Withnail
Full Member
You can't read much into an FA Cup win. Just ask LVG.By the FA Cup they won against Tuchel's Chelsea. I know, I know fluke and all that and sure they are in a bit of crisis I don't follow them around much (besides watching some games), but maybe the Leicester thing run its course and it's time for a change for the better of Rodgers and/or Leicester.
Leicester is a great club and all but they have a ceiling which is a lot lower than Man United
He is huge upgrade compared to Ole, his teams play great football, has a clear style of play, uses academy players, is "PL proven" and he just won the FA cup with freaking Leicester.
The most telling thing about a manager most of the times is the style of football he implements and how quickly, Rodgers had the foxes playing great stuff within 2-3 months since joining from Celtic. On the contrary Ole still hasn't got a style of play even after 3 years of patience, excuses, United DNA and shit like that.
My question is, why so much hatred for BR?
Being better than the current manager isn't a good enough reason to get the job. He would be a thoroughly underwhelming appointment.
Why is 'PL proven' a criteria? Klopp/Pep/Tuchel/Conte weren't 'PL proven' when they came in and have done alright so it doesn't seem like that should be a requirement.
His clear style of play has defensive flaws which he's never shown any signs of fixing. You don't win the PL without a mean defence and defensive organisation has never been his strong suit.
As for hatred, he's a Liverpool cast off for starters. He wasn't deemed a good enough manager for their title ambitions and a few years later he's suddenly a world-beater? Also, Utd fans regularly did and still do take the piss out of him for his twatishness so I don't think he'd ever get a fair crack of the whip here even if he was good enough.
EDIT: He also has a dodgy enough record on transfers over the years. (Leicester already had a good structure in place and were making excellent signings before he came in so I don't think he can take credit for much on that side of things)