If we dont buy a dm then we will resort to the ridiculous musical chairs we had last season with mou playing anyone who can tackle there. The big gap between midfield and defence will remain exploited, our attacking minded players will have to play deeper and we will struggle to score goals.
Im not too go bothered about our creative spark tbh. Mkhitaryan had always struggle in his first season + Both martial and rashford suffered from a second season syndrome. However we need a dm. Its nearly as important as us signing lukaku
Yeah, well i have been harping on about having an alternative to Carrick for years. I feel we lack aggression and presence in our midfield at times, and have done for a long time, since Keane really. Carrick is great at what he does and i'm not knocking him, but sometimes i feel having an aggressive energetic physical presence is also needed at times. Fletcher managed to provide this for a while, and more recently Fellaini has been the one who has added some much needed presence and physicality. But both lacked/lack the technical skills to ever be top drawer.
I was gutted to miss out on Kante, he looked like just what we needed. Yet missing out on Keita would gut me even more. He is the type of dynamic multi-attributed player who can fulfill a variety of midfield roles, and because he is so varied and effective in his overall contribution, you cannot really restrict his skill-set to only one position. He is not a specialist DM, but i have little doubt he could be extremely effective in such a role whenever needed. But again, in games where a DM skill-set is less required, he can easily transition to contribute positively in more advanced areas. So much variety and a wealth of differing options emerge from having a player like that.
That's what we should be looking for imo. When you have someone who can carry/drive/dribble the ball beyond the midfield and into advanced areas, the forwards are then obliged to group much closer together in and around the box, which then puts the defence under far more pressure and thus provides many more opportunities to score. A shield won't give us that, so while he will free up Pogba, the responsibility will then fall on Pogba to provide much of our general creativity. But buying Perisic -instead of a DM- would allow us to expect a regular source of reliable service to the strikers. Adding some much needed variety to our attacking options, and helping spread out the creative responsibilities.
So, in my view we would benefit much more from having Keita in our midfield than a winger, yet i feel we would benefit more from having a direct and reliable winger than giving Pogba an occasionally required safety net.