I’d sell Shaw, never was overly excited watching him, he does a lot of decent stuff but doesn’t contribute nearly enough in the way of attacking numbers, never makes it to the byline and rarely delivers a decent cross.
On the defensive side he always caught out of position, fails to make the ground up when caught on the counter, always fouling because lack of speed and how many times he breaks the offside trap.
Thoroughly average defender and will never propel us to the dizzy heights, call me petty but I think it’s a lot to do with his body shape, modern full backs are like beanpoles and relentlessly are up and down the pitch without hardly a bead of sweat, just don’t see it with Shaw. Not to be one of the highest paid in the world anyway.