Manager Poll

Who do you want to manage Manchester United next year ?

  • Total voters
    1,220
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
I was torn between Mourinho and Zidane. I thought someone might think i was being serious if i picked Mourinho so went for Zidane
 
What we think is going to happen or what we want to?

Edit: Thanks for the clarification
 
Last edited:
Sticking Ten Hag from that list. The single one proven younger manager is Alonso but he is unrealistic. I’d love Zidane but he has no interest.

McKenna I like think this squad eats him alive.
 
Give me De Zerbi. Shown what he can do with an inferior squad against the best teams from a performance level. Matching and beating Liverpool, City, Arsenal, Utd, Spurs and Chelsea in the last 18 months

If not, then Postecoglu. Seems like a serious and scary man willing to win in the long term. Also has Spurs post-Kane playing great football dominating the ball against City.

Just don’t get the McKenna shouts. He hasn’t managed in a top flight division yet. It’s like getting Kompany from Burnley last season.
 
Not sure why unattainable names are on there, it dilutes the poll. Alonso just signed a new contract for Leverkusen
 
Picked ten Hag, because I don't mind sticking with him, but there some good options out there if we decide to part ways with him
 
I would have gone for Tuchel, but i think McKenna can be able to allow us to build slowly while we clear the squad
 
I've gone for Tuchel, but don't have a big preference amongst a few of them as I don't think there's a stand out candidate in what's a pretty uninspiring bunch of options really.

All the experienced ones (as regards managing big clubs) with a decent CV seem to be on their way down and so questions over their current level. And all the others come with various degrees of risk / inexperience.

Alonso would have been my choice but I see that as completely unrealistic so didn't bother wasting a vote on it. I'd most love to see McKenna succeed here but think he'd probably be the biggest gamble, only having two years of senior management and no experiences of top flight management. So I think it's probably too huge a leap at this early stage of his career.

I've never warmed to Thomas Frank, always thought he comes across as an annoying prick. So in that group of mid level PL experience, I'd put him last below the likes of Potter and De Zerbi. And Southgate and Mourinho would be down there with Frank as ones I definitely don't want.
 
I voted for Alonso obviously, but it's not realistic is it?

McKenna is my realistic choice since I don't know enough about Amorim. Tuchel seems like a chaotic guy, but I wouldn't hate it.

Frank, Mourinho or Southgate would be disastrous. Lukewarm when it comes to Pochettino, Potter and De Zerbi.
 
I couldn't see the result without voting so gave Southgate one. ;)

Seriously though I think Tuchel is the best manager on the list but I would be wary of his record of self destructing at clubs and the risk of doing that for short term success over long term success and stability of the club.
 
From that list of options, Xabi Alonso, surely? He is the outstanding managerial candidate when you consider leadership and gravitas, winning mentality, communication skills, tactical knowledge, age profile and so forth. But he is not a realistic option, unfortunately; and neither is Zinédine Zidane, if certain reports are to be believed.

Considering some of the more realistic options out there, in order of preference...
  • Thiago Motta: have voted for him, could be a real candidate given the Jean-Claude Blanc link, in a project oriented approach where he progresses along with the squad to emerge as a top manager. He is not a Xabi Alonso caliber of manager in terms of title-winning accomplishments, as of right now — but, they have a lot in common: up-and-coming profile as coaches, accomplished ex-players who are accustomed to the pressures and rigors associated with major clubs (Barcelona, Internazionale and Paris Saint-Germain for Thiago), played in some of the biggest, most high-profile matches (Champions League and European Championship final for Thiago), trained under a multitude of great managers (Ancelotti, Mourinho, van Gaal, Gasperini, Conte et cetera for Thiago), classy and likeable individuals who command respect from all and sundry, former holding midfielders who were renowned for their intelligence and decision-making. Bologna (impressive history but chronic underachievers in the modern era) have definitely trended in the right direction and defied certain odds when you consider the starting point (from 13th in Serie A to 9th and now 3rd (their highest position in almost 60 years)) and their financial capabilities (vis-à-vis clubs like Lazio and Napoli, let alone heavyweights like Juventus and Internazionale).
2016: 42 points, goal difference of -12.
2017: 41 points, goal difference of -18.
2018: 39 points, goal difference of -12.
2019: 44 points, goal difference of -8.
2020: 47 points, goal difference of -13.
2021: 41 points, goal difference of -14.
2022: 46 points, goal difference of -11.
2023 (Thiago's first season): 54 points, goal difference of +4.
2024 (Thiago's second season): 67 points with 2 games to go, goal difference of +24.
  • Thomas Tuchel: by no means an an ideal candidate and you might argue that he is regressing with time, but he's undoubtedly one of the best, most meticulous and versatile coaches around — and INEOS is specifically looking for someone who is going to be satisfied with the responsibilities and authority of a Head Coach (with big-picture decision-making being handled by the Chief Executive, Sporting Director and Technical Director). Might not prove to be the ultimate solution, but he could organize a competitive and well-drilled unit in the short to medium term (that itself would represent a leap forward).
The likes of Sebastian Hoeneß and Kieran McKenna are also exciting options. But the former wants to further his development at Stuttgart, and it's probably a bit too soon to be appointing the latter (staying at Ipswich or joining a Top 10-ish Premier League team would be better for his progression at this moment in time, there's no need to hurry when he is just 38 years old).
 
None of Tuchel, Motta, Alonso or Pochettino look much like they will be available. Zidane probably would not be interested. That leaves Amorim, Potter, Southgate, Frank, McKenna, De Zerbi, Mourinho (:lol:) and Ten Hag. From that list, I'd probably give Amorim a go. 2nd choice would be De Zerbi. I'd probably keep Ten Hag over giving it to Potter, Southgate, McKenna or Frank.
 
I don't understand people voting for McKenna. He's started his managerial journey yesterday. Let him prove himself. We don't need a rookie, we need an experienced set of hands.

Ancelloti would be perfect, but he's not leaving RM, he's building a CL winning side there. Tuchel seems to be the next "big name" flavour of the month but the man failed to win the bundesliga with Bayern and Harry Kane.
 
I suppose this poll should stop the polls that pit one manager up against another :wenger: :wenger:
 
Its been a tough season. ETH has made mistakes in not playing Amad and Arabat a lot more. Hopefully he sees sticking with big names who are out of form is futile. I have slated him at times. At the same time hes done things i admire, getting rid of Ronaldo, not standing for Sanchos laziness.

The injuries have been horrendous. Worst in my life time and ive been a Red since the 60,s. What would the season have looked like with a defence of Dalot Varane Martinez Shaw most games?

We have been changing the manager regularly since SAF retired, it hasnt worked.

So we sack ETH take Tuchel, repeat the cycle, it doesnt work we sack Tuchel and wish we had stuck with ETH? Or we just keep hiring and firing for another 10 years.

Im saying give ETH another season mainly because my brain keeps telling me, in todays climate Fergie would have been sacked after 3 years. The fans were calling loudly for Fergie to be sacked but the club stuck with him and we had a very long golden era And he became a legend held up with Matt Busby.
 
Infra-red said:
None of Tuchel, Motta, Alonso or Pochettino look much like they will be available. Zidane probably would not be interested. That leaves Amorim, Potter, Southgate, Frank, McKenna, De Zerbi, Mourinho (:lol:) and Ten Hag. From that list, I'd probably give Amorim a go. 2nd choice would be De Zerbi. I'd probably keep Ten Hag over giving it to Potter, Southgate, McKenna or Frank.
Click to expand...
Same reasoning here. The dream would be McKenna but it comes too early as we are not a safe environment right now. It would be throwing him into a shark pool. That's why Tuchel next would be the best solution for me - he is able to handle the requirements and get results right away and does not tend to stay more than 2 seasons anyway, and then McKenna (if he confirms his promise until then) after that once the squad has been canalized by the new executives and Tuchel's coaching.
Now it sounds like Tuchel will stay (but honestly who knows with the circus that has been Bayern's managerial dealings..) and there is no obvious other short term solution, so yes, Amorim sounds like someone who could be a good hire.

Alonso should not be in the poll as he's not available.
 
As others have said, poll should be in realms of reality; I'm guilty of going for the make believe option myself, which obscures the point of the poll as I haven't even had to think about the other - realistic - options and their particular pros and cons.
 
We all want Alonso here but let's be honest, there's more chance of Fergie coming back.
 
Sticking with ETH.
Zidane isn't coming and Alonso is staying. No stand outs for me.
 
I see there's a change vote option. That's good, as I went for Tuchel - just because I think he's by far the best of the 'experience with big clubs' options that's available, and I'm not sure if any of the up and coming ones are more worth a gamble at this stage?

But with reports that Bayern and the players want Tuchel to stay - which further supports why I voted for him in the first place really - then I may need to change my vote soon for one of the up and coming managers. But not sure which at this stage.
 
Scandi Red said:
I voted for Alonso obviously, but it's not realistic is it?

McKenna is my realistic choice since I don't know enough about Amorim. Tuchel seems like a chaotic guy, but I wouldn't hate it.

Frank, Mourinho or Southgate would be disastrous. Lukewarm when it comes to Pochettino, Potter and De Zerbi.
Click to expand...

Same.
 
Bertie Wooster said:
I see there's a change vote option. That's good, as I went for Tuchel - just because I think he's by far the best of the 'experience with big clubs' options that's available, and I'm not sure if any of the up and coming ones are more worth a gamble at this stage?

But with reports that Bayern and the players want Tuchel to stay - which further supports why I voted for him in the first place really - then I may need to change my vote soon for one of the up and coming managers. But not sure which at this stage.
Click to expand...
Yep - with me it's the other way around, I did not vote for Tuchel as right now it seems he will not become available after all. But if the Bayern clown show takes another farcical turn I will change my vote to go for him. Since the question is about next season, not mid to long term.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.