004
Messages
14,331
Decision making comes with age. Watch Jesus at Man City who's of Rashford's age . He messes up a lot of easy passes and goes for the extraordinary when an easy option was waiting in front of goal. Sterling was also the same probably a year or two back. He used to do too much by himself and spoof the shot at the end. These players are being trained by the best in the game and still you can see them do the same thing you see Rashford do. It's a learning curve and that's how young players progresses, by making mistakes. Rashford decision making has severely improved this season than previous ones. Even last match against Norwich , he released Brandon Williams that led to the penalty call (). You also don't see him run into a blind ally anymore like he used to do a season or two back.

It's not that simple to say Fred just needed game time. Fred of last season was a major failure an utter waste of 50m pounds. If the manager had no intention of playing him, he would have brought in some other midfielder atleast as a backup if things didn't work out. IMO Ole saw something in Fred and he gave him an important Role to play in the team. Now all our attacks flow through him all of a sudden. Credit has to be given where its due. We can't just keep exchanging phrases like "Scott and Fred are playing well because they was given time" . There was a clear plan for Scott and Fred and what's exactly wanted out of them. They are executing it to a Tee
I appreciate your post and I’m not going to deny players have improved and are having good seasons. But with my own eyes I can see that these players aren’t getting the best Coaching and besides counter attacking there is no style to our play.

As for my point on Phillips he plays within a well oil tactician who like LVG requires players to play in a certain way. This also means what looks like a good footballer can be over inflated based on the system they are in. However there are plenty of examples of this with Klopp’s Dortmund players; probably his Liverpool players and how Pep coaches too. You mentioned Sterling and yes he might have got better with age but it’s not a coincidence he performed better under Rodger and Pep. It’s not by accident. They coach well.