lets leave pulisic out of it. that one is more a personal preference based on the little i've seen. I think you'd be hard pressed to find a non united fan that rates rashford above the other four. Reus, sterling and sane if you look at the past couple seasons massively outperform rashford. 4 champion leagues aint bad for a golfer.
Reus doesn't even play on the wing and hasn't for years, he plays as a false 9 or in behind and even then, he has a weaker goal to minute ratio than Rashford this season. I doubt you have even watched Reus in the last 3 years if you count him as a winger and are just pulling names out of your arse.
Bale you're having a laugh, he has played feck all football in these last two years and has an average of a goal every 420 minutes this season. He has 4 CLs but If you want to talk about past acheivements why don't we drop Bruno and get Rooney seeing as he has a CL and is England's top scorer? Shall we also get Sanchez back? Every criticism you levelled at Rashford applies to Bale and while Rashford hasn't hit the peak Bale did for Spurs, that was an absolute age ago and Bale is not that player any more.
Hazard this season has scored 1 goal. That's a goal every 1320 minutes. Hazard played great last season so it's fair to say he is just having a bad season at a new club and has been struggling with injuries. It's also worth noting that during his best season for Chelsea, he scored 21 goals with 5 penalties, Rashford is going to beat that this season.
Pulisic was benched by an 18 year old Sancho and Thorgan Hazard - imagine being a United fan and actually making a case for Pulisic being better than Rashford currently?
Mahrez and Sterling have been decent but I think Rashford has outperformed them both this season while playing for a struggling team.
Mane, Salah, Mbappe and Neymar are better than Rashford, fair enough but the rest are at the very best debatable.
You say Rashford has scored a lot of penalties but he won 4 of them this season so completely discounting them doesn't tell the whole story. He hasn't played great since he's been back but he's been out for 5 months before that he was our player of the season and was scoring important goals for us when we were threadbare.
remove those two words and how much weaker is your point?
Rashford is doing plenty of things right. He's a good football player just not on the level of the other 5 mentioned in the thread opener imo.
Rashford is also younger than those players and this is his breakout season where he has become an undisputed starter - what is the point in comparing his previous seasons when he was a youngster in and out the team with players who are in their prime and completely discounting the current one? What was Salah, Mane and Mahrez doing at 22 years old? Sterling and Sane had their breakout seasons at the same age and that was for a record breaking Man City side yet Rashford will end up with more goals this season than they did at his age.