fecking horrendous on that 2nd goal. Not sure what he was thinking with that wee dinked pass. After 2 very good games as well
23
5.7
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 15
- Clean sheets
- 4
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 1
- Yellow cards
- 7
bosnian_red
Worst scout to ever exist
Horror show today, but that'll happen if you get played out of position regularly. He's capable of being excellent at CB but he's not a natural at it so he'll have a bad day occasionally.
Stadjer
Full Member
He had a bad game but to claim he cant play LCB is a bit stupid. He had quite a few of good games at LCB last season and just a few days ago he had one. He just looked off today like he wasnt focused at times.
Rossa
Full Member
He lacks intensity. Always has. It’s also always been a concern with him.Also seemed to forget as CB he should be sweeping and a couple of times nearly let the ball run out or leave it to someone else. He was petulant in his duels and almost got a dumb yellow card kicking the ball away, luckily he kicked it to Bruno.
One to forget.
Doracle
Full Member
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2017
- Messages
- 3,030
Agree completely with this. He’s an extremely talented footballer but judging him against the standards of a top CB is unfair. He’s done very well playing there overall but he probably still hasn’t actually totalled 20 games there in his entire career!Horror show today, but that'll happen if you get played out of position regularly. He's capable of being excellent at CB but he's not a natural at it so he'll have a bad day occasionally.
Eric really needs to build whatever bridge he can with Varane and try the Varane-Maguire partnership. There’s no reason at all why their attributes can’t work together. Shaw back in his LB slot also massively improves us on that side.
acnumber9
Full Member
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2006
- Messages
- 22,299
Pulled his leg away from the cross for the first too. More concerned about maybe scoring an own goal than actually trying to stop the cross.fecking horrendous on that 2nd goal. Not sure what he was thinking with that wee dinked pass. After 2 very good games as well
RonaldoVII
Full Member
He was poor but he gets an easy ride as he's a LB and it's on the manager playing him there and allowing the inept Reguilon to play his position.
gaffs
Full Member
He is not playing Shaw at CB because he wants to start Reguilon. It is because he wants a left footed player in the CB slot because of the “passing angles”.He was poor but he gets an easy ride as he's a LB and it's on the manager playing him there and allowing the inept Reguilon to play his position.
This manager is a clown. A good game or two at CB an he thinks Shaw is the answer. Would rather play Shaw at CB because of his left foot that play an actual center back like Varane.
tentan
Poor man's poster.
- Joined
- Oct 5, 2013
- Messages
- 4,597
Average player at best.
Jezpeza
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 20, 2018
- Messages
- 2,058
Another player with questionable desire, injury record and consistency. Has seen off several managers.
Needs to be one of the first culled imho.
Needs to be one of the first culled imho.
Frank Grimes
Full Member
I only speak words of wisdom. Please end this Shaw cb nonsense.Ten Hag is weakening 2 positions by not playing him as a full back. Nonsensical.
berbasloth4
Full Member
He can’t be playing centre back beside any body but varane. Varane obviously talks to him and directs him so he could get away with it.
it’s terrible when we are taking our best crosser out of the game to play centre back
it’s terrible when we are taking our best crosser out of the game to play centre back
utdalltheway
Sexy Beast
Why are you quoting yourself?I only speak words of wisdom. Please end this Shaw cb nonsense.
Bondi77
Full Member
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2019
- Messages
- 7,368
How many games has he had since coming back from injury??
Jesus wept!
Jesus wept!
ti vu
Full Member
- Joined
- Jun 16, 2015
- Messages
- 12,799
5How many games has he had since coming back from injury??
Jesus wept!
Everton Galatasaray Newcastle Chelsea Bournemouth
Bondi77
Full Member
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2019
- Messages
- 7,368
Exactly.....he was out for quite a while so should have even eased back in and alternated with Sicknote until he was back up to speed.5
Everton Galatasaray Newcastle Chelsea Bournemouth
Woziak
Full Member
- Joined
- May 8, 2018
- Messages
- 3,738
Don’t agree but needs serious pressure, United should buy Theo Hernandez or Alphonso Davies, then he becomes an excellent back up option.Another player with questionable desire, injury record and consistency. Has seen off several managers.
Needs to be one of the first culled imho.
Red00012
Full Member
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2018
- Messages
- 12,384
get him on the left where he can influence the game .Ten Hag needs to admit he’s wrong and stick Varane with Maguire . Some posters on here have forgotten that flick to Fernandes v Galatasaray already .
Aint gota Kalou
Full Member
- Joined
- Sep 22, 2010
- Messages
- 3,318
I didn't see the game but only the highlights disclaimer. All of his errors were due to his slackness on the ball and lazy covering runs. He has it in him to have these games at left back too.
I honestly don't think it's down to position, he is generally very good at CB.
I honestly don't think it's down to position, he is generally very good at CB.
Man Utd 0:1 Bayern Munich
KranjskaKlobasa
Full Member
Subbed due to a knock / injury?
MyOnlySolskjaer
Creator of Player Performance threads
A proper club would have signed a starting LB 5 years ago, yet we're still persisting with the Luke Shaw experiment hoping he never gets injured.
Mourinho was right.
Mourinho was right.
Jezpeza
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 20, 2018
- Messages
- 2,058
Mourinho called him, Martial and Pogba years ago. Took us forever to see it and two still here for gods sakeA proper club would have signed a starting LB 5 years ago, yet we're still persisting with the Luke Shaw experiment hoping he never gets injured.
Mourinho was right.
FrankDrebin
Don't call me Shirley
The 'Mourinho was right brigade' popping out of the fecking cupboards.
- Joined
- Apr 27, 2022
- Messages
- 1,259
Shaw is soft as cheese, any sign of a tough game and he goes missing. The lack of speed is now apparent it is simply get him fit and sell.Mourinho called him, Martial and Pogba years ago. Took us forever to see it and two still here for gods sake
Rossa
Full Member
Yeah, he looked very slow tonight. Admittedly, Coman is very quick, but Shaw was equally slow to run and respond.Shaw is soft as cheese, any sign of a tough game and he goes missing. The lack of speed is now apparent it is simply get him fit and sell.
Marwood
Full Member
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2021
- Messages
- 4,366
Just looking at him, his build, the way he moves, he's not got it in him to be a fullback anymore. He looks 35. As soon as he has to go 100% you're thinking here comes the injury.
A real stark contrast to a few of the Bayern players gliding about the place.
A real stark contrast to a few of the Bayern players gliding about the place.
Jezpeza
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 20, 2018
- Messages
- 2,058
For me, him, lindelof, mctominay, martial and rashford are the common demoninators for the last few managers - all need to go if it is ‘the players’Shaw is soft as cheese, any sign of a tough game and he goes missing. The lack of speed is now apparent it is simply get him fit and sell.
Alemar
Full Member
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2017
- Messages
- 7,634
He performed poorly, in fact. Very slow, stopped going forward, slow getting back, always leaving the flank free.Subbed due to a knock / injury?
Judas
Open to offers
Totally unreliable, and massively overhyped on here, especially when he's not playing, which is often. He's been average for us more than he's been brilliant, even if when he's on form he's fantastic, overall, he can't be depended on.
bosnian_red
Worst scout to ever exist
Spends 3 months out with a muscle injury, oh I know, let's start him in all 6 of the games that we have in the next 17 days. Great idea!!! Genius management.
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2023
- Messages
- 77
100% agreeFor me, him, lindelof, mctominay, martial and rashford are the common demoninators for the last few managers - all need to go if it is ‘the players’
Cloud7
Full Member
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2016
- Messages
- 12,883
Always good for an injury is Luke. Fantastic player when he’s fit and in form but it always feels like the next injury is never too far away. Not exactly someone we can rely on in that regard.
Sunny Jim
Full Member
100% thisSpends 3 months out with a muscle injury, oh I know, let's start him in all 6 of the games that we have in the next 17 days. Great idea!!! Genius management.
AngliaRed
Full Member
Dont forget Dalot.100% agree
DickDastardly
New Member
Another one not living up to the potential.
Again us not being ruthless enough, we've been dragging on with Luke for years now, his injury time keeps pilling on, his perfomances keep getting worse....
There are left backs in the world you know.
Spurs just landed Udogie for peanuts.
You just have to look.
Again us not being ruthless enough, we've been dragging on with Luke for years now, his injury time keeps pilling on, his perfomances keep getting worse....
There are left backs in the world you know.
Spurs just landed Udogie for peanuts.
You just have to look.
Rossa
Full Member
Is he really fantastic? He's had some really good spells, but he has never consistently been fantastic for us. Defensively, even at his very best he causes concerns because of his positioning, reading of the game and poor one on one defending. His engine has also been a concern overall, and his injury record has been atrocious. Fantastic he is not. Now he's also looking slower than before.Always good for an injury is Luke. Fantastic player when he’s fit and in form but it always feels like the next injury is never too far away. Not exactly someone we can rely on in that regard.
Skills
Snitch
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2012
- Messages
- 42,125
So apparently, he was a massive miss when he was injured. But now he's back, apparently he was never that good and one of our problems all along.
redNATION
Full Member
Don’t forget Bruno and Dalot, these guys have had enough chances and failed to deliver, need a complete overhaul despite spending 1bn+ since fergie leftFor me, him, lindelof, mctominay, martial and rashford are the common demoninators for the last few managers - all need to go if it is ‘the players’