Sweet feck, do you really think your using stats objectively, comparing Socrates in Brazil to Riva in Serie A?
You started by making subjective claims as if they were objective. Then you ignored my entire point about how teams score goals and just trying to reduce things to silly comparisons that are irrelevant. You believe Riva is a better goalscorer than Socrates. I disagree with that completely. The stats can be twisted to either support either of our arguments or conclude there isn't much between them. I was trying to be fair and just compromise and say there isn't much between them.
If you want to keep insisting that Riva is better goalscorer in your tactic than Socrates is in mine then we can agree to disagree and leave it with the voters.
Still absolutely nothing on the opposition's defensive tactics I see.
I've talked about defense in every post including my OP. If you make a specific argument I disagree with I can counter it. For instance you claimed that Heynckes is going to be often attacking from your wide right, in that case Maldini is going to shut him down. You also implied Jansen and Maicon might attack that side as well. In which depending on scenario Vidal and Ribery would be marking/tracking them. Ultimately I see you as completely impotent on that side. Maldini with the help of Vidal and Ribery tracking back is not going to allow much if anything for you.
That compares very favorably to the other side where you don't have a wide forward (unless you are complaining Riva is playing wide as well). Marcelo, while a good attacker, is not the best defender and will have a very difficult time defending against Conti's speed, dribbling and passing. But then you said Marcelo would be marking Nelinho and van Hanegem would be on Conti?
So if Marcelo is Nelinho, you are expecting van Hanegem whose major weakness is being very slow and lacking agility to mark Conti whose main strengths are dribbling, guile and speed? I'll take that trade-off all game as it favors Cruyff-Socrates in the end by creating the space they can ruthlessly exploit.
Really those two points haven't been answered. Cruyff, the best player on the pitch can't really be stopped by your defenders. Meanwhile the fact Maldini can shut down Heynckes/LW gives my defense the advantage it needs.