Sigma
Full Member
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2015
- Messages
- 10,428
After I heard about all the outrage I watched the advert just now. No idea why everyone is outraged about it.
Simple case of them thinking their masculinity is being attacked.After I heard about all the outrage I watched the advert just now. No idea why everyone is outraged about it.
It's funny how the men who like to proclaim themselves as masculine usually seem to be the most fragile and easily offended.Simple case of them thinking their masculinity is being attacked.
Yes, surely the only reason someone might have for ridiculing a multi-national corporation's over the top simplistic attempt to score some goodwill points by advertisement based virtue signalling must be that they feel their masculinity is attackedSimple case of them thinking their masculinity is being attacked.
On the first page you have a tweet from Piers Morgan complaining about the global assault on masculinity and it seems to be a fairly common response. I don’t think the posters were saying that anyone who doesn’t like the advert feels their masculinity is being attacked, but rather those ‘outraged’ by it.Yes, surely the only reason someone might have for ridiculing a multi-national corporation's over the top simplistic attempt to score some goodwill points by advertisement based virtue signalling must be that they feel their masculinity is attacked
It’s a fundamental reason, not the only reason. Unless you want to enlighten me about why some people would spend hours trying to criticize an ad as it had severely affected them?Yes, surely the only reason someone might have for ridiculing a multi-national corporation's over the top simplistic attempt to score some goodwill points by advertisement based virtue signalling must be that they feel their masculinity is attacked
Humans are fragile sensitive creatures and it has been known for ages.It's funny how the men who like to proclaim themselves as masculine usually seem to be the most fragile and easily offended.
Because it's a terrible ad worthy of lengthy ridicule and excessive criticism.It’s a fundamental reason, not the only reason. Unless you want to enlighten me about why some people would spend hours trying to criticize an ad as it had severely affected them?
Yet attitudes change over time and even adverts saying the right thing can play a small part in that even if its intension is really just to sell razors.Some of us live in the real world & realize that ads like Gillette ain't gonna change things. Doesn't make us bad people though. Just a bit more realistic than others who want see the world as they'd like it to be.
Maccas should do that to reduce the amount of fast food rubbish in the streets.Because it's a terrible ad worthy of lengthy ridicule and excessive criticism.
I'm sure there are some who are fearful of their masculinity, but this narrative about it being the only reason people dislike it is wrong.
I would react the same way to a hypothetical moralistic McDonalds commercial telling me not to litter or something.
"Change things" is meaningless. Imagine that 0.1% of men who watched this will change their attitude. Wouldn't it be worth it? It would "change things" for many men and women.Some of us live in the real world & realize that ads like Gillette ain't gonna change things. Doesn't make us bad people though. Just a bit more realistic than others who want see the world as they'd like it to be.
I can understand people not liking the ad, I thought it was pretty clumsily done. But if someone spents a significant amount of time ridiculing it and 'excessively' criticising the advert, then at that point I think it's less to do with them thinking it's a bad advert and more with them having a problem with the message.Because it's a terrible ad worthy of lengthy ridicule and excessive criticism.
I'm sure there are some who are fearful of their masculinity, but this narrative about it being the only reason people dislike it is wrong.
I would react the same way to a hypothetical moralistic McDonalds commercial telling me not to litter or something.
You just sound like a bitter cynic if that’s really your reasoning. The ad being bad or not is debatable hence this thread. For me, it’s a positive message that imhas to he said one way or another and the fact that it got people talking about Gillette products means it accomplished one of it’s main objectives. However, because of the outrage, I stand by my statement that fragile masculinity is a findamental reason. I also never said it was the only reason. You said that.Because it's a terrible ad worthy of lengthy ridicule and excessive criticism.
I'm sure there are some who are fearful of their masculinity, but this narrative about it being the only reason people dislike it is wrong.
I would react the same way to a hypothetical moralistic McDonalds commercial telling me not to litter or something.
YepIt is, right? Don't you think that activism maybe helped this progression along?
Main reason to boycott them would be that they somehow managed to trick the world into believing that disposable razors are somehow better than safety razors.The advert is fine. I don't necessarily agree with everything in the advert. There is certainly no reason to take offense or boycott Gillette products in my opinion.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
I'd say she would too.Gillette are good at this "guaranteed to start an online flame war" type of advertizing. To everyone's huge surprize, this also created a giant dungstorm.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
I like how many people wrap their ugh fat slag comments in a "concerned for her heallth" statement.
I don't think it's Gillette's job to promote health, just well shaven bodies. If it makes women want to buy their products then good for them. People will be fat and will get fat regardless of Gillette and Gillette's products have no bearing on weight (unless you eat the shaving cream I suppose).Gillette are good at this "guaranteed to start an online flame war" type of advertizing. To everyone's huge surprize, this also created a giant dungstorm.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
I like how many people wrap their ugh fat slag comments in a "concerned for her heallth" statement.
Similar to all the overweight people claiming that the Protein World advert that got removed from the london underground promoted an unhealthy body image.Gillette are good at this "guaranteed to start an online flame war" type of advertizing. To everyone's huge surprize, this also created a giant dungstorm.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
I like how many people wrap their ugh fat slag comments in a "concerned for her heallth" statement.
I like the hypocrisy of it all. The people screaming this woman is beautiful are the same people who scream bloody murder when a size 0 girl is being used. Obviously beautiful isn't objective but neither anorexia nor morbid obesity is beautiful.Similar to all the overweight people claiming that the Protein World advert that got removed from the london underground promoted an unhealthy body image.
If a Gillette razor can shave that, it can shave anything.Gillette are good at this "guaranteed to start an online flame war" type of advertizing. To everyone's huge surprize, this also created a giant dungstorm.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
I like how many people wrap their ugh fat slag comments in a "concerned for her heallth" statement.